Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Cleansweep17]

Blues have NEVER won a final interstate minnows, we've won tonnes of them, lost count

Good luck

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

youve had them the last 5 years mostly and cant manage better than 8th lol

Where'd we finish last year? Also TDK has only just started to break out this year. He's got some more gears to go next

 

[HeathySure]

Where'd we finish last year? Also TDK has only just started to break out this year. He's got some more gears to go next

lol on that logic Young Nicholas is in his 3rd year and had 3 more years before he breaks out, Looks like he will be dragging us to 8 more premierships

 

[CarmenSandiego]

lol on that logic Young Nicholas is in his 3rd year and had 3 more years before he breaks out, Looks like he will be dragging us to 8 more premierships

Does TDK look like a finished product to you? Dude still looks like a skinny baby giraffe out there.

I predict he will still improve. Anyone who’s watched a lot of footy would agree.

 

[HeathySure]

Does TDK look like a finished product to you? Dude still looks like a skinny baby giraffe out there.

I predict he will still improve. Anyone who’s watched a lot of footy would agree.

One day you guys will realise its not about the players its about the system AND players. And as long as your coaching team is asleep at the wheel they will lose the premiership window and be back where they started, and it will be beautiful.

 

[carlton_99]

lol on that logic Young Nicholas is in his 3rd year and had 3 more years before he breaks out, Looks like he will be dragging us to 8 more premierships

Yes because key position players develop at the same rate as midfielders...

 

[HeathySure]

Yes because key position players develop at the same rate as midfielders...

most mids do not peak for 5 years either.
you offended Blues supporters are going to be crying for many years over how over rated Nick is, meanwhile as long as he is around we will be competitive because he is that good. A few free decent free agents is enohgh for us to win another few flags in the next 10 years

 

[carlton_99]

most mids do not peak for 5 years either.
you offended Blues supporters are going to be crying for many years over how over rated Nick is, meanwhile as long as he is around we will be competitive because he is that good. A few free decent free agents is enohgh for us to win another few flags in the next 10 years

Haven't said a negative thing about Daicos so not sure what you are on about. Haven't spoke about Collingwood's premiership chances in the next 10 years either. My comment was regarding key position players developing at a slower rate than mids.

Do you just like being offended?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Pies will be bottom 6 next year no matter what Squibby Nicky is doing. Their list is ancient and in decline

 

[JustaBattler]

most mids do not peak for 5 years either.
you offended Blues supporters are going to be crying for many years over how over rated Nick is, meanwhile as long as he is around we will be competitive because he is that good. A few free decent free agents is enohgh for us to win another few flags in the next 10 years

Welcome to the thread after Fadge 's melty resignation as resident Collingwood leader - you will no doubt make as much sense as he did in his. posttemological ingenuine - as evidence by the above.

 

[dees arent rabble]

This is utterly hilarious from a Dees supporter

*COVID Cup and nothing since

Bloody Carlton peanuts.

Give it up

 

[zeggie]

Bloody Carlton peanuts.

Give it up

Good luck in finals next week! Hope your lads do better than last year!

 

[dees arent rabble]

Good luck in finals next week! Hope your lads do better than last year!

We never got blown away like you peanuts will

 

[Madblue]

One day you guys will realise its not about the players its about the system AND players. And as long as your coaching team is asleep at the wheel they will lose the premiership window and be back where they started, and it will be beautiful.

Sort of like the Pies this season

 

[CarmenSandiego]

One day you guys will realise its not about the players its about the system AND players. And as long as your coaching team is asleep at the wheel they will lose the premiership window and be back where they started, and it will be beautiful.

I don’t think anyone has argued that our coaching needs improving, along with our players. I think it’s naive to think we’ve fired our best shot, given our list age profile.

 

[zeggie]

We never got blown away like you peanuts will

...Ooo self burn. Those are rare. Gotta make finals to get "blown away" lad.

 

[SuperSub17]

FFS if we are s**t what are you ? You finished below us on the ladder and arent playing finals.

You are an irrelevant football club and will be for years to come

A supporter of Carlton (the 17th best performed club this century) bringing out the “irrelevant” card?

Is this real life?

Is this just fantasy?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

A supporter of Carlton (the 17th best performed club this century) bringing out the “irrelevant” card?

Is this real life?

Is this just fantasy?

18th best. Won more spoons than Gold Coast and made the same number of grand finals. Gold Coast have an excuse too being a start up.

 

[Worm4]

A supporter of Carlton (the 17th best performed club this century) bringing out the “irrelevant” card?

Is this real life?

Is this just fantasy?

Oh look, it's Fadge is disguise

 

[SuperSub17]

18th best. Won more spoons than Gold Coast and made the same number of grand finals. Gold Coast have an excuse too being a start up.

Excellent point.

I will update the abacus.

 

[Worm4]

Excellent point.

I will update the abacus.

Welcome back, albeit under a alias account

 

[HeathySure]

Pies will be bottom 6 next year no matter what Squibby Nicky is doing. Their list is ancient and in decline

honestly you have no idea. We lost to the premiership faves by a point and beat Brisbane in the last 2 games when we got our structure back. WE will trade for our needs because we have a smart recruiting and coaching team. I am very comfortable with the fact that we will be top 4 with average luck with injuries, And you will be wrong yet again

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

honestly you have no idea. We lost to the premiership faves by a point and beat Brisbane in the last 2 games when we got our structure back. WE will trade for our needs because we have a smart recruiting and coaching team. I am very comfortable with the fact that we will be top 4 with average luck with injuries, And you will be wrong yet again

Ur 'needs' is some sort of cryogenic chamber that rewinds the aging of about 10 of your players. Sidebottom, Pendles, Crisp, Howe, Cox, Mihocek, Elliot, WHE, Titch... It's a god damn retirement home down at Pieland

Bottom 6 guaranteed

 

[SuperSub17]

Welcome back, albeit under a alias account

I am honestly flattered.

 

[Thrawn]

2-0 to the Pies
Carlton lost more games
Carlton significantly easier draw.
Can't even beat StKilda.

Yep it's a fake Victory.

You couldn't even beat Essendon, lol.