List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[Bianconeri]

Trac or B King?

Trac, get B King in free agency after Mihocek retires

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Don't forget TJ

I didnt

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Honestly Parker being shoehorned back in to the side for the last couple of rounds makes more sense now.

So does Markov getting an extension

 

[loki04]

Yes you are right.

Josh is generally a better ball user but lacks the genuine leg speed of a Noble/Markov. But maybe the better ball user makes sense.

Timing can make up for it, Josh has proven very capable as qb role off hb

 

[Bianconeri]

Yes you are right.

Josh is generally a better ball user but lacks the genuine leg speed of a Noble/Markov. But maybe the better ball user makes sense.

He’s a touch slower than Markov but he breaks more lines regardless.

 

[Scodog10]

The hawk tuah treatment as described sounded quite pleasant?

If you’re that way inclined I’m sure it could be! As a hetero male not so much.

Bianconeri 6 gets you a seat at the table. It’ll take a lot more to get a deal done.

 

[HFF]

We will have enough options to be able to go back there
As has been mentioned, we already have Quarnor and Maynard as mainstays
Parker is showing a bit
Markov is good depth
Demattia should be looking to make this a spot for himself as he learns his craft off half back

 

[nahnah]

JFN was a solid foot soldier but always felt a liability in finals and correctly dropped last year imo

 

[Bianconeri]

If you’re that way inclined I’m sure it could be! As a hetero male not so much.

Bianconeri 6 gets you a seat at the table. It’ll take a lot more to get a deal done.

That’s what I thought I just think I have a different hawk tuah in mind

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Can't say l am shocked, but certainly a bit flat to lose Nobes. Has been an unbelievable pick up in that 2019 mid-season draft.
The GC are getting him at his prime, at only 27 years old, and he will be a mainstay of their side for years to come.
This may open up for us an opportunity to try and somehow package up picks 13 and 20 from the Suns.
Thanks Nobes for everything you gave to this footy club over the years. Going to miss those dashes off HB, and everytime you wore the guernsey, you gave your all. From smothers, to lunging tackles to busting a gut to keep running and kick a goal on the run.....

 

[JuniorB]

Definitely not a pies supporter. More likely a certain deranged St Kilda supporter that hasn’t gotten over 2010 still, or a Suns supporter.

Leigh Montagna?

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Given he is contracted we HAVE to surely aim to get something of value to make other moves.

Well he will be an important player for them off HB, and you feel will be a mainstay of their side. He has to go for a higher end draft pick....

 

[LuckyLee]

Surely such meetings don’t occur in places as public as cafes?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

I don't recall us ever getting any of the famed Suns trading largesse, so maybe it's time. Maybe Noble and Hawks second rounder for 20

It will be pick 28 after F/S academy picks.

 

[Axl the great]

I know it’s nothing alike but I remember everyone cracking the shits when Hogan was mentioned as a trade target from Freo. Peter Wright was laughed at. We seem to be willing to accept certain Coleman medallist’s or nothing. I’m not advocating getting Lynch specifically but 31 for a KPF isn’t washed up and if he got his body right he’d help us enormously. Plus imagine the shit we could give Richmond while they’re winning spoons

Fully fit, Lynch is a gun and one of the top forwards in the game.
You would be stupid to not explore it.

 

[petrie pie]

I am shocked with the lack of empathy from Lyon and Melbourne. They are trying to play the victim which is shocking. Petracca has trauma and mental health issues which he has to overcome. He was told he might not make it.

I want Petracca at the Pies and maybe being with his mates at the Pies is best for him. He may need to sit out to do it

The Carlton McKay talk is bullshit created by scum media supporters who hate the fact he wants to be a Pie. They are not reporting news, they are making it up.

I can see him retiring rather than return to that shit mob. Look how they wrapped their arms around Oliver but seem to have failed to embrace Trac

I hate hearing some players are pissed off with him. They know nothing about trauma.

