List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion 2023

[Jen2310]

Hardly.
He played well but wasnt the only reason we won that day

the 2018 prelim? You may want to watch it again. He tore richmond apart.

 

[jamieb1983]

the 2018 prelim? You may want to watch it again. He tore richmond apart.

Yes i know he did but he wasnt the only reason we won as what the post i replied to says. We absoloutely dominated them that night. He was a part of it but not the only part of it

 

[Fat Jesus]

Yes i know he did but he wasnt the only reason we won as what the post i replied to says. We absoloutely dominated them that night. He was a part of it but not the only part of it

No one in history is ever the only part of it. Without Cox that day we would have lost. He was Wayne Carey like.
Unbelievable performance

 

[magpies42]

Interesting to see if we sit tight w 19+33 or package both to move up a pick or two to grab a player we really rate
Then just a wild swing w a very late pick

Who would take that deal is what you have to ask yourself.

 

[magpies42]

Who wouldn't want to play with Nick?

His mum and dad, I imagine Josh and most straight men…

 

[localfootylegend23]

He's 189cm & 100kg, so he's a solid, powerful unit.

Way too big, He did a ACL recently, and needed another op to fix the meniscus again not long after. Someone 189cm after this shouldn't be 100kgs, way too much duress on the joints. Needs to slim down to the low 90's

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Hey hey hey …. what’s going on with Bailey Smith and Nick Daicos? Training together over the off-season now?
Does the Pies recruiting department have Nick on a spotters fee for future trades?

Bailey Smith heading overseas with Naicos, then Harley Reid coming down to the club to train with our boys.
Smith joins us in 12 months, then Reid in 24 months. He'll last 2 years at either WC or North and want out to the Pies. ...

 

[sr36]

No one in history is ever the only part of it. Without Cox that day we would have lost. He was Wayne Carey like.
Unbelievable performance

We're going to find out soon. Kirby is currently digging up Gordon Coventry's grave. Not sure how he'll re-enact the rest of it though.

 

[Scodog10]

No one in history is ever the only part of it. Without Cox that day we would have lost. He was Wayne Carey like.
Unbelievable performance

JDG, Crisp (his night was phenomenal and got lost in the hype of Cox) and Dusty’s corkie were more influential on the night. Cox was fantastic, but not the unbelievable performance it’s revered as.

 

[Scud2]

the 2018 prelim? You may want to watch it again. He tore richmond apart.

That prelim still rates as my Pies favourite win in my lifetime.

 

[Vicky Park]

Hey a half-decent woodchop could be a laugh. But mostly I don’t like having to balance the insane tension/anxiety of a 1-point prelim with some *wads dancing for a bucket of fried chicken.

As long as it involves an O’Toole.

 

[SchuPie]

Who would take that deal is what you have to ask yourself.

That's the trouble, it would only get us up 1-2 picks
Is it worth it...?
Well, the diff bw Bont at 4 and Shaz at 6 (I know that's kind of different)
However, I always think you get the guy you want. If they have a few rated evenly, then pick at 19 - if one they love is at there at 17/18, do the trade

 

[Kirby]

We're going to find out soon. Kirby is currently digging up Gordon Coventry's grave. Not sure how he'll re-enact the rest of it though.

Apparently I could dig up the carcasses of the whole mean machine - along with Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Sir Walter Lindrum and Phar Lap, reanimate them and have them bitten by a radioactive spider, and they still wouldn’t have made a difference in that PF against the Tigers such was Coxy’s utter dominance that day.

 

[Horaceg]

No one in history is ever the only part of it. Without Cox that day we would have lost. He was Wayne Carey like.
Unbelievable performance

Best keep him away from social events

 

[JuniorB]

That's the trouble, it would only get us up 1-2 picks
Is it worth it...?
Well, the diff bw Bont at 4 and Shaz at 6 (I know that's kind of different)
However, I always think you get the guy you want. If they have a few rated evenly, then pick at 19 - if one they love is at there at 17/18, do the trade

Hawthorn did that last year to draft Weddle.

 

[Scodog10]

That's the trouble, it would only get us up 1-2 picks
Is it worth it...?
Well, the diff bw Bont at 4 and Shaz at 6 (I know that's kind of different)
However, I always think you get the guy you want. If they have a few rated evenly, then pick at 19 - if one they love is at there at 17/18, do the trade

I’d be surprised if we moved a couple of spots up using 33 because it’s an extra pick that clubs don’t have the list spots for (that’s before you even factor in who’s ahead of us). Maybe if North get the Reid deal done for 2 and 2 of the late 1sts it’s a goer, but I think that’s ultimately done with 2 and the Roos future 1st.

This late in the game I think 19 and 33 are more likely to move back to get other assets in. Let’s say Tholstrup is there at our pick and WC are all in on him so they offer “23” and “37”. I think we’ll take 3 picks at the draft so maybe it’s a deal we’d consider depending on who’s still on the board. If we’re only taking 2 picks we could then trade one of them into 2024.

 

[legendstatus]

Bailey Smith heading overseas with Naicos, then Harley Reid coming down to the club to train with our boys.
Smith joins us in 12 months, then Reid in 24 months. He'll last 2 years at either WC or North and want out to the Pies. ...

Imagine those 2 with Nick as our starting mids ( not 100% sold on Smith though)

 

[windchimes]

JDG, Crisp (his night was phenomenal and got lost in the hype of Cox) and Dusty’s corkie were more influential on the night. Cox was fantastic, but not the unbelievable performance it’s revered as.

Sidebottom was absolutely electric too. He’s always the player I’ve associated that game with the most, personally.

 

[Pistol Night]

JDG, Crisp (his night was phenomenal and got lost in the hype of Cox) and Dusty’s corkie were more influential on the night. Cox was fantastic, but not the unbelievable performance it’s revered as.

Jordy kicked 4 on Rance and was taking one handers at times. Huge game

 

[sr36]

JDG, Crisp (his night was phenomenal and got lost in the hype of Cox) and Dusty’s corkie were more influential on the night. Cox was fantastic, but not the unbelievable performance it’s revered as.

Throw in Langers, Grundy and Adams having outstanding games. It was just a great team performance.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

As long as it involves an O’Toole.

He’s still stuck down the well.

 

[Kirby]

Sidebottom was absolutely electric too. He’s always the player I’ve associated that game with the most, personally.

And how we all forget about Pendles who titted more blokes that night than Pamela Anderson.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Hardly.
He played well but wasnt the only reason we won that day

Agreed, Sidebottom brought his own ball to that game. Unfortunately it earnt him Hutchings in the GF, and we know how that went.

 

[sr36]

And how we all forget about Pendles who titted more blokes that night than Pamela Anderson.

What does than mean? Nipple cripple?

 

[Kirby]

What does than mean? Nipple cripple?

Passes hitting players on the t1t