Preview Changes: R5 vs Carlton, Thursday April 13, 7.10pm ACST @ Adelaide Oval

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

They aren’t easy selections when McHenry did play well today and Murphy had been good last 2 weeks. Might seem easy for us, but you’re dropping two guys who are very stiff and only missing because more talented guys are returning.

They're only hard if we make them hard for ourselves

We haven't done "man selections" for a while

I know I'm generally pessimistic but I genuinely think Nicks will wuss out and not pick our strongest team this week

 

[BACCS]

They're only hard if we make them hard for ourselves

We haven't done "man selections" for a while

I know I'm generally pessimistic but I genuinely think Nicks will wuss out and not pick our strongest team this week

At least you can admit you’re pessimistic

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Great problem to have when 3-4 players have to make way for best 22 players and they'd be unlucky to be dropped.

 

[Multiballz]

Out: Schoenberg, Murphy, Butts

Sub: Sloane.

In: Fog, McAdam, Pedlar

Gollant to play back 6 for Butts( Has this been tried in SANFL?)

 

[krrzr]

IN: Fogarty, McAdam, Pedlar
OUT: Gollant, Murphy, McHenry

Although, I'd say Murphy has been better than Keays ... Just don't see us dropping Keays though

 

[BACCS]

Out: Schoenberg, Murphy, Butts

Sub: Sloane.

In: Fog, McAdam, Pedlar

Gollant to play back 6 for Butts( Has this been tried in SANFL?)

No and not a week to try it

 

[WeeBlake]

I’m happy with Gollant’s form, McAdam can play SANFL this week

 

[Scorpus]

At least we have depth, unlike Port Adelaide

 

[Mutineer]

Out Schoenberg - McHenry or Murphy Sub

 

[dogs105]

I’m happy with Gollant’s form, McAdam can play SANFL this week

It will be almost 4 weeks since his previous game. Week of SANFL, or straight back, I don't really mind.

 

[Multiballz]

Sloane has played 3.5 quarters all year. Could use the rest Im sure.

No and not a week to try it

Why? Cant be much worse than what Butts or Himmelberg have served up this year. Who is ready from the 2s?

 

[BACCS]

I don’t mind Sholl, but McHenry played a far better game today. I’m ok if we decide to drop Sholl instead of Ned.

 

[BACCS]

Sloane has played 3.5 quarters all year.


Why? Cant be much worse than what Butts or Himmelberg have served up this year. Who is ready from the 2s?

Keane or Borlase are better options

 

[Golumless]

My guess

Out: McHenry, Gollant

In: Pedlar, Fogarty.

I think we'll retain Murphy over McAdam. Seems to have found his role as a supporting tough nut in the forward 50/midfield. Other two are done-in by walk up best 22 starters coming back.

 

[Multiballz]

Keane or Borlase are better options

Borlase, really? Geez he must have come along well this year.

 

[baldandbroke]

I’m happy with Gollant’s form, McAdam can play SANFL this week

Huh? McAdam was great before the bullshit 3 weeks.

 

[Executive Landlord]

Why is McAdam an automatic inclusion? Gollant showed some great signs and is way younger.

 

[Multiballz]

My guess

Out: McHenry, Gollant

In: Pedlar, Fogarty.

I think we'll retain Murphy over McAdam. Seems to have found his role as a supporting tough nut in the forward 50/midfield. Other two are done-in by walk up best 22 starters coming back.

McHenry way outplayed Murph today. If either have to play,surely we get them battling week to week for selection.

I predict neither go out.

 

[Mutineer]

Borlase, really? Geez he must have come along well this year.

He has actually looked pretty good yes and also reasonable last season.

 

[VictorianCrow85]

First time in a while I think selection decisions are gonna be tough & there's probably likely to be a couple fairly unlucky players.

 

[VictorianCrow85]

I’m happy with Gollant’s form, McAdam can play SANFL this week

I'm happy with him but Gollant gassed out pretty early this week. Up til that point he'd looked really good. I'd have him make way & he'd be stiff to miss out.

 

[Geoffa32]

Out Butts McHenry Gollant (hate saying that one)

In Keane/Borlase Pedlar Fog.


Butts is struggling. If you are not playing Borlase or even Keane now, why do we have them on the list?

We can't have Dawson playing down back.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Bearded Clam]

Out: Schoenberg, Murphy, Butts

Sub: Sloane.

In: Fog, McAdam, Pedlar

Gollant to play back 6 for Butts( Has this been tried in SANFL?)

Nope..

and gollant playing defence is just about the last thing that will happen..

also.. no SANFL games next week so you’d think Keane might be a chance..

 

[krrzr]

Why is McAdam an automatic inclusion? Gollant showed some great signs and is way younger.

McAdam more versatile, Can play tall & small - McAdam/Pedlar are replacing smalls in Murphy/McHenry, FOG is the one replacing Gollant

Gollant's time will come, Tex can't play forever unfortunately

 

[dogs105]

Borlase, really? Geez he must have come along well this year.

Played well yesterday