Preview Changes: R8 vs Carlton - Sunday May 8, 4.10 pm ACST @ Marvel Stadium

How many changes will we make this week?


  • Total voters
    78
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Need to find a way to get Worrell in the team, 27 touches, 8 rebound 50s and held up for the final 3 quarters where South had the momentum after 1/4 time. Think he has the ability to play big or small, would be able to push Dawson further up the ground.
Shouldn't be hard since he can play nearly anywhere!
 
Out. In
Smith inj. Hinge
McHenry inj. Newchurch
Gollant (rest). Murray
Crouch. Hammill


Play Murray forward with Tex


Mcadam. Murray. Rachele
Newchurch. Berg. Tex
Hamill. Keays. Dawson
Hinge. Frampton. Jones
Doedee. Butts. Brown

1st. Rob
Hatley
Laird

Int
Berry
Murphy
Sholl
Cook


Murphy, Berry , cook to rotate thru the middle .


Another bad game for Frampton and Berg and replace them with McAsey and thilthorpe
 
Shouldn't be hard since he can play nearly anywhere!
I'd love to know what the feedback is internally for Josh. Debuted in slippery Cairns where we only rocked up for 20 minutes of footy and hasn't been seen since. Arguably been our most consistent player in the 2s over the last 12 months.
 
OUT
Smith - inj
Ned - inj
Gollant - speed
Crouch - speed
Sholl - soft

IN
Hinge - to play half back in Smith spot
Rowe
Newchurch
Hamill
Worrell - to play the Dawson defender role. Dawson to the wing.


Playing Carlton at Marvel, you need speed. No point having Gollant and Himmelberg. No point having Crouch. We have enough mids. Let's add some speed in to the mix.
 
In
Rowe (best in the sanfl would have had 10+ score involvements)
Hinge
Strachan (just hopeful)

Out
McHenry (inj)
Smith (inj)
O'Brien (omitted)

Need to get Dawson up the ground. I'd also love to push Doedee up onto a wing.
 
Out: Smith (inj), McHenry (inj), Sholl, Hately, Crouch

In: Hamill, Pedlar, Hinge, Schoenberg, Rowe


B: Brown - Butts - Doedee
HB: Hinge - Frampton - Jones
C: Dawson - Keays - Cook
HF: Murphy - Walker - Pedlar
F: Rachele - Himmelberg - McAdam
R: O’Brien - Laird - Schoenberg
Int: Berry, Hamill, Gollant, Rowe
Sub: Sholl
Emg: Newchurch, Parnell, Worrell

Brown is extremely lucky that there’s so many other changes. Smith comes in for him the following week if he stinks it up again, and we reshuffle the deck to cover his lockdown role.

Rachele probably needs a spell at some point but it would be nice to see him bounce back after 2 down games.

Gollant and Himmelberg are both lucky that Thilthorpe isn’t 100% and that Fogarty has proven he’s not AFL standard.

Rowe gets a gig purely because we need someone who can hit targets by foot and make decent decisions with ball in hand.

Parnell and Worrell are getting close. Parnell could easily be the Smith replacement but I just think Hamill has a more well rounded game and runs on the board.

Hinge in is an absolute no-brainer.

Sholl has been horrible for about 10 of the last 12 quarters so him out is also a no-brainer. He had a great impact as sub in Round 1, so maybe he does that again, or spends a month in the SANFL regaining confidence. Or maybe he’s just not that good.

It’s time to see what our young midfield can do without either of Sloane or Crouch in there.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Out: Smith (concussion), Brown, Crouch, Sholl, Himmelberg, O'Brien
In: Hinge, Parnell, Schoenberg, Worrell, Thilthorpe, Strachan

Hinge in to cover Smith, Worrell in down back freeing Dawson to move up the ground, replacing Sholl. Sub role goes to Sholl

Schoenberg in from the sub as a straight swap for Crouch who should never play again

Parnell in for Brown who has been woeful

Thilthorpe in for Himmelberg if fit
I dont mean to pick on your post specifically, but this is Adelaide. I see my kids put up a christmas list every year with all sorts of stuff they want, but they only get a small fraction. That is how i think it will roll this week..a couple of changes tops
 
I dont mean to pick on your post specifically, but this is Adelaide. I see my kids put up a christmas list every year with all sorts of stuff they want, but they only get a small fraction. That is how i think it will roll this week..a couple of changes tops
We'll bring in Hinge for Smith, Rowe for McHenry and probably drop Hately for Schoenberg as our only unforced change (if we make any)
 
Hamill for Smith (Inj) - Hamill has to come in - showed a lot of speed today. Is exactly what we will need at Marvel.
Rowe for McHenry (Inj)
Murray for Frampton - is much better defensively than Frampton. Will need it against Curnow & Mckay. Shame his kicking is awful.
Schoenberg for Hateley - Speed. Hateley has been underwhelming.
Hinge the Scholl - spend a week in the gym m8

Would really like to see Pedlar given more of a go. Would be nice to give Parnell and Worrell a game or two to see if they are ready to step up to the next level. Mcasey was much better today, is really good in the air, give him another go.
 
Based on the SANFL game

Worrell to replace Smith and provide some height coverage to Billy and Butts. Dodee to play more loose defender role

Hinge to replace Scholl

Rowe to replace McHenry

Fish and FOG played well but not enough to replace Berg. The interesting one is Gollant, looks to be fading and needing a break. Would go with FOG as a replacement

Smokey - Newchurch for Crouch with Newchurch taking Rachelle's spot and Rachelle spending more time in the middle along with Murphy
 
Worrell has to be rewarded. Has been consistently in the best in the SANFL all year. Easy replacement for Smith.

Would like to see Parnell in for Brown.

Rowe for McHenry.

You just know though it’ll be Milera for Smith, despite Worrell deserving the spot.
 
Out..........In
Smith (inj)...Hinge
McHenry(inj)....Rowe
Gollant (managed)....Fog
Sholl..Hamill
Crouch(Sub)..Schoenberg

Doedee.Butts.Brown
Hinge.Frampton.Jones
Dawson.Keays.Hamill
Cook.Walker.Rachele
McAdam.Fog.Rowe
Obrien.Berry.Laird
Murphy.Himmleberg.Hately.Schoenberg

Crouch(Med.Sub)
 
Mcasey teased enough today , I’d almost play him

What’s to lose ?

Also hinge comes in so Dawson plays wing/ mid / fwd

Hamill and Worrall must be close

Wouldn’t mind dropping brown and Chayce can play small lockdown and bring in Worrall or Hamill
 
Changes after sanfl game

Out
Smith inj McHenry inj Sholl Hately

In:
Hinge Newchurch Worrell Schoenberg

Brown Butts Doedee
Worrell Frampton Hinge
Cook Laird Dawson
Rachele Walker Murphy
Newchurch Himmelberg McAdam

ROB Keays Berry

Schoenberg Jones Crouch Gollant
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Changes: R8 vs Carlton - Sunday May 8, 4.10 pm ACST @ Marvel Stadium

Back
Top