Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[MadMundy]

You know this for a fact ?
Can't say you would know this through your own experiences , because , well , you follow Fremantle

Oh well you can keep us company if we're down there too then can't ya

 

[Joffaboy]

Good to see posters who haven't been here all season join the pile on. Saad unaccountable? Saved us about five goals with his defensive efforts against your lot a fortnight ago,

Cost you the game by leaving Higgins unattended for the final goal noddy.

 

[MadMundy]

Carlton last night:

 

[Robertio]

60-0 is historic stuff, we'll never see that in a final again (unless Carlton get back there one day)

Of course anyone else would have done better

Terrible team selection and management reflected on the field, a full choke from a mentally fragile club

 

[Worm4]

60-0 is historic stuff, we'll never see that in a final again (unless Carlton get back there one day)

Of course anyone else would have done better

Terrible team selection and management reflected on the field, a full choke from a mentally fragile club

So the difference between the Geelong/ Collingwood 2020 final where the pies had kicked 1 solitary for the first half - any better ?

 

[Worm4]

Carlton last night:
View attachment 2104961

This is like Fremantle since inception

 

[carlton_99]

Cost you the game by leaving Higgins unattended for the final goal noddy.

Noddy? Are you four? No one player costs a team any game - Saad was brilliant that game.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

So the difference between the Geelong/ Collingwood 2020 final where the pies had kicked 1 solitary for the first half - any better ?

Look up what happened the week before

 

[Madblue]

This post confirms that you’re indeed, mad.

Look at the ladder

 

[Worm4]

Look up what happened the week before

What's that got to do with collingwoods half time score of 1.0.6 in a final ?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

What's that got to do with collingwoods half time score of 1.0.6 in a final ?

Plenty!! Everything!!! Go on look it up and report back

 

[RCAB]

This is our thread and we won it, your post shows just how delusional some Pie supporters are.

How do you not realise you were worse? Do you want the Carlton football club to stay in this mediocre state indefinitely?

 

[jmac70]

Look at the ladder

Congratulations.
How old were you the last time Carlton won a flag?

 

[Robertio]

How do you not realise you were worse? Do you want the Carlton football club to stay in this mediocre state indefinitely?

I don't care about the footy, i just wanted to win this thread.

 

[Worm4]

Plenty!! Everything!!! Go on look it up and report back

Are you looking for an excuse as to why Collingwood kicked 1 goal in a finals game up to half time , will add their score was 1.1.7 at 3/4 time , and you reckon Carltons performance was way worse ? Cmon mate, own it.

 

[SuperSub17]

Oh so you were just trolling? Got it

Can someone please explain Carlton supporters’ fascination with Fadge’s “16th” prediction, and why it’s been referenced probably a thousand times in this thread?

Like, somehow the fact it was a joke post has gone over their collective heads a thousand times?

The post was a tongue-in-cheek retort made after Collingwood’s 1-3 and Carlton’s 2-0 starts…specifically designed to place Carlton’s two opponents to that stage in 17th and 18th, and the three teams who beat the Pies in 1st, 2nd and 3rd.

This fact hasn’t once dawned on any of you at all, not even a little bit?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Can someone please explain Carlton supporters’ fascination with Fadge’s “16th” prediction, and why it’s been referenced probably a thousand times in this thread?

Like, somehow the fact it was a joke post has gone over their collective heads a thousand times?

The post was a tongue-in-cheek retort made after Collingwood’s 1-3 and Carlton’s 2-0 starts…specifically designed to place Carlton’s two opponents to that stage in 17th and 18th, and the three teams who beat the Pies in 1st, 2nd and 3rd.

This fact hasn’t once dawned on any of you at all, not even a little bit?

This is a banter thread mate, none of us actually care.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Are you looking for an excuse as to why Collingwood kicked 1 goal in a finals game up to half time , will add their score was 1.1.7 at 3/4 time , and you reckon Carltons performance was way worse ? Cmon mate, own it.

Ok I'll spell it out for you

The week before, having finished 8th we travelled to Perth, had to stay indoors for 7 days while they called us Dirty Pies, then went out and beat 5th placed Eagles by 1 point in an incredible final



Blues finished 8th, had a bye, no quarantine and travelled to Brisbane on their own terms, not being called Dirty Blues, went out there and were 0-60 in the worst finals performance ever

 

[RCAB]

You had us coming 16th this year and you want to claim you arent a troll?

I don't think you can safely say Carlton is better than any team right now, other than the bottom 3. So 16th wasn't too far off.

 

[Worm4]

Ok I'll spell it out for you

The week before, having finished 8th we travelled to Perth, had to stay indoors for 7 days while they called us Dirty Pies, then went out and beat 5th placed Eagles by 1 point in an incredible final

View attachment 2104988

Blues finished 8th, had a bye, no quarantine and travelled to Brisbane on their own terms, not being called Dirty Blues, went out there and were 0-60 in the worst finals performance ever

1.1.7 to 3/4 time. That's worse I don't care which way you spin it.

 

[SuperSub17]

This is a banter thread mate, none of us actually care.

I don’t know, a lot of Carlton folk in here seemed to get very upset about it.

It’s all very bizarre.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I don’t know, a lot of Carlton folk in here seemed to get very upset about it.

It’s all very bizarre.

We enjoy the back and forth. If I didn't have Fudgey and Corn to abuse and argue with god knows how I'd relieve my stress!

 

[T2B_]

I'd still take our season over the Wobblers. Yes we started the final itself about as well as the local Auskickers, but you'd take the chance at a final every time. Game was pretty much lost before it started because of some of the most inept decision making and planning I've ever seen at AFL level. Imagine if we actually get our acts together there. Gonna be a shake up of staff needed over the off season. Onwards and upwards

 

[RCAB]

I don't care about the footy, i just wanted to win this thread.

So that's really sad. You're not even hiding that fact you're happy with this mediocrity. I'm just wondering if Carlton next year make finals or finish bottom 4. Your coach after the press conference didn't seem to unhappy. I can tell you Mitchell would've been disconsolate as **** if Hawks had produced that.

 

[carlton_99]

So that's really sad. You're not even hiding that fact you're happy with this mediocrity. I'm just wondering if Carlton next year make finals or finish bottom 4. Your coach after the press conference didn't seem to unhappy. I can tell you Mitchell would've been disconsolate as **** if Hawks had produced that.

This thread is about which team had a better season - that's it. How are you not getting that? Carlton could have finished 17th and Collingwood 18th and you'd get the same reactions in here