List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[stormskye]

Is there any benefit to North not signing him now? Or for him?

He will get bigger offers end of next season if he waits. Bigger $ and a way out

 

[Carlthetruth]

His absence after the 2022 trade period was delightful. It’s a shame he can’t learn from his mistakes.

Monitoring people's posts is creepy AF, like strutting around bigfooty thinking you're the Apex predator. You don't like being told you're wrong and being proven wrong, it's just the truth.

 

[rdangelo]

Schultz always copping a lot of flack. He plays one of the hardest positions on the ground for consistency and will only get better in year 2.

One thing he needs to do is relax a bit, he's always going a hundred miles an hour. Needs to be more cool in his decision making.

 

[Apex36]

Monitoring people's posts is creepy AF, like strutting around bigfooty thinking you're the Apex predator. You don't like being told you're wrong and being proven wrong, it's just the truth.

Keep that rage wank going Carl, you’re doing great.

 

[DopeMaster]

Revised list of cheap(ish) targets: Wright, Peatling, Keane, Cumming.

If Richards does go to Port, what to we need to add to the trade to get Bergman coming back?

2-3 of the above would be a bit like the Hill/Framps/Lippa/Mitch trade period IMO. Targeted value acquisitions where sum is greater than parts.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

He will get bigger offers end of next season if he waits. Bigger $ and a way out

That's what we're all hoping for..

 

[Go Woods]

Knew it wouldn’t take long after last nights game.

From the Eagles board:

“Darling plus f2 to pies for Ed Allan? No way they’d accept that but wishful thinking. Chesser was a pies fan if we ever do want to do a straight swap”

Why the F would we want Darling?

FM, Darling, isn't he out to pasture yet?

 

[asongofnightsandliars]

Revised list of cheap(ish) targets: Wright, Peatling, Keane, Cumming.

If Richards does go to Port, what to we need to add to the trade to get Bergman coming back?

2-3 of the above would be a bit like the Hill/Framps/Lippa/Mitch trade period IMO. Targeted value acquisitions where sum is greater than parts.

Wright - is as medicore a key forward as there is, he's in and out of essendons team and that says alot

Peatling - could be a good acquisition if cheape, no guarantee he would get game time though

Keane - so long as he's cheap its a decent enough trade, not 100% lock to play, and always the threat he packs up for Ireland so idk

Cumming - is an ufa so really we'd be competing with clubs for how much we'd pay him and how long the contract is. Could be a good shout

Bergman - huge fan of his, and if Richards goes that way we should definitely try and package him with a pick to get Miles. If Richards was worth pick 50, the combination of that + our first pick in the 30s is the equivalent of pick 22ish. And that's lowballing Richards' value at pick 50. I definitely think it's possible to send a current or future 2nd rounder with Richards for Bergman

On SM-A146P using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[VinnieB]

Knew it wouldn’t take long after last nights game.

From the Eagles board:

“Darling plus f2 to pies for Ed Allan? No way they’d accept that but wishful thinking. Chesser was a pies fan if we ever do want to do a straight swap”

Why the F would we want Darling?

And Chesser is rubbish.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

My two favourite words this time of year are bundle & package.

 

[DopeMaster]

Wright - is as medicore a key forward as there is, he's in and out of essendons team and that says alot

Peatling - could be a good acquisition if cheape, no guarantee he would get game time though

Keane - so long as he's cheap its a decent enough trade, not 100% lock to play, and always the threat he packs up for Ireland so idk

Cumming - is an ufa so really we'd be competing with clubs for how much we'd pay him and how long the contract is. Could be a good shout

Bergman - huge fan of his, and if Richards goes that way we should definitely try and package him with a pick to get Miles. If Richards was worth pick 50, the combination of that + our first pick in the 30s is the equivalent of pick 22ish. And that's lowballing Richards' value at pick 50. I definitely think it's possible to send a current or future 2nd rounder with Richards for Bergman

On SM-A146P using BigFooty.com mobile app

Agree for the most part.

Wright has been below average for a while, but also has shown he’s capable of winning a club b and f
- so upside is there. If he could be had for a 3rd rounder as a Cox ‘succession plan’ then I’d consider it.

Would pull the trigger on Richard’s and a 2nd for Bergman is a heartbeat if Richard’s requested a trade.

Keane for a 3rd I’d do. We’ve really missed Murphy structurally, and whilst Keane is no Murph, he fills the hole. I’m increasingly disillusioned with Framps who has a good moment every now and then followed by multiple head scratchers.

