Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Robertio]

The coaching hire or the sub choice?

Sub choice.

 

[Robertio]

What do you mean long gone?

Collingwood are the reining premiership team.
True of false?

This means we are still the current premiers.

Reining Premiers, this still makes me smile .

This may be why Carlton supporters are more upset about making finals (for a minute), than Collingwood supporters are with missing them.

I may go and watch our Grand Final win again.
I would offer you the same service but the quality may be a bit grainy from the VHS

I got the 95,87, 82, 81, 79, 72, 70 and 68 all on DVD, what's a VHS?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I got the 95,87, 82, 81, 79, 72, 70 and 68 all on DVD, what's a VHS?

What's DVD? We stream our latest

 

[beerbandit]

1927, 1928, 1929 and 1930. In fairness your club was a flag winning machine back in those days.

Yes but I said 1936 was just “after” we won 4 in a row. That’s where I think you’ve gone Irish on me!

 

[Sweeetleftfoot]

With the Brownlow shaping up to be between Daicos and Cripps, there's still life in the thread for this year.

Don’t think there’s much life really, Cripps polls well on losses daicos doesnt.

Could very well be the difference.

 

[RonnieRaven]

We finished above your mob, how insipid were they?

We don’t have 2 Coleman medalist up front yet

 

[South of the Yarra]

The legend of the Blueshakes grows.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Yes but I said 1936 was just “after” we won 4 in a row. That’s where I think you’ve gone Irish on me!

Oh yeah i thought you meant 1933, 1934, 1935 and 1936 was when you did your four peat.

 

[Worm4]

Yeah true.
But Sam Walsh is still a stat plodding B grader.

The fat German cost Collingwood 2 first round draft picks.
Walsh only cost us 1 first rounder.
Pies need to get TWICE as much output from the little sausage after what Collingwood coughed up for him.
10pm here in LA - 5 hours after I left Melbourne. Looks like the same crap being talked about so not missing any conversations.

 

[Cleansweep17]

Best you go measure up a cabinet for your wooden spoons.
Ask Carlton what dimensions are required, as they will know.

I’ll ask Joffa, he’s probably been put on cafeteria duty so he’d have a few spare ones.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

The fat German cost Collingwood 2 first round draft picks.
Walsh only cost us 1 first rounder.
Pies need to get TWICE as much output from the little sausage after what Collingwood coughed up for him.
10pm here in LA - 5 hours after I left Melbourne. Looks like the same crap being talked about so not missing any conversations.

Great stuff Wormy, living the dream

 

[Robertio]

Not true actually. Didn't the nice folk at Carlton give us a trophy for beating them again? The annual Dick Pratt Carlton lost to Collingwood trophy or something?

They gave Nick Daicos the Dick Pratt medal for reaming them again.
Heard he graciously accepted then quietly threw it in the bin where it belongs.

That's not very respectful to blokes who have prostate cancer, the two clubs do a great job in making men aware which you're obviously not.

 

[Worm4]

That's not very respectful to blokes who have prostate cancer, the two clubs do a great job in making men aware which you're obviously not.

Agreed mate. I've had cancer and beat it. The people that work at Peter Mac and ONJ where I got my treatment are absolutely amazing. The Peter Mac cup is a wonderful initiative. Anyone who talks it down is not a worthy human

 

[Bunk Moreland]

128 years, 20 clubs, and there’s only been 11 instances in league history of 30+ year premiership droughts.

In exciting news for the Baggers, they now have the chance to join this illustrious group in 2025. Can they do it?

Sth / Sydney: 1933 - 2005

St Kilda: 1897 - 1966

Dogs: 1954 - 2016

St Kilda: 1966 - 2025

Melbourne: 1964 - 2021

Fitzroy: 1944 - 1996

North: 1925 - 1975

Geelong: 1963 - 2007

Richmond: 1980 - 2017

Hawthorn: 1925 - 1961

Collingwood: 1958 - 1990

 

[Fadge]

128 years, 20 clubs, and there’s only been 11 instances in league history of 30+ year premiership droughts.

