List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[manicpie]

But, but, but he's a game changer, a finals winner type player isn't he?...why isn't anyone else interested in him?

It'll be interesting. Fly seems to want him. I'm easy either way.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Happy to pay the “$400k difference” if they hand over pick 12.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

It'll be interesting. Fly seems to want him. I'm easy either way.

Does he though? We've just been told the pick we reportedly wanted for Noble is not true. So what makes them think they know what's going on in Fly's mind?

 

[BEEG]

According to some journalists on SEN, he doesn't have many suitors. Just get him

Pies and GWS currently.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Pies and GWS currently.

What happened to Swans interest?

Personally I think he's a perfect fit for Saints.

 

[loki04]

But, but, but he's a game changer, a finals winner type player isn't he?...why isn't anyone else interested in him?

He IS a 40 goal a year forward. Not too many of those in Black and White stripes atm.

 

[manicpie]

What happened to Swans interest?

Personally I think he's a perfect fit for Saints.

I think the swans link was just journalistic assumption .

 

[manicpie]

He IS a 40 goal a year forward. Not too many of those in Black and White stripes atm.

We have all the forward defensive mechanisms in place, we need an attacking option.

 

[BEEG]

What happened to Swans interest?

Personally I think he's a perfect fit for Saints.

I'm not sure, GC had interest early days too but have cooled.

That's the latest, actually wants to get to Collingwood but will take whoever offers most years.

GWS get close to a flag I can see them offering 3.

2 is the market value currently.

 

[Anzacday]

P

3 years at 30 lol
Bit full of himself to actually think that happens once you hit 30

Talk is he’s on $400k.
Tell him we will give him $900k for 3 years and he’ll think he’s winning.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

I think the swans link was just journalistic assumption .

How do we know it all isn't?

Link a player to Pies & it's guaranteed to get clicks.

Seems like the journo's are salivating over linking us to anyone over 30. Just so they can continue to bang on about how old we are

 

[Apex36]

He did kick 42.25 this season and is not thier main target.

Have a look at what our forwards produced.

Thats because when he’s on he’s really on. I’m not going to argue about his talent, because it’s there for all to see. If he actually gave a shit he could probably be the best player in the league, I’m just not convinced he’ll ever have the motivation or discipline to reach those heights, particularly with time against him in context of his age.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

I'm not sure, GC had interest early days too but have cooled.

That's the latest, actually wants to get to Collingwood but will take whoever offers most years.

GWS get close to a flag I can see them offering 3.

2 is the market value currently.

I don't believe anything these journo's are saying tbh.

We need a young midfielder. A defender. A young kpf. Not an old fat small forward.

 

[loki04]

3 years at 30 lol
Bit full of himself to actually think that happens once you hit 30

Quite a few players get 3 years at 30yo on the dot.

It's typically the last one before the retirement cliff or 1 year deals come in.

33 in last year of deal isn't too bad if the $$ are modest. Just added to the list of dads army to retire.

 

[BEEG]

I don't believe anything these journo's are saying tbh.

We need a young midfielder. A defender. A young kpf. Not an old fat small forward.

Haha have you seen him up close?

He isn't small, very big man.

I wouldn't be against playing Mcstay down back.

 

[loki04]

Thats because when he’s on he’s really on. I’m not going to argue about his talent, because it’s there for all to see. If he actually gave a shit he could probably be the best player in the league, I’m just not convinced he’ll ever have the motivation or discipline to reach those heights, particularly with time against him in context of his age.

He really only needs to replicate that in our system imo. To add good value.
And work a bit harder defensively.

Clubs gone all in our the retirement village might as well add him to the mix.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Haha have you seen him up close?

He isn't small, very big man.

I wouldn't be against playing Mcstay down back.

He's huge, I know. But not in a good way.

 

[Apex36]

Pick 6 it is!

 

[loki04]

Haha have you seen him up close?

He isn't small, very big man.

I wouldn't be against playing Mcstay down back.

No.

Need Mcstay up front.

Imo our best team fwd set up would look like.

Hill McStay Elliott
Stringer Mihocek McCreery/Schultz

Would rotate Beau Mc on ball.

 

[cfc19902010]

I don't believe anything these journo's are saying tbh.

We need a young midfielder. A defender. A young kpf. Not an old fat small forward.

We need the 40 goals tho

 

[Eric Shin]

If Houston ends up at Carlton I can see his career going down the gutter like Saad, McGovern and Martin.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Couch Coach]

No.

Need Mcstay up front.

Imo our best team fwd set up would look like.

Hill McStay Elliott
Stringer Mihocek McCreery/Schultz

Would rotate Beau Mc on ball.

2nd ruck taking up a bench spot?

 

[Pistol Night]

If Houston ends up at Carlton I can see his career going down the gutter like Saad, McGovern and Martin.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Hes got a choice between staying at a club that shits the bed in finals or moving to a club that is just happy to be able to be in a position to shit the bed in finals

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

We need the 40 goals tho

Who says we can't get that from others on our list? First year to hopefully have both Dan & Checkers playing together. Second year for Schultz with Bobby. Billy. Beau. A fit JDG.

If he's a guaranteed 40 goals for any team, why are Bombers not wanting to keep him? Why isn't any throwing themselves at him?

He'll be 31 next year. He's known to not look after himself. Bomber supporters know how lazy & inconsistent he is. And how he only turns it on when he's contract is expiring. What a great attitude

I don't get the salivating over this bloke.

 

[Apex36]

He's huge, I know. But not in a good way.

He’s the same height and build (minus fitness) as Checkers, calling him a small forward is nonsense.