Preview Changes: R3 v Port Adelaide, Saturday April 1, 7.00pm ACDT at Adelaide Oval

[George Kramer]

Any word on Fog?

 

[MsTopG]

Surely Sloane needs to be dropped or rested he was jogging to contests within the first five minutes. * his leadership, we are heading to last place with it anyway.

He was rushed back when his knee wasn't fully healed. Every game from the trial match onwards he has looked lame. Not sure why he played but I suspect it was Slone chasing another contract. He was cooked before he did his knees so in hindsight it would have been best for both parties if he retired last year.

Nicks can't play an injured player who can't run. How would that make another fit squad member feel that a cooked bloke on one leg is being chosen over you? If Nick's continues to play him he needs to be fired earlier than I suspect he will be. I believe Sloane, Smith and Keays all need to be moved out of the AFL side. They aren't the future and if they are playing them to improve our games played numbers that's on list management. I'm tired of parts of the club covering up the for the incompetence of list management. Roo must go this year along with Nicks.

 

[thebirdman 24]

Big game next week.

Time to make a statement on underperforming players. Smith and Shoenberg to be dropped for me.

The cupboard is pretty bare, we have depth but it's not good depth. Most of our talented players are already out there.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

My point is that if we dropped Laird we wouldn't lose by 10 goals because he doesn't have as much impact on the result as people think.

This was proven last week when he played the worst game of his recent career and we were still in the game until the 4th quarter

Except that could you the reverse.

If laird had played well we would have beat gws

 

[Eagleboy2011]

Can we just get a new coach. 4 years on and still not showing team improvement.

 

[cleanhands]

Big game next week.

Time to make a statement on underperforming players. Smith and Shoenberg to be dropped for me.

The cupboard is pretty bare, we have depth but it's not good depth. Most of our talented players are already out there.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Statements are made by dropping senior players

 

[Scorpus]

Statements are made by dropping senior players

And not immediately bringing them back after 1 week

 

[ABAB]

Big game next week.

Time to make a statement on underperforming players. Smith and Shoenberg to be dropped for me.

The cupboard is pretty bare, we have depth but it's not good depth. Most of our talented players are already out there.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

How do we know if we don't play them? Taylor for Schoenberg is the obvious to see if he can transition his potential to the AFL and Cook in defense for Smith (probably too early for this since he has only started to play there).

 

[SLOWNE]

OUT: Harry, Parnell, Dragon, Smith

IN: Thilth, Jones, Gollant, Hamill

 

[Sir Ronald Mac]

OUT: Harry, Parnell, Dragon, Smith

IN: Thilth, Jones, Gollant, Hamill

So uninspiring.
Like asking me to give to a Vegetarian meal

 

[MsTopG]

Out:
Parnell inj Sloane inj Smith Schoenberg Himmelberg Keays

In:
Hamill Taylor Keane Jones Butts Sholl

Jones Butts Doedee
Hamill Keane Michalanney
Hinge Laird Dawson
Walker Murray Rachele
Rankine Fogarty Pedlar

ROB Berry Soligo

Murphy Sholl Thilthorpe Taylor

Players who would be best 22 if not for injury or suspension:
Worrell, McAdam, Parnell?
*Worrell for Jones/Hamill
*McAdam for Murphy

 

[bigman]

Out Himmelberg and Parnell

In Jones and Butts

Not on butts appearance today. He may need an operation on his shoulder

 

[BACCS]

In: Keane, Taylor, Jones, RT
Out: Smith, Schoenberg, Parnell, Himmelberg

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Not on butts appearance today. He may need an operation on his shoulder

Is this in game or on sideline ?

How was Keane ?

 

[BACCS]

Is this in game or on sideline ?

How was Keane ?

Nicks mentioned Butts has been carrying a shoulder injury for a while. Sounds like Keane was good reading the sanfl thread.

 

[bigman]

N

Is this in game or on sideline ?

How was Keane ?

ot sure Jeff but he looked
Very sore at end of game

 

[glengowan]

B: Michalanney O’Brien Jones
HB: Laird Murray Doedee
C: Soligo Dawson Rankine
HF: Sloane Walker Pedlar
F: Gollant Fogarty Cook
R: Strachan Berry Rachele
I: Thilthorpe Murphy Hateley Sholl
Sub: Hinge

 

[the big lebowski]

Seek Kill Destroy

 

[Burtonsgottago]

B: Michalanney, Murray, Hinge
HB: Doedee, Keane, Dawson
C: Sholl, Soligo, Jones
HF: Keays, Walker, Pedlar
F: Thilthorpe, Fogarty, Rankine
R: O'Brien, Rachele, Laird
I: Hamill, Berry, Taylor, Gollant
Sub: Smith

In: Keane (need a 2nd key defender), Hamill, Taylor (play talent), Jones, Gollant
Out: Himmelberg, Parnell (inj), Schoenberg, Murphy, Sloane

Yeah, why not?

 

[Burtonsgottago]

OUT: Harry, Parnell, Dragon, Smith

IN: Thilth, Jones, Gollant, Hamill

I’m sorry, who’s Dragon?

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

I’m sorry, who’s Dragon?

Himmelberg. All puff, no fire.

 

[Burtonsgottago]

OUT
Smith Schoenberg Sloane
IN
Cook Taylor Gollant

 

[aabp1978]

Out: Parnell, Schoenberg, Smith
In: Thilthorpe, Taylor, Jones

Only trying to go for realistic changes from now on. Smith has been a liability and needs to go. Would also like Sloane, ROB etc but wont happen. Himmleberg as the sub

 

[Dockzy]

So uninspiring.
Like asking me to give to a Vegetarian meal

This MacDonalds Schtick is cringe, give it a rest hey?

 

[CrowToon]

Umpiring changes :

Out: Ray.
In: go with 3


Razor should not ever be allowed to umpire a properly important game. Loves the sound of the crowd nearly as much as his own voice.