I’m torn between bringing in an extra mid like Peatling or backing in Allan w Long as backup for a development year. Wish we’d seen more of Allan at backend of season as one game against witches hats is not a big enough sample size.

Cumming I’d be strongly pursuing.

 

[Fat Jesus]

Agree for the most part.

Wright has been below average for a while, but also has shown he’s capable of winning a club b and f
- so upside is there. If he could be had for a 3rd rounder as a Cox ‘succession plan’ then I’d consider it.

Would pull the trigger on Richard’s and a 2nd for Bergman is a heartbeat if Richard’s requested a trade.

Keane for a 3rd I’d do. We’ve really missed Murphy structurally, and whilst Keane is no Murph, he fills the hole. I’m increasingly disillusioned with Framps who has a good moment every now and then followed by multiple head scratchers.

I’m torn between bringing in an extra mid like Peatling or backing in Allan w Long as backup for a development year. Wish we’d seen more of Allan at backend of season as one game against witches hats is not a big enough sample size.

Cumming I’d be strongly pursuing.

I strongly pursue that daily.

 

[No SPIN]

Yeah after he played a decent 5 minutes.

It’s the 5 minutes that haunts you because of what your forsee in 2025 - which is egg all over your face.

 

[No SPIN]

My two favourite words this time of year are bundle & package.

How about Mega Trade?

 

[Mollythedolly]

Drinking before lunchtime is ok by me. But some disapprove. Next time be less obvious.

Brunch is just an excuse to wake up late and drink early. Nothing to see here....

 

[soreplums]

Tell us.

I’m waiting for someone else to back it up, but for once we could come out well ahead on a deal without offering much and it could open up many other trade possibilities as well.

 

[DopeMaster]

I’m waiting for someone else to back it up, but for once we could come out well ahead on a deal without offering much and it could open up many other trade possibilities as well.

I’ll back it up If you say what it is.

 

[Exambolor]

I’m waiting for someone else to back it up, but for once we could come out well ahead on a deal without offering much and it could open up many other trade possibilities as well.

And with the other rumours we hear it’ll probably be radio silence after that

List managers don’t read social media for trade ideas so I dunno why everyone is so secretive with rumours

 

[TradeDraft]

We haven't been seriously linked to anyone this year.

Mid Season there was big Talk we get Lobb but nothing Recent

 

[JuniorB]

Hmm I didn't see that in the games I viewed. But very early in his development so hopefully they are now stand out traits.

It's easy to forget that he's still only 19.

 

[coolidge1000]

I've heard that apparently petraca and his management are investigating through solicitors if they have a right to break the contract due to medical negligence. I'm not saying it will happen but apparently that's where this all sits I'm guessing the AFL are involved where this all lands I don't have a clue

 

[Fat Jesus]

I've heard that apparently petraca and his management are investigating through solicitors if they have a right to break the contract due to medical negligence. I'm not saying it will happen but apparently that's where this all sits I'm guessing the AFL are involved where this all lands I don't have a clue

I mentioned this. Medical negligence.
I'm no lawyer but I'd think this has legs.

 

[sr36]

Wright - is as medicore a key forward as there is, he's in and out of essendons team and that says alot

Peatling - could be a good acquisition if cheape, no guarantee he would get game time though

Keane - so long as he's cheap its a decent enough trade, not 100% lock to play, and always the threat he packs up for Ireland so idk

Cumming - is an ufa so really we'd be competing with clubs for how much we'd pay him and how long the contract is. Could be a good shout

Bergman - huge fan of his, and if Richards goes that way we should definitely try and package him with a pick to get Miles. If Richards was worth pick 50, the combination of that + our first pick in the 30s is the equivalent of pick 22ish. And that's lowballing Richards' value at pick 50. I definitely think it's possible to send a current or future 2nd rounder with Richards for Bergman

On SM-A146P using BigFooty.com mobile app

Is this the product of the current points system that is being changed because it's way out of kilter with too much value attached to later picks?

 

[JuniorB]

FM, Darling, isn't he out to pasture yet?

And a straight swap for Chesser?
What are they smoking?

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

I hate it when posters do this, and then don't reveal said rumour, means it's most likely nonsense

You see it on Twitter too, some accounts saying 'Pies getting a big player' people ask and then they say "Nah can't reveal it or else rival list managers will see it" and their account has like 100 followers

Because it's just rumour and not fact