Chris Judd leaving WCE: OFFICIAL.

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

You are dreaming mate. Gumby will be on the table, but so will your 1st rounder. Your suggestion is laughable.

Gumby won't be on the table.

Either will Ryder.

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

Where do i sign for that one? I'd do it in a heartbeat.

I'll be in that to

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

I was just thinking the same thing, mate.

To me, that would be like Deledio winning a brownlow say next year, then asking to be traded the year after.

Heartbreaking

Does Deledio want a summer job at VISY ?

 

[beaver fever]

Mark Williams, Chance Bateman and Hawks top draft pick for Judd.

Eagles will want Franklin, but the Hawks could probably sweeten the deal by sending a handy midfielder and a small forward capable of kicking 60-70 goals home to WA.

I reckon, Judd would favour Hawthorn over Carlton as well as he was from the Eastern Suburbs and they are a more likely to be a chance to be in the running for a flag over the next couple of years.

Surely hawthorn have a KP forward they could offer other than franklin.

 

[Embers]

Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

Is about as low as it gets. It will go down in history as probably one of the scummiest things ever done by a AFL footballer, Wayne Carey incident included. Regardless of what happens, Judd doesnt belong in a WCE jumper and when he comes back/if he has the guts too he will be roundly booed by most I feel.

Seeya Judd, Welcome Fev

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

Mark Williams, Chance Bateman and Hawks top draft pick for Judd.

Eagles will want Franklin, but the Hawks could probably sweeten the deal by sending a handy midfielder and a small forward capable of kicking 60-70 goals home to WA.

I reckon, Judd would favour Hawthorn over Carlton as well as he was from the Eastern Suburbs and they are a more likely to be a chance to be in the running for a flag over the next couple of years.

You don't trade handy players and a pick in the teens for a superstar.

 

[WakeUpPies]

Surely hawthorn have a KP forward they could offer other than franklin.

they could offer roughhead, lewis and their first round? too much?

 

[High Ryder]

Gumby won't be on the table.

Either will Ryder.

Why not?

Its the only way we'll get him.

 

[HoldenMCaulfield]

Since RB has a past with Chris maybe he'll try and pull this off to save his bacon?

I think it would take more than all our picks combined though.

He'd have my vote then - what a way to spend more money on the football department ?

But I (unfortunately) agree that we probably don't have (or rather - are not willing to offer) enough for a trade.

Add L Ball into the mix ? A no 2 draft pick against a no 3 draft pick ? Both possibly with OP (or something similar) ?

Oh, forget it - Baker (or Gilbert) will take care of him regardless of where he plays next year !

 

[G.F.C]

Gumby won't be on the table.

Either will Ryder.

Do i know you? You sound awfully certain about the things your saying, which is the total opposite of what i'm hearing.

Gumby yes, Ryder no.

 

[GoYouBlues]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

Is about as low as it gets. It will go down in history as probably one of the scummiest things ever done by a AFL footballer, Wayne Carey incident included. Regardless of what happens, Judd doesnt belong in a WCE jumper and when he comes back/if he has the guts too he will be roundly booed by most I feel.

Seeya Judd, Welcome Fev

Why would he want to stay at a drug infested club like the WCE?

 

[Baroclinic instability]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

YOu should be happy he stayed one more contract

He could have pissed off last time negotiations came up but he decided to stay another term and get a premiership

 

[Deledio2Conca]

Gumby won't be on the table.

Either will Ryder.

Who'll be on the table for Carlton?

I reckon you guys losing Fev will have more of an impact than you guys gaining Judd.

If you can somehow get Judd and keep Fev, look out!

Won't happen though. Unless 1 and 3 are involved.

1 + 3 + Fevola ---------> West Coast
Chris Judd + Pick 11/12 ----------> Carlton

 

[Butane]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

Is about as low as it gets. It will go down in history as probably one of the scummiest things ever done by a AFL footballer, Wayne Carey incident included. Regardless of what happens, Judd doesnt belong in a WCE jumper and when he comes back/if he has the guts too he will be roundly booed by most I feel.

Seeya Judd, Welcome Fev

. You should spit on him when he comes back to W.A for a game. Just to thank him for leading your team to a premiership.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Why not?

Its the only way we'll get him.

I'd put my life on it.

You won't be trading Gumbleton or Ryder.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Who'll be on the table for Carlton?

I reckon you guys losing Fev will have more of an impact than you guys gaining Judd.

If you can somehow get Judd and keep Fev, look out!

Won't happen though. Unless 1 and 3 are involved.

1 + 3 + Fevola ---------> West Coast
Chris Judd + Pick 11/12 ----------> Carlton

Picks #3, #20 + Bower/Kennedy

If we secure Judd with that trade.

Then lock in Kreuzer for #1.

 

[The Magenius]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

Why would he want to stay at a drug infested club like the WCE?

Well if he hangs around the women he does he will never be far from drugs.

Can't understand why he would go to carlton though, doubt west coast will talk to them if pick 1 is not on the table.

 

[beaver fever]

1 + 3 + Fevola ---------> West Coast
Chris Judd + Pick 11/12 ----------> Carlton

That trade is fair for both sides, and will make WC unstoppable.

 

[Embers]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

. You should spit on him when he comes back to W.A for a game. Just to thank him for leading your team to a premiership.

Judd didnt lead us to a premiership. WCE led Judd to a premiership. I wouldnt spit on him, but he wont get any respect from anyone at the club id imagine

 

[Greg Miller= Messiah]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

Lol cya Judd welcome Fev.
That's like saying goodbye Jennifer Hawkins, Hello Caroline Wilson

 

[BBFFC]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

Dont get bitter because he wants to leave, there is nothing wrong with the timing of the anouncement, everyone wants to know especially WCE fans.

Be grateful for what he has done for your club, move on, losing him will hurt your team alot

 

[Smiley43]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

Is about as low as it gets. It will go down in history as probably one of the scummiest things ever done by a AFL footballer, Wayne Carey incident included. Regardless of what happens, Judd doesnt belong in a WCE jumper and when he comes back/if he has the guts too he will be roundly booed by most I feel.

Seeya Judd, Welcome Fev

Fev ain't going anywhere my friend...

 

[PUSSIES_07_FLAG]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

Imagine the reception Judd will get when he plays againts the Eagles next year.

 

[__Ron_]

Aside from the banter on BigFooty, the anger, the gloating, the deal making ... this is one side of footy that grates on my nerves. The business side of it always tramples on the emotional side of it. Kids grow up idolising to these players and it can all be taken away in the blink of an eye. My sincere wish is that Judd stays with the Eagles where he belongs. If he has to go though, I would welcome him.

lol something tells me you are not entirely sincere. You seem quite happy to offload your best player at the drop of a hat to poach another sides best player. No respect for Carlton fans who think like you.

 

[Lord Eddie]

Re: Announcing your leaving 2 days after bundling out of the finals series

Is about as low as it gets. It will go down in history as probably one of the scummiest things ever done by a AFL footballer, Wayne Carey incident included. Regardless of what happens, Judd doesnt belong in a WCE jumper and when he comes back/if he has the guts too he will be roundly booed by most I feel.

Seeya Judd, Welcome Fev

i guess the contract was all that kept him in the cesspit