List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[ElliottsMaggies]

Surely off the hook now.
Well done to Treloar, he’s having a stellar year.

We still owe him what we owe him. Makes no difference to us that he's signed an extension.

 

[Seedsfan]

This year? Not 2025?

Nobody actually knows. The most information anyone ever got was 1.5 over 5. Yet how that plays out is between the dogs and us. We could have paid him nothing for the first two years there and then 500k each for the last 3. We may have paid 750k for the first two years and nothing since.

Sure we are told it averages out to 300k a year

 

[magpies42]

G'day Pies fans,

Someone over on our board has said that a punter called into SEN suggesting Sam Berry might be heading your way. Absolutely no idea what sort of credence to lend it, but seeing as there's been a fair amount of recent chat in here about guys like Alex Davies, figured I'd take a temperature check. He's behind Matt Crouch and Rory Laird but has put in a decent couple of performances lately with bulk mid minutes. Could be an option for you guys as Mitchell and Crisp begin to age out?

Strikes me as a Taylor Adam’s type, hard at it…but lacking pace and skill?

We definitely have a need, with Mitchell close to the end and Carmichael Hunt recently retiring. Problem is we have nothing to give.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Nobody actually knows. The most information anyone ever got was 1.5 over 5. Yet how that plays out is between the dogs and us. We could have paid him nothing for the first two years there and then 500k each for the last 3. We may have paid 750k for the first two years and nothing since.

Sure we are told it averages out to 300k a year

Perhaps we have paid it all out already, or maybe we still owe him some $.

But the original poster had asked what Treloar's extension meant for us. It means nothing as far as what we do or don't owe Treloar.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Just had a read of the crows board, delusional some of them thinking they will get a future first for Keane

 

[Jen2310]

Just had a read of the crows board, delusional some of them thinking they will get a future first for Keane

everyone is the next superstar when trying to fleece us.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Just had a read of the crows board, delusional some of them thinking they will get a future first for Keane

Tell them to get fooked.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

everyone is the next superstar when trying to fleece us.

Yeah stuff that, walk away if that’s what they ask for. I’d prefer to try and get back into this draft as it’s supposedly strong

 

[jmac70]

What do people think is a fair deal for Keane?

 

[Caztheconquerer]

What do people think is a fair deal for Keane?

Not a first rounder that’s for sure

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

What do people think is a fair deal for Keane?

A pint of Guinness.

 

[TheVillageIdiot7]

G'day Pies fans,

Someone over on our board has said that a punter called into SEN suggesting Sam Berry might be heading your way. Absolutely no idea what sort of credence to lend it, but seeing as there's been a fair amount of recent chat in here about guys like Alex Davies, figured I'd take a temperature check. He's behind Matt Crouch and Rory Laird but has put in a decent couple of performances lately with bulk mid minutes. Could be an option for you guys as Mitchell and Crisp begin to age out?

Holy cow!!
Nice player. But not worth much.

Since he’s in you delist territory, doubt anything other than a 3rd or 4th gets its done.

Happy for you to keep him.

 

[PieBeast]

Just had a read of the crows board, delusional some of them thinking they will get a future first for Keane

KPD's are a massive need for us given we only have Moore and Frampton and Dean is a VFL player at best, we also paid more than a future first rounder for Shultz....

 

[satanshoof101]

Cal Twomey said with Essendon having a stacked midfield Tsatas might be gettable. He would be a perfect player to sit next to Naicos for the next 10 years. Tsatas trained with us in his draft year and I heard mumbles of trying to get Essendon's pick to take him.

 

[loki04]

This year? Not 2025?

Was off the top of my head, I thought it ended end of 24 but looks end of 25 going off the next post after yours.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

KPD's are a massive need for us given we only have Moore and Frampton and Dean is a VFL player at best, we also paid more than a future first rounder for Shultz....

It may be a need for us but trading away future firsts has not been good for us. Next years first could be a top 10 pick and there’s no way Keane is worth that imo

 

[Jen2310]

It may be a need for us but trading away future firsts has not been good for us. Next years first could be a top 10 pick and there’s no way Keane is worth that imo

No way would it be a F1. Late 2nd maybe. A pick in the late 20's early 30s?
or wait til he is OOC next year

 

[Mollythedolly]

Players of influence - leadership group and or Harley Reid.

Cannot be giving up a second round draft pick for Keane. That is too much.

If people believe Keane is a second rounder then what would we get for Quaynor, McCreery and John Noble?

We were talking about Simpson & the Weagles. Not sure how Keane is relevant to that.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

No way would it be a F1. Late 2nd maybe. A pick in the late 20's early 30s?
or wait til he is OOC next year

Yep that’s what I’m saying, no way to a first for Keane

 

[PieBeast]

It may be a need for us but trading away future firsts has not been good for us. Next years first could be a top 10 pick and Athere’s no way

Just playing the devils advocate, the way we've been operating of late future first for Keane from us would be business as usual....

 

[TheVillageIdiot7]

It may be a need for us but trading away future firsts has not been good for us. Next years first could be a top 10 pick and there’s no way Keane is worth that imo

I was fine with us trading our future first last year. After winning it, reasonable to think it’s 13+.
No one could foresee what has happened this year. Insane!
But even still, the decision was solid.

regardless of that, I’d def be holding next year as it is more likely to be top 8 than 13-18.
And I’m usually all for trading firsts!!
Caveat is who is available!
.

 

[Mollythedolly]

Blame Hine for that.

Yeah, couldn’t believe he didn’t get more than 2 players at the ND last year with the 2 picks he was given to use.

 

[JLC]

We were talking about Simpson & the Weagles. Not sure how Keane is relevant to that.

I spoke about multiple topics in one post. Maybe I am ahead of my time.

 

[Harry O]

A fair few Crows fans aren't pleased that he's behind them in the pecking order, particularly behind Laird. Berry's decent. As I said, no idea if there's anything to it, but I could see it working. He's out of contract.

Berry would be a good fit for Pies. A Newcombe style bull to ride shotgun with Nick

 

[Harry O]

What do people think is a fair deal for Keane?

Jakob Ryan or maybe a future second