Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Worm4]

Are you aware there is a 31% probability that their current 29 year premiership drought will extend to 50 years and beyond?

 

[Worm4]

Significant numbers from a Carlton supporter's perspective in the 21st Century:
0 - Times a premiership contender.
1 - Number of Preliminary Finals played.
5 - Wooden Spoons.
31 - Percentage probability that their current premiership drought extends to 50 years and beyond.
49 - Age of their youngest premiership player.
60 - Number of points given up to their opponent (Brisbane) before they scored themselves in their most recent game.

Any other significant numbers I should add to the list?

5 - the number of times they have beaten Collingwood in a Grand Final
Quite significant I believe

 

[Fadge]

5 - the number of times they have beaten Collingwood in a Grand Final
Quite significant I believe

My stats are relating to the current millennium, not ancient history.

Unfortunately Carlton haven't given Collingwood the opportunity to square that ledger this century...

We've played in plenty of them, where have Carlton been?

 

[Worm4]

How deluded are Carlton?

Not willing to use their #10 pick this year to get Houston, but willing to offer their 1st and 2nd round picks next year, which will be in the order of picks 5 and 23...

How deluded are you ?
Are you "in the know" or something ?
There is plenty to play out don't ya think ??

 

[T2B_]

I'm not sure a team can ever have too many elite ball users like Dan Housten.

Interesting decision to risk losing him to pick up a kid who may or may not make it - and if Carlton's time is now with your top 5 players in the prime age window - you may be missing an opportunity...

So if, for some weird reason, the Blues completely back flip and pay up for DH, you'll laude it?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

So if, for some weird reason, the Blues completely back flip and pay up for DH, you'll laude it?

He's worth pick 10 imo, given it might end up being pick 14-16 after FS and academy matched bids

 

[Robertio]

So if, for some weird reason, the Blues completely back flip and pay up for DH, you'll laude it?

I will like to see his answer as well mate.

 

[Robertio]

He's worth pick 10 imo, given it might end up being pick 14-16 after FS and academy matched bids

No argument there but obviously the Carlton boys have their eye on someone.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

No argument there but obviously the Carlton boys have their eye on someone.

In fact it's already dropped to pick 12, in free-fall

 

[Robertio]

In fact it's already dropped to pick 12, in free-fall

These free agency picks are dubious.

 

[Fadge]

So if, for some weird reason, the Blues completely back flip and pay up for DH, you'll laude it?

Indeed I would.

Your best players are at their peak age.

If Carlton are going to contend, the time is now.

No point thinking about 5 years into the future.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

These free agency picks are dubious.

Has to be a better system when you're getting pick 8 for a turd like Battle

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Significant numbers from a Carlton supporter's perspective in the 21st Century:
0 - Times a premiership contender.
1 - Number of Preliminary Finals played.
5 - Wooden Spoons.
31 - Percentage probability that their current premiership drought extends to 50 years and beyond.
49 - Age of their youngest premiership player.
60 - Number of points given up to their opponent (Brisbane) before they scored themselves in their most recent game.

Any other significant numbers I should add to the list?

8
for 8 coaches in 24 years.

14
For the 14% win ratio against Collingwood this century.

24
For 24 years since they finished top 4.

 

[Fadge]

8
for 8 coaches in 24 years.

14
For the 14% win ratio against Collingwood this century.

24
For 24 years since they finished top 4.

Love it.

Will update my post.

(Does the 8 coaches include the caretakers? Surely not...)

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Love it.

Will update my post.

(Does the 8 coaches include the caretakers? Surely not...)

15 if you include the caretakers.

Add:
3
On average Carlton has changed coach every 3 years this century .

What a basket case.
Oh my!

 

[Worm4]

15 if you include the caretakers.

Add:
3
On average Carlton has changed coach every 3 years this century .

What a basket case.
Oh my!

Add 2 - the amount of Whanquors currently talking up stats that don't matter

 

[Fadge]

I've added another one:

'17 - The number of Carlton supporting posters who took great offence when I refused to regard Carlton as a 2024 premiership contender midway through the season when they were second favourites for the premiership and second on the ladder.'

 

[Arr0w]

1: The worst analysis/predictions I've seen from an opposition supporter in the last 3 years.

So bad that any betting agency could live comfortably off one person

 

[carlton_99]

He's worth pick 10 imo, given it might end up being pick 14-16 after FS and academy matched bids

I believe Port want more than just a single pick but they obviously may drop their demands as we get closer to next Wednesday

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I believe Port want more than just a single pick but they obviously may drop their demands as we get closer to next Wednesday

Not sure about that, tasty potential recruit, feels like a bidding war, they may INCREASE their demands

 

[carlton_99]

Not sure about that, tasty potential recruit, feels like a bidding war, they may INCREASE their demands

Don't let Adam Cooney find out - he'll put Daicos in the mega trade for Houston

 

[Robertio]

15 if you include the caretakers.

Add:
3
On average Carlton has changed coach every 3 years this century .

What a basket case.
Oh my!

What a laugh, are you the no name Fadge.

 

[Robertio]

I've added another one:

'17 - The number of Carlton supporting posters who took great offence when I refused to regard Carlton as a 2024 premiership contender midway through the season when they were second favourites for the premiership and second on the ladder.'

Give us something new mate.

 

[jooce8891]

Indeed I would.

Your best players are at their peak age.

If Carlton are going to contend, the time is now.

No point thinking about 5 years into the future.

its bad when im agreeing with fadgey

 

[CarmenSandiego]

I'm fine with missing Houston but wouldn't be thrilled if he got to Collingwood.

He'd make them a much better side, perfect for their game plan that relies on a rebound game.