Opinion Chris Scott's coaching - PART III

[Landgraft]

I'd be happy to with kids developing into guns, problem is none have.

Bews, Duncan, Menz.

 

[JumpyHolden]

Bews, Duncan, Menz.

Hahaha, hardly anyone you can build a side around.

 

[JumpyHolden]

Tonight Crows beat us at our game. Nothing disastrous about that.
Bews has been managed superbly by our MC and coach. What we see now reflects that.
What I read from you reflects nothing but anger.

No tonight the crows beat us because of poor coaching, no tagging of Sloane, never started the game with a second tall to help Hawkins, Just because Danger kicked goals last week CS played him forward when it was obvious Selwood is struggling and playing duds like Murdoch doesn't help either.

 

[Landgraft]

Hahaha, hardly anyone you can build a side around.

Glad to see the goalposts steadily shifting.

 

[Vdubs]

No tonight the crows beat us because of poor coaching, no tagging of Sloane, never started the game with a second tall to help Hawkins, Just because Danger kicked goals last week CS played him forward when it was obvious Selwood is struggling and playing duds like Murdoch doesn't help either.

SS was on Sloane, then Blic. We did not win that battle.
Murdoch has not been a dud for 2 months, but dig in as soon as we have a loss.
If we had rested Danger this week, I wonder how much we would have lost by. That was my preference, but clearly, he was ok.

 

[JumpyHolden]

What I read from you reflects nothing but anger.

Forgot to answer this, you're wrong again, i'm actually happy, i backed the crows at the line.

 

[JumpyHolden]

SS was on Sloane, then Blic. We did not win that battle.
Murdoch has not been a dud for 2 months, but dig in as soon as we have a loss.
If we had rested Danger this week, I wonder how much we would have lost by. That was my preference, but clearly, he was ok.

You obviously don't read my posts, i dig in win lose or draw.

 

[David the Cat]

Tonight Crows beat us at our game. Nothing disastrous about that.
Bews has been managed superbly by our MC and coach. What we see now reflects that.
What I read from you reflects nothing but anger.

You forgot ignorance then?

 

[Vdubs]

You obviously don't read my posts, i dig in win lose or draw.

Is that right- been calling Murdoch a spud for the past 8 weeks?

 

[Vdubs]

Forgot to answer this, you're wrong again, i'm actually happy, i backed the crows at the line.

So did I but it doesn't lead to the word happy.

 

[JumpyHolden]

Is that right- been calling Murdoch a spud for the past 8 weeks?

Have always called him a spud cause that's what he is.

 

[JumpyHolden]

So did I but it doesn't lead to the word happy.

So when you win money your sad? now that makes a lot of sense NOT.

 

[Vdubs]

So when you win money your sad? now that makes a lot of sense NOT.

No $ involved. Just tipping comp. "At the line" means $ involved?

 

[JumpyHolden]

No $ involved. Just tipping comp. "At the line" means $ involved?

No $!!!!! no wonder you're a sad sod.

Yes money involved, Crows had to win by at least 11 points

Oop sorry 15 points not 11

 

[Vdubs]

No $!!!!! no wonder you're a sad sod.

Not sad at all, just don't like seeing us lose, but when it's almost inevitable, a bit easier to accept. Like our lastQ, and Harry's effort. Loved Bewsy. Always something to like.

 

[Daniel McL]

Some Cats 'fans' are terrible.

If you're going to slam our coach/players after a loss, then no worries, we lost, and when you lose you invite scrutiny.

But these posters who slam our coach/players when we lose, can at least applaud our coach/players when we win.

Yet whenever we win, these Cats 'fans' are nowhere to be seen... Or if they are it's to pick out the one or two negatives after the win, no matter how good the win was, and never picking out the positives or applauding the coach/players on their efforts.

Don't just disappear (or continue only talking crap) for however many weeks it is when we are winning, only to reappear AS SOON as we lose!

I'm disappointed in Scott & the players after tonight's performance, and I have no trouble posting that. But whenever we win I applaud Scott & the players too, and I have no trouble posting that either.

Some 'fans' only post when we lose, and that is awful, we all support the one club, and supporting a club means that we stick around in the good times/wins and the bad.

 

[RegHickeyStand]

Is that right- been calling Murdoch a spud for the past 8 weeks?

Why do you keep talking to these Hawk sockpuppets?

 

[JumpyHolden]

Some Cats 'fans' are terrible.

If you're going to slam our coach/players after a loss, then no worries, we lost, and when you lose you invite scrutiny.

But these posters who slam our coach/players when we lose, can at least applaud our coach/players when we win.

Yet whenever we win, these Cats 'fans' are nowhere to be seen... Or if they are it's to pick out the one or two negatives after the win, no matter how good the win was, and never picking out the positives or applauding the coach/players on their efforts.

Don't just disappear (or continue only talking crap) for however many weeks it is when we are winning, only to reappear AS SOON as we lose!

