Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Doc1763]

Umpiring decisions? Like your game against North?

Swings an roundabouts of a season, one where we finished higher, and being the better side

You played North and Richmond twice.
We beat you twice.
We beat the team that humiliated you twice.
You showed what a worthy finalists you were in Brisbane.
We were clearly better than you in 2024.
Happy 29th anniversary.

 

[Arr0w]

You played North and Richmond twice.
We beat you twice.
We beat the team that humiliated you twice.
You showed what a worthy finalists you were in Brisbane.
We were clearly better than you in 2024.
Happy 29th anniversary.

Unfortunately, the ladder says differently in 2024 but you will get your chance in 2025

 

[Fadge]

You played North and Richmond twice.
We beat you twice.
We beat the team that humiliated you twice.
You showed what a worthy finalists you were in Brisbane.
We were clearly better than you in 2024.
Happy 29th anniversary.

They're clinging on to any small win they possibly can, despite their stance being completely illogical and irrational.

Nearly 3 decades of complete irrelevance will bring out that desperation and delusion.

 

[Doc1763]

They're clinging on to any small win they possibly can, despite their stance being completely illogical and irrational.

Nearly 3 decades of complete irrelevance will bring out that desperation and delusion.

Not true, they've 'won' 5 spoons this century.
At least that's something.

 

[Fadge]

Not true, they've 'won' 5 spoons this century.
At least that's something.

Good point.

They've thrived with all those #1 draft picks...

 

[Worm4]

Yet another flagless year.
Happy 29th anniversary

Still finished above Collingwood.

 

[Pistol Night]

Good point.

They've thrived with all those #1 draft picks...

Its actually impressive to be able to have 6 number 1 picks in 20 years and sill not be able to get past a prelim in that time

 

[Worm4]

Good point.

They've thrived with all those #1 draft picks...

Finished above Collingwood in 2024

 

[Pistol Night]

Still finished above Collingwood.

You know the aim of the game is to win a flag. If we pulled ourselves every year we finished above you guys we'd have no skin left on our old fellas

 

[Fadge]

Its actually impressive to be able to have 6 number 1 picks in 20 years and sill not be able to get past a prelim in that time

A solitary Preliminary Final, in which they were completely outclassed.

Half decent teams couldn't do that if they tried.

But then again, half decent teams wouldn't win 5 spoons in less than two decades.

 

[Worm4]

Its actually impressive to be able to have 6 number 1 picks in 20 years and sill not be able to get past a prelim in that time

Who are the 6 players ?

 

[Worm4]

You know the aim of the game is to win a flag. If we pulled ourselves every year we finished above you guys we'd have no skin left on our old fellas

You know the aim of the thread title ?

 

[Pistol Night]

Who are the 6 players ?

****ed if i know. 6 spuds i gather

 

[Pistol Night]

You know the aim of the thread title ?

To give Carlton supporters something to cling onto for the first time this century?

 

[caloschwaby]

Carlton were just that much better and more impressive in 2024, the thread poll is already 3:1 in favour of Pies being better for 2025 lmao

 

[Worm4]

A solitary Preliminary Final, in which they were completely outclassed.

Half decent teams couldn't do that if they tried.

But then again, half decent teams wouldn't win 5 spoons in less than two decades.

You do realise that the AFL played a significant part of those 5 spoons .
Collingwood won theirs by being in control of being shit. We were forced to select players like Digby Morrel and mighty Mick Martyn

 

[Worm4]

****ed if i know. 6 spuds i gather

Don't think there were 6 mate.

 

[Fadge]

You do realise that the AFL played a significant part of those 5 spoons .
Collingwood won theirs by being in control of being shit. We were forced to select players like Digby Morrel and mighty Mick Martyn

Yep.

Always someone else's fault.

Never on Carlton.

 

[Pistol Night]

Don't think there were 6 mate.

5? That makes it heaps less shit. Should of been 6 but you got caught cheating. Tisk tisk

 

[caloschwaby]

Collingwood won theirs by being in control of being shit.

Agree. If we were wiser like your lot we would've rorted the salary cap and country draft zones

 

[Worm4]

Carlton were just that much better and more impressive in 2024, the thread poll is already 3:1 in favour of Pies being better for 2025 lmao

There are only 6 Carlton posters on here. Are you surprised by the poll ?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Are Pies fans still clambering to get some validation in this thread??? Fudgey was wrong, the Pies missed finals and the Blues, while we had a few disastrous days on the field still were still better than the miserable old Pies.

As for 2025 the Pies have no youth coming through, no good picks, losing one of their best half backs and Schultz has been getting on the KFC early from what I've heard.

Pies won't be relevant next year, much like they weren't this year with their retirement village list.

 

[Worm4]

5? That makes it heaps less shit. Should of been 6 but you got caught cheating. Tisk tisk

Every team cheated. Carlton just kept it quiet. The rest of the comp dobbed themselves in. Bunch of puppets the lot of ya's

 

[carlton_99]

Carlton were just that much better and more impressive in 2024, the thread poll is already 3:1 in favour of Pies being better for 2025 lmao

Lol at least 14 of them are Collingwood supporters but congrats on winning a poll. The ladder which determines who makes finals is "simple" analysis but using a poll is fine

 

[carlton_99]

This thread is now about 2025 and all I'm seeing is Pies fans stuck in the past. If you truly were better in 24' you would be talking about what will happen in 25' not deflecting to 30 years ago