Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[beerbandit]

Worm4 seems a bit emotional in that video.

“The GABBAs a Dog!”

Hahaha

 

[g_TRAIN]

Honestly both clubs may struggle in 2025.

 

[doppleganger]

Perfect timing we need a new biggest loser sponser since Hawkins has retired.

Speaking of losers.

Carlton 11 losses in 2024, Collingwood only 9.

 

[Cleansweep17]

Speaking of losers.

Carlton 11 losses in 2024, Collingwood only 9.

Dunno if you realise but I go for Richmond bro

 

[doppleganger]

Dunno if you realise but I go for Richmond bro

Richmond 21 losses

 

[DrEvil_]

Pies ahead. Carlton 2024 was an embarrassment

 

[Worm4]

Pies ahead. Carlton 2024 was an embarrassment

You must think Collingwood going from 1st to 9th was some type of achievement

 

[Robertio]

Speaking of losers.

Carlton 11 losses in 2024, Collingwood only 9.

Now give us the wins Mr Trump.

 

[Worm4]

Speaking of losers.

Carlton 11 losses in 2024, Collingwood only 9.

How many wins but ?

 

[Cleansweep17]

Richmond 21 losses

All good mate, I just bought a GC Suns membership

I’m feeling the VicBias already.

 

[Fadge]

Dunno if you realise but I go for Richmond bro

Seems you missed his point....

 

[DrEvil_]

You must think Collingwood going from 1st to 9th was some type of achievement

That's pretty bad, but it happens. Let me tell you what a true achievement is:

1) sub your ruck
2) donuts to ten goals 3 minutes before half time
3) forced to make strategic sub before scoring any point

Congratulations, Carlton 2024 has just unlocked the achievement "Peak Embarrassment"

 

[Doc1763]

That's pretty bad, but it happens. Let me tell you what a true achievement is:

1) sub your ruck
2) donuts to ten goals 3 minutes before half time
3) forced to make strategic sub before scoring any point

Congratulations, Carlton 2024 has just unlocked the achievement "Peak Embarrassment"

And as disappointing as going from 1st to 9th is, we are still, at the minute, the reigning premier.
It's been 28 long years since Carlton have been able to say that.

 

[Worm4]

That's pretty bad, but it happens. Let me tell you what a true achievement is:

1) sub your ruck
2) donuts to ten goals 3 minutes before half time
3) forced to make strategic sub before scoring any point

Congratulations, Carlton 2024 has just unlocked the achievement "Peak Embarrassment"

Some people have short memories. Peak embarrassment goes to the Swans 100plus loss to Port without a shadow of doubt.
If Carlton went in against the Lions with a healthy list, I could see some sort of validity to your reasoning, but I just can't. Cmon, Port ffs ?

 

[Fadge]

Some people have short memories. Peak embarrassment goes to the Swans 100plus loss to Port without a shadow of doubt.
If Carlton went in against the Lions with a healthy list, I could see some sort of validity to your reasoning, but I just can't. Cmon, Port ffs ?

Yeah, I'm sure Sydney are really embarrassed reflecting on that loss as they prepare for their home Preliminary Final next week.

NFI.

 

[Worm4]

Yeah, I'm sure Sydney are really embarrassed reflecting on that loss as they prepare for their home Preliminary Final next week.

NFI.

Will still go do down as a worse loss. Spin it any way you want. Pies didn't play finals and were in the top 8 for 3 weeks of the season. Embarrassing for them.

 

[Fadge]

Will still go do down as a worse loss. Spin it any way you want. Pies didn't play finals and were in the top 8 for 3 weeks of the season. Embarrassing for them.

Yep.

Pies embarrassed themselves finishing 9th as the reigning premier.

Sydney embarrassed themselves losing to Port by over 100 points in a home and away game, despite the fact they are currently preparing for a home Preliminary Final next week.

Both teams have been premiership contenders as often as they haven't over the past two decades.

Both far more 'embarrassing' than Carlton, who fell into 8th spot after winning 2 of their last 8 games against 16th and 17th on the ladder, and proceeded to a scoreline of Owen 60 just before half time of an Elimination Final. That, in a season when they were second on the ladder and second favourites for the flag at the mid point of the season, after failing to contend for a premiership in a quarter of a century.

CARLTON LOGIC.

 

[doppleganger]

All good mate, I just bought a GC Suns membership

A typical Tiger, jumping off when gets a bit tough.

 

[Worm4]

Yep.

Pies embarrassed themselves finishing 9th as the reigning premier.

Sydney embarrassed themselves losing to Port by over 100 points in a home and away game, despite the fact they are currently preparing for a home Preliminary Final next week.

Both teams have been premiership contenders as often as they haven't over the past two decades.

Both far more 'embarrassing' than Carlton, who fell into 8th spot after winning 2 of their last 8 games against 16th and 17th on the ladder, and proceeded to a scoreline of Owen 60 just before half time of an Elimination Final. That, in a season when they were second on the ladder and second favourites for the flag at the mid point of the season, after failing to contend for a premiership in a quarter of a century.

CARLTON LOGIC.

How did Collingwood go last week ? Pie logic - don't play finals, but are a better side. Righteo. Carlton were never favourite for the flag at any point during the season - collingwood were favourite prior to round 1. Nice deflection.

 

[Doc1763]

How did Collingwood go last week ? Pie logic - don't play finals, but are a better side. Righteo. Carlton were never favourite for the flag at any point during the season - collingwood were favourite prior to round 1. Nice deflection.

Carlton were undisputed, unbackable flag favourites. And then fell in a hole, yet again.
We had a disappointing season, but we are still, for the moment, the undisputed reigning premier.
Happy 29th anniversary.

 

[Worm4]

Carlton were undisputed, unbackable flag favourites. And then fell in a hole, yet again.
We had a disappointing season, but we are still, for the moment, the undisputed reigning premier.
Happy 29th anniversary.

Bullshit. Stop making up rubbish . Prove that Carlton were favourites at any stage or admit you just made up that statement.
Sportsbet or TAB will be able to assist with your query

 

[Fadge]

Bullshit. Stop making up rubbish . Prove that Carlton were favourites at any stage or admit you just made up that statement.
Sportsbet or TAB will be able to assist with your query

Why were you guys all crying for months on end because I refused to label your team 'Premiership Contenders'?

 

[Doc1763]

Bullshit. Stop making up rubbish . Prove that Carlton were favourites at any stage or admit you just made up that statement.
Sportsbet or TAB will be able to assist with your query

I'm not making up anything.
We can accept we had a disappointing season, because we still have the warm inner glow of a Premiership.
Carlton's glow went out at quarter time against the Giants, when you were undisputed Premiership favourites.
Happy 29th anniversary.

 

[Worm4]

Why were you guys all crying for months on end because I refused to label your team 'Premiership Contenders'?

Huh ? What's that got to do with a poster making up an unsubstantiated claim about Carlton being favourites for the flag .

 

[Doc1763]

Huh ? What's that got to do with a poster making up an unsubstantiated claim about Carlton being favourites for the flag .

Absolutely they were. Then only beat the might of Richmond, North and West Coast before embarrassing themselves in Brisbane.
Happy 29th anniversary.