List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[sr36]

They also mentioned that if Richards leaves, what port get for Soldo, can be passed onto us.

Banana peel can be handy ...

Just sign with us Joey.

 

[Jen2310]

Banana peel can be handy ...

Just sign with us Joey.

Port will be asking for a second rounder for Soldo

 

[sr36]

Port will be asking for a second rounder for Soldo

Really? Isn't he a dud? Would anyone pay that?

 

[Jen2310]

Really? Isn't he a dud? Would anyone pay that?

Its what they paid to get him and he's contracted for 2 more years

 

[Apex36]

Fair enough but it’s debatable if Pies are desperately wanting to buy or Tigers are desperate to move pick forward. A chance a negotiated trade could happen.

Of course, this is all just hypothetical.

 

[barrackers]

They also mentioned that if Richards leaves, what port get for Soldo, can be passed onto us.

Went to port for essentially a second, third and fourth round pick last year. Soldo’s value certainly won’t have increased from that.

The Tigers have received picks 41 and 49, a future second-round pick tied to Fremantle as well as Port's future fourth-round pick in exchange for Soldo, with the Power also getting Richmond's pick 50 in return.

 

[Apex36]

They also mentioned that if Richards leaves, what port get for Soldo, can be passed onto us.

Is that a joke? Because Port aren’t getting anything of significance for Soldo, and we’d clearly want a late second for Richards at an absolute minimum.

 

[nahnah]

I really want Perryman. Signing players like Perryman without giving up anything is how we stay up the top like Geelong have imo

 

[sr36]

Its what they paid to get him and he's contracted for 2 more years

Is there a club chasing him?

 

[manicpie]

I think he struggles against the really big forwards

There's certainly something holding him back. I get the same feeling as you though.

 

[Harry O]

2025 likely to be his final year




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Doubt it

 

[Stripes B and W]

Is that a joke? Because Port aren’t getting anything of significance for Soldo, and we’d clearly want a late second for Richards at an absolute minimum.

Wouldn't you actually give something with the Soldo trade rather than get anything back...

 

[Pistol Night]

I really want Perryman. Signing players like Perryman without giving up anything is how we stay up the top like Geelong have imo

Except we have to target free agents. They play the sympathy card that anyone born outside of Melbourne wants to “come home” to Shitlong for the love of it rather than the dodgey 3rd party deal

 

[Harry O]

Just heard that bit lol sounds a bit of he said, she said

Place more credibility in it than a Jon Ralph article

 

[Jen2310]

Is there a club chasing him?

St Kilda. Has indicated it's where he wants to get to, and they want him.
They have pick 24

 

[nahnah]

Except we have to target free agents. They play the sympathy card that anyone born outside of Melbourne wants to “come home” to Shitlong for the love of it rather than the dodgey 3rd party deal

any wannabe farmer goes to Geelong we should be front and centre for the rest

 

[sr36]

Is that a joke? Because Port aren’t getting anything of significance for Soldo, and we’d clearly want a late second for Richards at an absolute minimum.

Future second I think. My hope for this trade period is Noble and a future first out to give us a decent hand in this draft. Perryman and a cheap stop gap KPD added and Richards out for a future second for McGuane points. But won't mind if we go all in on the short term with Houston.

 

[SchuPie]

He is a random SEN text for you
Cadman has been in contact with vic clubs, and his family are big pies fans

Good work, Jen

This is how it’s done, manicpie

You know how I wanted to trade our F1 into 2024?!
HOLD THE PHONE!

 

[Sweeetleftfoot]

We need good young players and Houston is 29 so probably past his prime especially for Price Port would want for him

Houston is 27 plenty of good years left.

 

[Harry O]

It is actually depressing that 12 months after landing a premiership, we cannot even attract a Perryman (not a star) to our club.

I am happy the club is not paying overs, as I want players driven by success and not money.

If he chooses Port now, this will be Damien Drum all over again

 

[Jen2310]

Future second I think. My hope for this trade period is Noble and a future first out to give us a decent hand in this draft. Perryman and a cheap stop gap KPD added and Richards out for a future second for McGuane points. But won't mind if we go all in on the short term with Houston.

F2 would be ideal as we'll need more picks in the 20's/30's to match a 1st rounder.

 

[sr36]

St Kilda. Has indicated it's where he wants to get to, and they want him.
They have pick 24

Would you pay up for him if you were the Saints? THey've got a gun first ruck and neither he or Soldo are much of a forward.

 

[SchuPie]

Well that settles it Cadman to Geelong.

We can still buy him a farm!

 

[manicpie]

Houston is 27 plenty of good years left.

We retire them early here

 

[Jen2310]

Would you pay up for him if you were the Saints? THey've got a gun first ruck and neither he or Soldo are much of a forward.

Their next pick is 43, not sure port will accept that.
But saints apparantely think they can play them both. Alongside Marshall.