Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Robertio]

What does Motlop have to do with Pick 3?

Motlop way better than Harrison anyway.

 

[Bale Dup]

2017 draft:
Carlton: pick 3: Paddy Dow.
Collingwood pick 39: Nathan Murphy.
2021 draft:
Carlton pick 27: Jesse Motlop
Collingwood pick 52 Harvey Harrison

Carlton is more than capable of screwing up another pick 3. Does the experience of history mean nothing to you?

History is all you Collingwood fans go on about. Back in the old days....

On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

History is all you Collingwood fans go on about. Back in the old days....

Yeah.

Collingwood supporters can spend all day discussing what their club has achieved.

Carlton supporters try to avoid discussing what has actually happened, and love to spend all day waxing lyrical about why 'next year is going to be different'.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Yeah.

Collingwood supporters can spend all day discussing what their club has achieved.

Carlton supporters try to avoid discussing what has actually happened, and love to spend all day waxing lyrical about why 'next year is going to be different'.

Any explanation as to how Kennedy and Owies would be Collingwoods 30-35th best players despite the gigantic list of duds I mentioned?

Half of them will be lucky to survive another year on an AFL list and none are currently better than either

Saying they will be better is an absolute cop out

 

[Fadge]

You don't remember the 2013 draft mate, we can play this game all day.

2013?

More than 10 years ago?

Since which time Collingwood have won a flag, and contended on another three occasions, despite the poor return from our high draft picks in 2013.

 

[Robertio]

Yeah.

Collingwood supporters can spend all day discussing what their club has achieved.

Carlton supporters try to avoid discussing what has actually happened, and love to spend all day waxing lyrical about why 'next year is going to be different'.

Before we pck at no 3 tell me out of the proposed top 4 Lalor, Smith, FOS and Draper which one won't make it?

 

[Fadge]

Any explanation as to how Kennedy and Owies would be Collingwoods 30-35th best players despite the gigantic list of duds I mentioned?

Half of them will be lucky to survive another year on an AFL list and none are currently better than either

I've already responded.

Keep up.

 

[Robertio]

2013?

More than 10 years ago?

Since which time Collingwood have won a flag, and contended on another three occasions, despite the poor return from our high draft picks in 2013.

Get with the conversation mate and forget about the change of topic.

 

[Fadge]

Before we pck at no 3 tell me out of the proposed top 4 Lalor, Smith, Fos and Draper which one won't make it?

As I said....

'Carlton supporters waxing lyrical about why next year/the future will be different'.

I hope they all make it, why would I be hoping kids fail?

 

[Chief]

Carlton supporters try to avoid discussing what has actually happened

Like their 2024 ladder position?

Oh wait...

 

[Robertio]

As I said....

'Carlton supporters waxing lyrical about why next year/the future will be different'.

I hope they all make it, why would I be hoping kids fail?

You've already said our recruiters have a bad record with no 3, instead of waiting till after the fact which one won't make it? I predict all 4 will be very good.

 

[Robertio]

Like their 2024 ladder position?

Oh wait...

Don't bring current reality into it mate.

 

[Fadge]

Like their 2024 ladder position?

Oh wait...

'2024 - A Year For The Ages' in the history of the Carlton football club.

When do we expect them to actually do something meaningful, like contend for a premiership, or beat Collingwood in a meaningful game?

 

[Fadge]

You've already said our recruiters have a bad record with no 3, instead of waiting till after the fact which one won't make it? I predict all 4 will be very good.

Have I?

When?

 

[Robertio]

Have I?

When?

You don't want to answer my question mate?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

As I said....

'Carlton supporters waxing lyrical about why next year/the future will be different'.

I hope they all make it, why would I be hoping kids fail?

Next year/the future you say... But then ur waffling on like an idiot with posts like this?

Half of those players either are, have been, or will be better players than Owies and Kennedy.

Have been:
Cox
Markov
Frampton

Will be:
Macrae
DeMattia
Allen
Jiath
Ryan
Mcinnes
Sullivan
Long
Richards
Dean

I'd keep all of them on Collingwood's list before picking up Kennedy and Owies. (Noting Richards is no longer on our list)

???

 

[Fadge]

You don't want to answer my question mate?

No, because it's a stupid question.

As I said, I hope all of them succeed.

I'm not like you guys who deadride quality young kids.

 

[Robertio]

No, because it's a stupid question.

As I said, I hope all of them succeed.

I'm not like you guys who deadride quality young kids.

Such as?

 

[Fadge]

Such as?

You're not familiar with behaviour of Carlton supporters in the Nick Daicos thread?

 

[Cyclops]

Pies gonna 4peat starting in 2025, no way Carlton get near us.

I disagree with my fellow Pies, Owies a huge lose for the Bluesbecause even though we gave several (many, even) better flankers they are very small poor up forward, and he brings uncompromising effort (another area where Carlton is pretty weak).

If you put McReery or Shukz in that Carlton forward line pencil them in for a prelim.

 

[Fadge]

I disagree with my fellow Pies, Owies a huge lose for the Bluesbecause even though we gave several (many, even) better flankers they are very small poor up forward, and he brings uncompromising effort (another area where Carlton is pretty weak).

Another thing that is easily overlooked is the importance of durability.

For a team who believes they have had the worst injury run of all teams every year for the last 10 years, they readily gave up two players who played 47 of a possible 48 games between them last year.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

History is all you Collingwood fans go on about. Back in the old days....

On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yeah way back 14 months ago when we won the flag... It's so long ago now it feels more like 30 years... But that's just a feeling. I'd have to defer to you on that.. lived experience and all.

 

[Robertio]

You're not familiar with behaviour of Carlton supporters in the Nick Daicos thread?

I'm only worried about my behaviour mate, the only time i post in that thread was when someone said something stupid about a Carlton player.

 

[Worm4]

You've already said our recruiters have a bad record with no 3, instead of waiting till after the fact which one won't make it? I predict all 4 will be very good.

Lucky for us we won't have pick 3 then. We are safe

 

[Fadge]

Yeah way back 14 months ago when we won the flag... It's so long ago now it feels more like 30 years... But that's just a feeling. I'd have to defer to you on that.. lived experience and all.

Even worse than 29 years (and counting) since their last premiership, is 25 years since they contended for a premiership.

When do we start to feel sorry for them?