I'm disappointed in Scott & the players after tonight's performance, and I have no trouble posting that. But whenever we win I applaud Scott & the players too, and I have no trouble posting that either.

Some 'fans' only post when we lose, and that is awful, we all support the one club, and supporting a club means that we stick around in the good times/wins and the bad.

But my belief is he stole the 2011 flag with Bomber players, hasn't been able to develop players himself, has struggled to win finals since 2011, he's just a useless twit who won't ever win another flag. So why would I want to praise him when we win games when all I want is to see him gone.

 

[Dawn to Dark]

Want him to roll with this 22

Backs: T.Stewart, T.Lonergan, J.Kolodjashnijj
Half Backs: Z.Thuoy, L.Henderson, J.Bews
Centre: M.Blicavs, J.Selwood, S.Selwood
Half Forwards: B.Parfitt, H.Taylor, S.Menengola
Forwards: D.Menzel, T.Hawkins, D.Lang
Rucks: Z.Smith, P.Dangerfield, M.Duncan
Interchange: S.Motlop, C.Guthrie, A.Mackie, N.Cockatoo
Emergencies: J,Murdoch, T.Ruggles, J.Thurlow

 

[Dawn to Dark]

Some Cats 'fans' are terrible.

If you're going to slam our coach/players after a loss, then no worries, we lost, and when you lose you invite scrutiny.

But these posters who slam our coach/players when we lose, can at least applaud our coach/players when we win.

Yet whenever we win, these Cats 'fans' are nowhere to be seen... Or if they are it's to pick out the one or two negatives after the win, no matter how good the win was, and never picking out the positives or applauding the coach/players on their efforts.

Don't just disappear (or continue only talking crap) for however many weeks it is when we are winning, only to reappear AS SOON as we lose!

I'm disappointed in Scott & the players after tonight's performance, and I have no trouble posting that. But whenever we win I applaud Scott & the players too, and I have no trouble posting that either.

Some 'fans' only post when we lose, and that is awful, we all support the one club, and supporting a club means that we stick around in the good times/wins and the bad.

But my belief is he stole the 2011 flag with Bomber players, hasn't been able to develop players himself, has struggled to win finals since 2011, he's just a useless twit who won't ever win another flag. So why would I want to praise him when we win games when all I want is to see him gone.

With ya DanielMCL
Scott has had to semi rebuild a list and has had to move on SJ, Bartel, Chappy, Kelly to name a few. He has done extremely well and we have been competitive in finals well except for 2015, we did bow out in 13 and 14.
Don't just come on here and slander CS and be a pessimist of the club

 

[Daniel McL]

But my belief is he stole the 2011 flag with Bomber players, hasn't been able to develop players himself, has struggled to win finals since 2011, he's just a useless twit who won't ever win another flag. So why would I want to praise him when we win games when all I want is to see him gone.

I don't really give a sh*t what players he had at his disposal, the key thing is HE WON A PREMIERSHIP.

That line "Won't ever win another flag" is hilarious to me, making it sound like flags are easy to win, also whether he does or doesn't win another flag doesn't change the fact that he won a flag in the first place. So many clubs would wish they were in the position of winning a premiership and usually being in the finals year-after-year. Cats 'fans' definitely take it for granted.

But mate, even if you don't want to praise Chris Scott, you could still join in on the Autopsy threads after a win and praise some of the players, but you don't even do that...

 

[David the Cat]

But mate, even if you don't want to praise Chris Scott, you could still join in on the Autopsy threads after a win and praise some of the players, but you don't even do that...

That wouldn't fit the agenda Daniel.

 

[Nankervis brothers]

No tonight the crows beat us because of poor coaching, no tagging of Sloane, never started the game with a second tall to help Hawkins, Just because Danger kicked goals last week CS played him forward when it was obvious Selwood is struggling and playing duds like Murdoch doesn't help either.

What an insightful analysis, thanks for sharing. You really should pass this on to the club, there's so much here Scott would never have considered himself.

 

[Biggy_Boy]

I don't really give a sh*t what players he had at his disposal, the key thing is HE WON A PREMIERSHIP.

That line "Won't ever win another flag" is hilarious to me, making it sound like flags are easy to win, also whether he does or doesn't win another flag doesn't change the fact that he won a flag in the first place. So many clubs would wish they were in the position of winning a premiership and usually being in the finals year-after-year. Cats 'fans' definitely take it for granted.

But mate, even if you don't want to praise Chris Scott, you could still join in on the Autopsy threads after a win and praise some of the players, but you don't even do that...

You're right. The 2011 premiership absolves him of all criticism.

Let's all disregard 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, and 2017. Those years aren't important in assessing Scott's qualities as a coach.

 

[dazbroncos]

Hahaha, hardly anyone you can build a side around.

Ahh the classic GPS.. that would be goal post move for the new.. but you're not really new either..

" we have no new developing kids"

- Bews, Duncan, Menzel...

"Hardly anyone you can build a side around"

Ahh the GPS.. long may it continue to underpin the thinnest of crap points

Go Catters