Strategy Changes & Pre-match Discussion - PF vs. GWS, MCG 22/9 7:50pm

[Jen2310]

Lets get through the prelim, and then deal with if adams is right for a potential GF or not. One week at a time.

 

[bunter]

Poor bugger,
surely with his history he won’t be risked if we make the GF.
could macrea fill his spot?

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

And can we make it a rule no one openly brags about our full healthy list again.

Just keep it to yourself.

 

[Scodog10]

Poor bugger,
surely with his history he won’t be risked if we make the GF.
could macrea fill his spot?

No.

 

[Jen2310]

Poor bugger,
surely with his history he won’t be risked if we make the GF.
could macrea fill his spot?

Wouldn't think they'd throw him to the wolves this time of year. Any other game, probably. But I'd rather he focus on breaking into the team early next year.

 

[bunter]

No.

How come?
do you think we could cover it from existing mids?

 

[Piewithsauce13]

I get so triggered by the ****ers who laugh and make shit comments when someone gets injured! I need to stay off social media not good for my anger.

 

[bunter]

Wouldn't think they'd throw him to the wolves this time of year. Any other game, probably. But I'd rather he focus on breaking into the team early next year.

Ok, sounds like he’s not quite ready for it?

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

How come?
do you think we could cover it from existing mids?

Yes. Adams out. Nick in. It's pretty simple.

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Look on the bright side it saves more selection heartbreak for the Prelim

 

[Jen2310]

Ok, sounds like he’s not quite ready for it?

If he had played more games this year, maybe. But he's had limited exposure, so would be quite tough I reckon.

 

[Jen2310]

Look on the bright side it saves more selection heartbreak for the Prelim

Yup, pretty straight forward now at least.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Ok, sounds like he’s not quite ready for it?

He's not ready for a Prelim. Played one senior game this year against a team we were always going to smash. Laid some great tackles. He's not coming in for Adams.

 

[Mostfamousclub_Pies]

That one time when we need Eddie McGuire back. This wouldn’t happen on his watch.

How do you know Jeff Brown won’t have something to say. You don’t hand to be a loud mouth to make a point.

 

[Scodog10]

How come?
do you think we could cover it from existing mids?

Macrae’s played 2 quarters of senior footy all year, he doesn’t play the same role as Adams, with Naicos to return it means we need to find someone to drop, we have midfield cover for Adams within the 23 and Noble is going to be the next man in so we’d really need 3 changes to find room for Macrae (plus I’d prefer Allan anyway).

 

[Rohan25]

How long was Darcy out...?

27 days

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Yeah, he's been a good choice. But there is always a component of luck to all decisions -- by definition, that's what a decision really is, a combination of skill, knowledge and luck.

Looking at our weaknesses, injury risks and depth issues at the end of 2022 there is no question we nailed it.

Inside mid adams and jdg are always injury risks and pendles and Sidey a year older. . Pick up a Brownlow medallist on the cheap as steak knives after losing henry
Key defence. Pick up frampton who can also ruck replacing depth lost from grundy leaving
Small forward. Needed electric pace. Hill.
Key forward. Need a bullocker to help . Mcstay

And picked up a pacy Russian at the last
Minute. Maybe that was luck, he could be a Carlton player right now but the rest were inspired picks. No luck involved.

 

[stormskye]

27 days

From Memory he missed out last two games which were dead rubbers really and then we had the finals bye. Hard to know how long he would have been out tbh. He was also running usually means a higher grade

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

27 days

And Fly had said he was probably right to go in the last game he missed, definitely would have played if that game was just a day later or a do or die match .. and then we had the bye which is included in the 27 days.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

If Tay is a declared out, that place is taken by Nick. Does Macrae come in as a possibility for sub? That would be tough on Ginnivan, but in finals the toughest of calls need to be made. Both Port and GWS have strong midfields

No.

 

[bunter]

Macrae’s played 2 quarters of senior footy all year, he doesn’t play the same role as Adams, with Naicos to return it means we need to find someone to drop, we have midfield cover for Adams within the 23 and Noble is going to be the next man in so we’d really need 3 changes to find room for Macrae (plus I’d prefer Allan anyway).

Cheers mate, sounds like the squad has the flexibility to cover his potential loss.

 

[Scud2]

Tough for Adams now being ruled out.

I’m leaning towards that it secretly balances the team better if Naicos is in with Adams out…

 

[Snakerz]

Dammit. Daicos, Ginni in.
Adams and Lippa out.

Lippa sub.

 

[Jen2310]

From Memory he missed out last two games which were dead rubbers really and then we had the finals bye. Hard to know how long he would have been out tbh. He was also running usually means a higher grade

They mentioned if there was a game in the bye week, he would have played.
Would he have played the last round? who knows.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

If Tay is a declared out, that place is taken by Nick. Does Macrae come in as a possibility for sub? That would be tough on Ginnivan, but in finals the toughest of calls need to be made. Both Port and GWS have strong midfields

Fin in or as a sub over Ginni in a final? Nah. Not a chance.