Toast Carlton's best 22 retreads

[goalsquarecloke]

I love being to able spot a troll and a muppet in one post.

Hogg played for Victoria.

Manton owned Lloyd.

Murphy played 115 games.

Represented us in finals and a Grand Final.

Parkin rated Justin Murphy as one of the best kicks at Carlton.

I was worried for a minute...

I expected you to name Corey McKernan.

French was a warrior.

Our worst 22 retreads would come from the last seven seasons.

Hogg was good for when he was on Bewick, you cant tell me everyone who has played for Victoria has been good!

Manton owned Lloyd...delusional

Murphy the Richmond sorry Blue sorry Cat sorry blue again...good players normally do change clubs 4 times

French a warrior who just couldnt kick. mark or play!

 

[SMOO]

Barnaby was no great but gave our club bloody good service when we were at our lowest ebb

 

[Silvagnis]

Hogg was good for when he was on Bewick, you cant tell me everyone who has played for Victoria has been good!

Manton owned Lloyd...delusional

Disagree.

I can recall Manton having a few good games on Lloyd and punching above his weight.

Beaumont too.

Murphy the Richmond sorry Blue sorry Cat sorry blue again...good players normally do change clubs 4 times

How many players get to 115 games?

You're as bright as your username.

Murphy did his knee in the 1999 GF and was sent packing the next year.

We got a good pick, but it was a stupid decision to move Murphy on.

French a warrior who just couldnt kick. mark or play!

You'll fit right in here with cattle_prod and the rest. :spade:

 

[Blue Dimension]

Manton used to give Lloyd hell back in the day. Used to minimalise his output massively.

 

[Silvagnis]

Manton was only McKay's size, but he had a massive leap.

Manton could dunk like a maniac if your saw the footage of him doing every trick in the book.

 

[dumb]

my favorite manton games were when he played a forward tag on a half-back buckley. keep him quiet, sneak a goal.

 

[Silvagnis]

Why does every thread on BF go off topic and attract idiots?

 

[dumb]

Why does every thread on BF go off topic and attract idiots?

is that in reference to my last post? i can remember those manton HF games quite clearly, i'm not making it up. as for other posts i've made... they weren't deadly serious, but i didn't know that was such a crime. i was bringing to light some players that maybe were forgotten. arceri was no good, but definitely has novelty value.

 

[goalsquarecloke]

Manton was only McKay's size, but he had a massive leap.

Manton could dunk like a maniac if your saw the footage of him doing every trick in the book.

Lucky we recruit players who dunk then!! gee, you won me over with that!
Mckay's size but again not a tenth the footballer. Manton did have a wonderful armguard...

Can i add Lachlan Henderson to the list too....hear he can lay up and is good from inside the paint!