Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Robertio]

What did you pay for that crap spud Cerra? He wouldn't get a game in the WAFL

Fantasia Durdin Williams Cowan 60-0

What are you on? I want some and Cowan will be a great player.

 

[jakson68]

Cowan? Cowan is an absolute weapon mate. Would be the Pies 2nd best youngster behind Squibby

Then clearly Cowan must be your best!

 

[nahnah]

Schultz couldn't hit the side of a barn door by hand or foot.

He's a glorified meatball whos dominated Pies fans discussion all year of how they managed to get reamed so hard at the trade table

He had a bad year for sure, his past two years were pretty damn good should bounce back next season. Mayne and Howe also had rough first years before settling. Playing for the biggest and best club can be an adjustment

 

[Robertio]

Congrats.

Who is that Collingwood poster that makes the commemorative DVDs/posters celebrating Carlton's latest achievement?

"More Percentage Than Collingwood: Carlton's June Premiership Against Geelong".

Meanwhile, in things that actually mattered, if Geelong didn't beat Carlton in round 7 then there is no QF and the Cats aren't through to a PF.

If the Blues won every game against Collingwood and Geelong this season, they would've had the honour of playing Hinkley's men in a QF.

Sliding doors moments, eh?

"If" is a couple of letters that mean absolutely nothing.

 

[carlton_99]

What are you on? I want some and Cowan will be a great player.

Got him thanks to the Pies as well

 

[nahnah]

Got him thanks to the Pies as well

you're more than welcome

 

[RPCB]

Yet I only have to go back to last year for our most recent.
Why would I give a rats arse about 1967?
I wasn't even born!

Sadly for you Y2K is more recent than your last flag.

Do you remember Y2K, it may be difficult as it was a quarter of a century ago.

I remember it well. I was wearing an Italy top and 3 English looking skinheads were staring at me with death in their eyes. Good times.

 

[Mr Meow]

"If" is a couple of letters that mean absolutely nothing.

Would you rather swap positions? Carlton beat Geelong by a couple of goals in round 7, lose the rematch by 10 goals but then go on to secure a home PF while the Cats get spanked in an EF? Of course you would. So bringing up the mid season match is only ever going to be thrown back in your face.

You could've had similar bragging rights over Collingwood if you lost to them but then walked into a prelim.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Every year Carlton seem to find new ways to be even more

 

[nahnah]

Every year Carlton seem to find new ways to be even more

They over hype their players like crazy and they all seem to buy into it

 

[Robertio]

Would you rather swap positions? Carlton beat Geelong by a couple of goals in round 7, lose the rematch by 10 goals but then go on to secure a home PF while the Cats get spanked in an EF? Of course you would. So bringing up the mid season match is only ever going to be thrown back in your face.

You could've had similar bragging rights over Collingwood if you lost to them but then walked into a prelim.

We already have bragging rights over Collingwood

Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3​

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

We already have bragging rights over Collingwood

Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3​

Don't worry the Pies are banking on Nicky learning to win a hard ball over the pre season to propel them back into finals

May as well move onto the 2026 thread now as we know the answer for next year as well

 

[Corn Cobbers]

They over hype their players like crazy and they all seem to buy into it

They lol at Schultz but how bad is Cerra

https://www.theroar.com.au/2024/09/08/ports-nightmare-wasnt-all-hinkleys-fault-but-plenty-of-it-was-six-takeaways-from-finals-week-one/

 

[carlton_99]

They lol at Schultz but how bad is Cerra
View attachment 2105692
View attachment 2105693

https://www.theroar.com.au/2024/09/08/ports-nightmare-wasnt-all-hinkleys-fault-but-plenty-of-it-was-six-takeaways-from-finals-week-one/

Yep injuries ruined his season but he has given us a very good 2023 already. No reason he can't get back to that if he gets a decent run at it

 

[beerbandit]

Oh yes you are hurting we prevented you albeit by accident from playing finals footy! That must really do your nut in.

Is what Carlton produced what you call “playing finals footy”?

Wow. Only 1 team was playing finals footy and then they put the cue in the rack at half time.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Yep injuries ruined his season but he has given us a very good 2023 already. No reason he can't get back to that if he gets a decent run at it

Cerra is a along with Fantasia, Motlop, Cowan, Hollands x 2, Durdin, Williams, Martin, Saad, Pittonet, McGovern...

It's one of the worst teams ever assembled, straight back down to the bottom 4 next year

 

[jakson68]

We already have bragging rights over Collingwood

Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3​

I backed a horse in the Melbourne Cup and it came 9th
Your horse finished 8th.

We both still won f**k all.

But you keep celebrating being mediocre and making up the numbers.
At least when we bragged last season, we had something to brag about.

Well done Carlton, you snuck into finals (for a week )

Go get a tattoo to immortalize the great achievement.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Is what Carlton produced what you call “playing finals footy”?

Wow. Only 1 team was playing finals footy and then they put the cue in the rack at half time.

I did say on our board that at sixty to zero the show was over. Anything afterwards was mere window dressing.

With the right changes we can win the flag in the next two years. We need to cash in while we still have Patrick Cripps in his prime!

 

[Robertio]

They lol at Schultz but how bad is Cerra
View attachment 2105692
View attachment 2105693

https://www.theroar.com.au/2024/09/08/ports-nightmare-wasnt-all-hinkleys-fault-but-plenty-of-it-was-six-takeaways-from-finals-week-one/

Stop yelling old mate.

 

[nahnah]

Cerra is a along with Fantasia, Motlop, Cowan, Hollands x 2, Durdin, Williams, Martin, Saad, Pittonet, McGovern...

It's one of the worst teams ever assembled, straight back down to the bottom 4 next year

No wonder we beat them twice while having all our injuries

 

[Robertio]

I backed a horse in the Melbourne Cup and it came 9th
Your horse finished 8th.

We both still won f**k all.

But you keep celebrating being mediocre and making up the numbers.
At least when we bragged last season, we had something to brag about.

Well done Carlton, you snuck into finals (for a week )

Go get a tattoo to immortalize the great achievement.

Last season is long gone mate, it's like us bringing up 1995.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

No wonder we beat them twice while having all our injuries

And the biggest spud is VOSS, what an epic twit

TDK sub

 

[Fadge]

I did say on our board that at sixty to zero the show was over.

Wow. That was a brave call...

 

[carlton_99]

Cerra is a along with Fantasia, Motlop, Cowan, Hollands x 2, Durdin, Williams, Martin, Saad, Pittonet, McGovern...

It's one of the worst teams ever assembled, straight back down to the bottom 4 next year

All this talk and you still couldn't finish above us...

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

I backed a horse in the Melbourne Cup and it came 9th
Your horse finished 8th.

We both still won f**k all.

But you keep celebrating being mediocre and making up the numbers.
At least when we bragged last season, we had something to brag about.

Well done Carlton, you snuck into finals (for a week )

Go get a tattoo to immortalize the great achievement.

It was still worth it. We stopped you flogs from going back to back, something you last did in 1936.