Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[jmac70]

We played this weekend and the Pies didn't, if the Pies could've beaten Essendon just once it would've been a different story, we won the thread and that's it and if you don't know how the ladder works ask Fadgey and you'll be no better off.

I don’t think what you did last night was playing.

 

[Robertio]

I don’t think what you did last night was playing.

I know mate but we were still there.

 

[jmac70]

I know mate but we were still there.

It’s a bit like waving to someone famous, only to realise they were looking the wrong way.

 

[Seeds]

Which middle road side will be better then the other middle road side?

Lol. Who cares. Take it to the pies and blues boards.

 

[Robertio]

It’s a bit like waving to someone famous, only to realise they were looking the wrong way.

I'm only going to be nice to you for a little while mate.

 

[manicpie]

I know mate but we were still there.

if you had your time again, would you still want to be there Rob? It was a horrible night for the bloose. don't worry, we get to argue our cases again next year, yay!

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

I know mate but we were still there.

In all seriousness, what did Carlton gain from last night?

Serious question.

In some years it’s like ‘players got to experience a final’ but the first half embarrassment did more harm than good.

 

[Robertio]

if you had your time again, would you still want to be there Rob? It was a horrible night for the bloose. don't worry, we get to argue our cases again next year, yay!

Yeah we go again mate.

 

[Tadpole]

if you had your time again, would you still want to be there Rob? It was a horrible night for the bloose. don't worry, we get to argue our cases again next year, yay!

Oh, I just can't wait.

 

[Robertio]

In all seriousness, what did Carlton gain from last night?

Serious question.

In some years it’s like ‘players got to experience a final’ but the first half embarrassment did more harm than good.

I hope not but we'll have to wait and see.

 

[jmac70]

Which middle road side will be better then the other middle road side?

Lol. Who cares. Take it to the pies and blues boards.

It will be amusing to see the Hawks beat you in another Grand Final.

 

[Monco Matt]

Which middle road side will be better then the other middle road side?

Lol. Who cares. Take it to the pies and blues boards.

Come now Seeds! Don't forget that the Cats were a middle of the road side last year too after their flag, it can turn back around quickly. Let's not rope us in with "they whom never achieve", thanks!

 

[carlton_99]

Which middle road side will be better then the other middle road side?

Lol. Who cares. Take it to the pies and blues boards.

Maybe give the thread title a read

 

[DopeMaster]

Just on the thread title change situation.

As 'serious' as we can all expect to be on BF....what is the point of having a discussion/banter thread that rages for 12 months for 1000 pages just for one unknown BF mod to make a final decision based on their own opinion? Is this a democracy or North Korea? Many, many great facts and arguments against the ladder percentage situation has been made by many, many supporters of not just the Collingwood Football Club but many, many other club supporters as well.

I motion for the thread title to revert back to its initial form as the jury of the BF community is very much still deliberating.

Thank you!

Does anyone suspect Chief gifted his team a consolation prize?

Now just waiting on BigFooty merchandise department to cash in with a framed poster celebrating the historic self-anointed achievement.

 

[10571z]

So Pies are going to improve by that much- what are you basing this assumption on ?

Why wouldn’t we have faith in a quick regroup. We have played in 6 GFs since your last.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Just on the thread title change situation.

As 'serious' as we can all expect to be on BF....what is the point of having a discussion/banter thread that rages for 12 months for 1000 pages just for one unknown BF mod to make a final decision based on their own opinion? Is this a democracy or North Korea? Many, many great facts and arguments against the ladder percentage situation has been made by many, many supporters of not just the Collingwood Football Club but many, many other club supporters as well.

I motion for the thread title to revert back to its initial form as the jury of the BF community is very much still deliberating.

Thank you!

Here here!
I second this motion.

Misinformation should not be tolerated in Bigfooty thread titles.

Kudos to Fadge for taking a principled stance and boycotting this thread for about 6 days in protest to the title change. His sacrifice should inspire us all to fight against lies in thread titles.

 

[Worm4]

Why wouldn’t we have faith in a quick regroup. We have played in 6 GFs since your last.

This coming season , the pies have at least 11 players over the age of 30 in their starting 23. Doubt that has happened with your previous 6 grand final teams.
Are you not a little cautious about that ?

 

[Robertio]

Here here!
I second this motion.

Misinformation should not be tolerated in Bigfooty thread titles.

Kudos to Fadge for taking a principled stance and boycotting this thread for about 6 days in protest to the title change. His sacrifice should inspire us all to fight against lies in thread titles.

I think a few of you should learn how the ladder system works and that melt only lasted 6 days so it's one of the weakest melts I've seen.

 

[Worm4]

Here here!
I second this motion.

Misinformation should not be tolerated in Bigfooty thread titles.

Kudos to Fadge for taking a principled stance and boycotting this thread for about 6 days in protest to the title change. His sacrifice should inspire us all to fight against lies in thread titles.

I wanted it changed to say " who will finish higher in 2025" and your old mate Fadge wanted none of it.
Why can't it be "who finishes higher ?"

 

[caloschwaby]

This coming season , the pies have at least 11 players over the age of 30 in their starting 23. Doubt that has happened with your previous 6 grand final teams.
Are you not a little cautious about that ?

 

[Worm4]

Literally boarding a plane now so if I don't respond, you know why

 

[Scritchyscroony]

I think a few of you should learn how the ladder system works and that melt only lasted 6 days so it's one of the weakest melts I've seen.

6 days is an eternity for Fadge to not post in this thread mate.
Don't try to underplay the self sacrifice and moral fortitude he displayed. It was inspirational!

 

[Pistol Night]

Literally boarding a plane now so if I don't respond, you know why

You've hijacked it?

 

[Worm4]

You've hijacked it?

Not a terrorist mate. I'm off to the USA.