Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Fadge]

Just proving my point that your are more invested into posts involving Carlton and continue to troll , rather than having bugger all input into threads involving other teams. The defence rests

I've participated in plenty of non Collingwood / non Carlton game day threads over the journey.

Stalker.

 

[Worm4]

I've participated in plenty of non Collingwood / non Carlton game day threads over the journey.

Stalker.

Pot kettle Black. Stop stalking Carlton only posts.
Your input is merely trolling.

 

[Fadge]

But who are your picks for this week OB1

Are you really THAT invested in my predictions?

And why would my predictions have any relation to who I conclude were the genuine premiership contenders once it's all played out?

 

[Fadge]

Pot kettle Black. Stop stalking Carlton only posts.
Your input is merely trolling.

Here we are at the pointy end of the season, and again Carlton are non-existent.

What a shame...

 

[Hawkboy62]

Not a Pies fan but they have the better coach and Nick Daicos so tipping the Pies in 25.

Carlton seem to be aggressively trying to improve their list but the total coaching panel seems to be the weakest link, and they are locked in for 2025. Remember the gaggle of coaches in the box during R22 against Hawthorn. "People, people everywhere, and not a brain to think." Oh, the injuries, the injuries!

I know that many Blues fans think they are a lock for top four but it's a stretch for a team that has so many shockers.

Buy a Carlton - 0-60 in under 2 (quarters)!

 

[jakson68]

Not a Pies fan but they have the better coach and Nick Daicos so tipping the Pies in 25.

Carlton seem to be aggressively trying to improve their list but the total coaching panel seems to be the weakest link, and they are locked in for 2025. Remember the gaggle of coaches in the box during R22 against Hawthorn. "People, people everywhere, and not a brain to think." Oh, the injuries, the injuries!

I know that many Blues fans think they are a lock for top four but it's a stretch for a team that has so many shockers.

Buy a Carlton - 0-60 in under 2 (quarters)!

You are not a Pies fan but you are very wise beyond your years

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Not a Pies fan but they have the better coach and Nick Daicos so tipping the Pies in 25.



I know that many Blues fans think they are a lock for top four but it's a stretch for a team that has so many shockers.

Agreed. Nowadays you cannot be top 4 without small (or pressure) forwards and elite ones, do tell who are Carlton's ones? Their best one is a 2 game rookie in Moir and he isn't even a true small forward. Their defence is also as shaky as the Titanic was on that voyage, Weitering in AA form saved them all year long, was a brilliant year but can that be relied on? Who is their 2nd or 3rd defenders? You are relying on Curnow/McKay saving your side every week it's unsustainable, it just is.

In a weird way going back so to speak to go forward should be Carlton's objective but whether Crazy Vossy even admits that is another question. Get some games into Moir, spend your earliest pick on the best pressure small in the draft, and play both from day dot.

 

[Worm4]

Here we are at the pointy end of the season, and again Carlton are non-existent.

What a shame...

Where are Collingwood ?
Clown comment from you

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Just proving my point that your are more invested into posts involving Carlton and continue to troll , rather than having bugger all input into threads involving other teams. The defence rests

You proved that you are stalking Fadge. It's not flattering it's creepy! He's not interested. No means No!

 

[Chief]

I've participated in plenty of non Collingwood / non Carlton game day threads over the journey.

Yes but only to bring up Carlton and/or Collingwood.

 

[Worm4]

You proved that you are stalking Fadge. It's not flattering it's creepy! He's not interested. No means No!

I'm just wondering why he doesn't pop his head into other game threads unless Carlton are involved. More to the point - Fadge is stalking Carlton. That's the creepy part

 

[Scritchyscroony]

I'm just wondering why he doesn't pop his head into other game threads unless Carlton are involved. More to the point - Fadge is stalking Carlton. That's the creepy part

His posting proclivities are up to him and non of your business.
He has found his niche in tormenting Carlton supporters and he's damm good at it!

 

[Worm4]

His posting proclivities are up to him and non of your business.
He has found his niche in tormenting Carlton supporters and he's damm good at it!

Thanks Fadges mum

 

[Fadge]

Where are Collingwood ?
Clown comment from you

Refer to my key word.... 'again'.

Unfortunately, it's unrealistic for Collingwood supporters to expect their team to contend for the premiership EVERY year...

 

[Fadge]

Yes but only to bring up Carlton and/or Collingwood.

Oh.

So when I was active in the Sydney v. GWS Game Day Thread - the third most recent game played - and was talking up Heeney's performance (for example), was that under the guise of talking up Collingwood, or talking down Carlton?

 

[Chief]

Oh.

So when I was active in the Sydney v. GWS Game Day Thread - the third most recent game played - and was talking up Heeney's performance (for example), was that under the guise of talking up Collingwood, or talking down Carlton?

Our exclusive AI LLM Sentiment Engine says yes.

Can't argue with technological progress. Get on board or get out of the way.

(Not financial advice.)

 

[Fadge]

Our exclusive AI LLM Sentiment Engine says yes.

Can't argue with technological progress. Get on board or get out of the way.

(Not financial advice.)

Sounds like yet another flawed algorithm.

I might be available for consulting advice, though I don't come cheap.

 

[Reg Grundy35]

next year Carlton aim to consolidate their superiority to the Pies by actually beating them in a footy match

 

[gappa]

Is the question now who will win trade week (or come second to Essendon at least)?

 

[Worm4]

Oh.

So when I was active in the Sydney v. GWS Game Day Thread - the third most recent game played - and was talking up Heeney's performance (for example), was that under the guise of talking up Collingwood, or talking down Carlton?

Gws v Sydney- 5 posts
Brisbane v Carlton - 15 posts

Common theme - fadge has a love affair for the blues

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Is the question now who will win trade week (or come second to Essendon at least)?

If they're getting rid of guys like Kennedy and Owies then we'll win trade week pretty easily without doing anything

 

[Fadge]

Gws v Sydney- 5 posts
Brisbane v Carlton - 15 posts

Common theme - fadge has a love affair for the blues

Oh. Another Stalker.

How dare I post as many as 15 posts in a Carlton Game Day thread when I only had 5 posts in a non-Carlton game on the same weekend.

You guys are pathetic.

 

[Worm4]

Oh. Another Stalker.

How dare I post as many as 15 posts in a Carlton Game Day thread when I only had 5 posts in a non-Carlton game on the same weekend.

You guys are pathetic.

You're the pathetic one

 

[Scritchyscroony]

You're the pathetic one

No you are
smelly bum

 

[Chronz]

We both won't fall the way of Richmond at least. They'll clean sweep the next 4 spoons.