In exciting news for the Baggers, they now have the chance to join this illustrious group in 2025. Can they do it?

Sth / Sydney: 1933 - 2005

St Kilda: 1897 - 1966

Dogs: 1954 - 2016

St Kilda: 1966 - 2025

Melbourne: 1964 - 2021

Fitzroy: 1944 - 1996

North: 1925 - 1975

Geelong: 1963 - 2007

Richmond: 1980 - 2017

Hawthorn: 1925 - 1961

Collingwood: 1958 - 1990

How many of those teams, within that 30 year premiership drought, have:
A 25 year plus Grand Final Drought
5 plus wooden spoons?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

The fat German cost Collingwood 2 first round draft picks.
Walsh only cost us 1 first rounder.
Pies need to get TWICE as much output from the little sausage after what Collingwood coughed up for him.
10pm here in LA - 5 hours after I left Melbourne. Looks like the same crap being talked about so not missing any conversations.

He cost us a first rounder (pick 10) and a second rounder (plus Ginnivan if I'm being honest). I ain't defending that!.
But Sam the B grader Walsh was a #1 pick!. He's looking like Bryce Gibbs MK2.

You gonna go for a drive through Compton Wormy?
I also recommend a trip out to the old Spahn ranch site.

 

[nahnah]

128 years, 20 clubs, and there’s only been 11 instances in league history of 30+ year premiership droughts.

In exciting news for the Baggers, they now have the chance to join this illustrious group in 2025. Can they do it?

Sth / Sydney: 1933 - 2005

St Kilda: 1897 - 1966

Dogs: 1954 - 2016

St Kilda: 1966 - 2025

Melbourne: 1964 - 2021

Fitzroy: 1944 - 1996

North: 1925 - 1975

Geelong: 1963 - 2007

Richmond: 1980 - 2017

Hawthorn: 1925 - 1961

Collingwood: 1958 - 1990

I think we are looking at a Swans situation here

 

[beerbandit]

Oh yeah i thought you meant 1933, 1934, 1935 and 1936 was when you did your four peat.

It doesn’t really matter, all that matters is that we have won a 4 peat, I believe Arr0w was in the crowd with his kids at these games!

 

[Fadge]

I think we are looking at a Swans situation here

Would you like me to calculate the probability of that scenario eventuating?

 

[Fadge]

It doesn’t really matter, all that matters is that we have won a 4 peat, I believe Arr0w was in the crowd with his kids at these games!

Speaking of which....

Where is Arr0w?

He's been very quiet since Carlton have proven to be nothing more than a mid-table team, and obviously fell short of being a premiership contender...

 

[nahnah]

Would you like me to calculate the probability of that scenario eventuating?

Yes

 

[Arr0w]

It doesn’t really matter, all that matters is that we have won a 4 peat, I believe Arr0w was in the crowd with his kids at these games!

Get it right, with my grand kids

Speaking of which....

Where is Arr0w?

He's been very quiet since Carlton have proven to be nothing more than a mid-table team, and obviously fell short of being a premiership contender...

I'm always around fadge, I don't spit my pizza like you sooking up over a thread title

Facts are, we finished higher on the ladder, and by the OP, the better side in 2024

I'll be back for the fun, frivolity and pizza spitting for next year

Looking forward to more of your failed predictions

 

[Fadge]

Looking forward to more of your failed predictions

Failed predictions indeed.

Like Carlton not being a premiership contender, and instead being nothing more than a mid table team?

 

[beerbandit]

The fat German cost Collingwood 2 first round draft picks.
Walsh only cost us 1 first rounder.
Pies need to get TWICE as much output from the little sausage after what Collingwood coughed up for him.
10pm here in LA - 5 hours after I left Melbourne. Looks like the same crap being talked about so not missing any conversations.

Work or play ? Worm4

 

[Joffaboy]

Noddy? Are you four? No one player costs a team any game - Saad was brilliant that game.

Saad can't defend, is a mediocre kick and he lost you that game. Live with it noddy.

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app