Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[beerbandit]

Oh. Another Stalker.

How dare I post as many as 15 posts in a Carlton Game Day thread when I only had 5 posts in a non-Carlton game on the same weekend.

You guys are pathetic.

Need we bring up the Nick Daicos thread to these guys Fadge

 

[Fadge]

We both won't fall the way of Richmond at least. They'll clean sweep the next 4 spoons.

I wouldn't be too sure.

It is Carlton you're talking about...

 

[Fadge]

No you are
smelly bum

They're not real good at this banter thing, are they?

I guess that what happens when you finally come to the realisation that after more than two decades of building and rebuilding, your beloved club remains no better than 'mid table'...

 

[Chronz]

I wouldn't be too sure.

It is Carlton you're talking about...

Sometimes I think they can change until they don't.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

If they're getting rid of guys like Kennedy and Owies then we'll win trade week pretty easily without doing anything

They obviously think they're getting Houston. Stripping the list to make room for him.
Be a real shame if they lose their best small forward and backup mid and then Houston decides to come to the Pies instead.

 

[Robertio]

They obviously think they're getting Houston. Stripping the list to make room for him.
Be a real shame if they lose their best small forward and backup mid and then Houston decides to come to the Pies instead.

Another nuffy that believes everything they read in the papers.

 

[Fadge]

Another nuffy that believes everything they read in the papers.

So Houston locked and loaded at Carlton then?

In the same way Carlton were definite premiership contenders midway through the season?

 

[Robertio]

So Houston locked and loaded at Carlton then?

In the same way Carlton were definite premiership contenders midway through the season?

He is not locked and loaded at Carlton, talking about nuffys.

 

[Cleansweep17]

I reckon we should start a days till Pies won a final count. I have a feeling it may rival the Bombers.

 

[Fadge]

I reckon we should start a days till Pies won a final count. I have a feeling it may rival the Bombers.

Yeah, great idea.

Do it!

 

[Pistol Night]

Another nuffy that believes everything they read in the papers.

I liked you better when you weren’t so grumpy.

 

[Pistol Night]

I reckon we should start a days till Pies won a final count. I have a feeling it may rival the Bombers.

Finished annoying Geelong so its back to Collingwood while cupping Carlton’s balls. What a life

 

[Cleansweep17]

Finished annoying Geelong so its back to Collingwood while cupping Carlton’s balls. What a life

Better than whipping out your Pistol all Night

 

[Pistol Night]

Better than whipping out your Pistol all Night

All night? You’re too kind.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Finished annoying Geelong so its back to Collingwood while cupping Carlton’s balls. What a life

He's strangely chipper for a guy whose team just won the spoon and whose best players are cueing up to leave. Not to mention his all time idol doing the dirty on the Tigers and going to Gold Coast.

Wonder if he's ripped down all the Dusty posters on his bedroom wall yet?

 

[VinnieB]

I reckon we should start a days till Pies won a final count. I have a feeling it may rival the Bombers.

I’m fairly sure the Tigers will wrap that up. Back to where we know they belong.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Are these Collingwood simpletons and flogs still banging on about how they were supposed to be better this year?

The more you explain the more you're losing people! Beaten to the finals by an injury plagued Carlton team.

I think that tells us that this Pies team ain't much chop indeed!

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

They obviously think they're getting Houston. Stripping the list to make room for him.
Be a real shame if they lose their best small forward and backup mid and then Houston decides to come to the Pies instead.

Why would he join a sinking ship though?

 

[Fadge]

Are these Collingwood simpletons and flogs still banging on about how they were supposed to be better this year?

The more you explain the more you're losing people! Beaten to the finals by an injury plagued Carlton team.

I think that tells us that this Pies team ain't much chop indeed!

'Injuries'

 

[Fadge]

I’m fairly sure the Tigers will wrap that up. Back to where we know they belong.

The Tigers have had two separate multi decade streaks of not contending for premierships:

1945 to 1966 - 0 finals wins (over 2 decades)
1983 to 2016 - 2 finals win (over 3 decades)

I'm tipping a 4 decade period of non contention, of which they are are 4 years into.

Any wonder Carlton and Richmond supporters are besties. Misery needs company.

 

[Fadge]

Why would he join a sinking ship though?

Go back through the history of the game and inform us any stage during which the Collingwood ship has 'sunk'?

Meanwhile, the Carlton ship has been anchored to the shore for the last quarter of a century...

 

[Worm4]

Go back through the history of the game and inform us any stage during which the Collingwood ship has 'sunk'?

Meanwhile, the Carlton ship has been anchored to the shore for the last quarter of a century...

If you think history repeats itself , Carlton are in for a wonderful period . Last time we had a drought, we went hard with multiple premierships

 

[Fadge]

If you think history repeats itself , Carlton are in for a wonderful period . Last time we had a drought, we went hard with multiple premierships

'Desperation'.

Collingwood as a football club has always evolved with the times and consistently proven they know what it takes to be regular premiership contenders... since the very first season of the competition.

Carlton meanwhile...

 

[HeathySure]

If you think history repeats itself , Carlton are in for a wonderful period . Last time we had a drought, we went hard with multiple premierships

the difference is you dont have the benefactors to fund the illegal cheating premierships you won during that period now.

 

[VinnieB]

The Tigers have had two separate multi decade streaks of not contending for premierships:

1945 to 1966 - 0 finals wins (over 2 decades)
1983 to 2016 - 2 finals win (over 3 decades)

I'm tipping a 4 decade period of non contention, of which they are are 4 years into.

Any wonder Carlton and Richmond supporters are besties. Misery needs company.

Hard to think of a team where their best players are all wanting to leave. The club is back to their basket case level. Only a matter of time before