I see a situation Petracca wants the Pies, druggies refuse to trade - absolute scum to refer to contract - stand off means he retires or stands out

I doubt he goes to another club or returns to Melbourne. My view only but this is beyond trade value with picks and players. Legal eagles will be all over this.

I think you are right there is a very good chance the legals do get their hands on this and probably rightly so from Petracca,s perspective. He is now being hung out to dry by Demons figures, when you look at him in comparison to Clarry he has not put a foot wrong,he is not on the gear and as far as I can see has consistently conducted himself in a proper way.

And to have that paragon of virtue Garry Lyon talk about you in such a manner would be the final straw when you consider the amount of times Oliver has F----- up without no comebacks would be galling. I have watched Petracca closely last season and I think his time at Melbourne is over ,I no inside info on where he will be but it will not be the Dees.

 

[DopeMaster]

Would the Suns consider Noble + F1st for pick 7?

Then pick 7, 2024 2nd round and McInnes to Melbourne for Petracca. They’d probably think it unders, but it’s about what we got for a 25 year old Dayne Beams

11

Dayne Beams

Age

34

Ht

187cm

Wt

88kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

25.6

5star

K

13.2

5star

HB

12.4

5star

M

4.5

4star

T

3.6

5star

CL

4.9

5star

No current season stats available

D

15.6

4star

K

6.6

3star

HB

9.0

5star

M

4.6

5star

T

2.6

4star

. Might accept it if Trac holds firm that it’s Collingwood or bust.

Pickup Cumming as UFA to replace / upgrade Noble.

1-2 3rd rounders for Keane.

Flagpies.

About time we got some of Gold Coasts largesse, besides if they tip us to drop further next year they may even get a better pick, until Trac arrives that is…

In this hypothetical I’d be pretty tempted to take 7 to the draft, but think we’re in ‘win now’ mode with our older brigade still all playing good footy. Pick 7 won’t help us win a flag in the next couple years.

 

[Axl the great]

Correct. Although it sounds like we have to have "that" talk. When a Mummy defender and a Daddy line breaker love each other very much...

You could have come with a picture book.

 

[Jen2310]

Would the Suns consider Noble + F1st for pick 7?

Then pick 7, 2024 2nd round and McInnes to Melbourne for Petracca. They’d probably think it unders, but it’s about what we got for a 25 year old Dayne Beams. Might accept it if Trac holds firm that it’s Collingwood or bust.

Pickup Cumming as UFA to replace / upgrade Noble.

1-2 3rd rounders for Keane.

Flagpies.

About time we got some of Gold Coasts largesse, besides if they tip us to drop further next year they may even get a better pick, until Trac arrives that is…

In this hypothetical I’d be pretty tempted to take 7 to the draft, but think we’re in ‘win now’ mode with our older brigade still all playing good footy. Pick 7 won’t help us win a flag in the next couple years.

No, as I imagine Richmond will want that pick 7 for Rioli

 

[DopeMaster]

No, as I imagine Richmond will want that pick 7 for Rioli

I though they had 6 and 7?

Edit: Just see now it’s 7 and 13. Surely 13 is plenty for Rioli…. Come on GC

 

[Apex36]

No, as I imagine Richmond will want that pick 7 for Rioli

Which is bonkers because Rioli isn’t even close to being worth that.

 

[Jen2310]

I though they had 6 and 7?

Edit: Just see now it’s 7 and 13. Surely 13 is plenty for Rioli…. Come on GC

Its either pick 7 or two first rounders for rioli, to get him out of richmond.
They then also need points for Lombard.

Pick 20 is our best bet. Which we will then try push up the draft board and get one of the whitlocks who are currently rated at 20 and 26 according to Rookie me Central.

 

[Jen2310]

Which is bonkers because Rioli isn’t even close to being worth that.

Yeah, normally probably not. The fact he has 4 years on his deal likely pushes what you need to pay.

 

[sideswipe]

I think you are right there is a very good chance the legals do get their hands on this

There is no chance

 

[stormskye]

How is Rioli worth two first round picks .