List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[In Fly We Trust]

I'm hoping Fly is such a nice guy that whenever a player/manager requests a meeting, he'd say yes. Not because he's interested in the player

Hopefully we didn't instigate it.

It costs us nothing to talk, at the very least it gives us good market intel which should help in other negotiations.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[eddiesmith]

Fairytale is people convincing themselves a 30 year old Jake Stringer is the answer to our problems. He ain't.

But a 32 year old who’s played 8 games in 2 years and would cost 3 times as much is the answer?

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

It costs us nothing to talk, at the very least it gives us good market intel which should help in other negotiations.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

Exactly. Players & managers being told to explore their options are doing just that. And as you say we get to find out what's going on at other clubs.

 

[Quicky]

Peatling is a 24yo midfielder who just had a career year where he averaged 14 disposals a game.

Davies is a 22yo depth player for GC who averages 15 disposals a game.

I'm not real excited by those two.

 

[JuniorB]

Peatling is a 24yo midfielder who just had a career year where he averaged 14 disposals a game.

Davies is a 22yo depth player for GC who averages 15 disposals a game.

I'm not real excited by those two.

Both of them are stuck behind a bunch of gun midfielders.

 

[NMBB]

I'm hoping Fly is such a n XDice guy that whenever a player/manager requests a meeting, he'd say yes. Not because he's interested in the player

Hopefully we didn't instigate it.

Don't let this get out but this is Trac's manager and Fly meeting this evening - managed to snap it before I got noticed

 

[FAIRANDBALANCED]

But a 32 year old who’s played 8 games in 2 years and would cost 3 times as much is the answer?

If you can't work out the differences in Lynch and Stringer and what they bring to a team and if you want to compare them side by side, well, go right ahead.

 

[FAIRANDBALANCED]

Peatling is a 24yo midfielder who just had a career year where he averaged 14 disposals a game.

Davies is a 22yo depth player for GC who averages 15 disposals a game.

I'm not real excited by those two.

I am pretty sure they have both been subs quite a bit through the year.

I would like Davies. He just comes across as a big body that could get bigger and not allow players like Cripps to bully us in the middle.

 

[eddiesmith]

If you can't work out the differences in Lynch and Stringer and what they bring to a team and if you want to compare them side by side, well, go right ahead.

Well one would only be picked up if cheap and the other earns about 500,000 a game over the last 2 years.

Not sure how that’s a good pickup, but hey please tell us how Lynch will magically get fitter at 32 and be worth his 1.5 million…

 

[Hardas]

Both of them are stuck behind a bunch of gun midfielders.

Haven't seen much of either, but we're looking for cheapish upgrades on Bytel Long &/or Sully for decent mid depth, so...

 

[Roverjg]

He has times where he goes cold. Inconsistent with his effort.

So did every collingwood player this year.

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[flyingmagpies]

Peatling is a 24yo midfielder who just had a career year where he averaged 14 disposals a game.

Davies is a 22yo depth player for GC who averages 15 disposals a game.

I'm not real excited by those two.

Peatling averages 20 disposals in games when he's not the sub (and 8 tackles). I think being the sub 9 times this year due to GWS having a stacked midfield might have hurt his stats a bit. In the VFL (which is not the same), he looks to get 30+ regularly. If he is cheap, I think he's worth a look.

 

[soreplums]

Not that it has anything to do with his playing ability, but my son tells me he has converted to Islam?

Yep. I think I heard this too from one of Stringer’s neighbours.

 

[Apex36]

Peatling is a 24yo midfielder who just had a career year where he averaged 14 disposals a game.

Davies is a 22yo depth player for GC who averages 15 disposals a game.

I'm not real excited by those two.

You need to look in to Peatlings numbers a little bit harder before making judgement.

 

[JuniorB]

Haven't seen much of either, but we're looking for cheapish upgrades on Bytel Long &/or Sully for decent mid depth, so...

Peatling is behind Coniglio, Greene, Kelly, Green, and others.
Davies is behind Anderson, Rowell, Miller, Flanders and others.
Hard to get games when you have that sort of competition.
Both would get more opportunity elsewhere.

 

[Apex36]

Yep. I think I heard this too from one of Stringer’s neighbours.

It’s been well and truly reported on, it’s no big secret.

 

[Roverjg]

Peatling is a 24yo midfielder who just had a career year where he averaged 14 disposals a game.

Davies is a 22yo depth player for GC who averages 15 disposals a game.

I'm not real excited by those two.

They have done ok based based on their average game time. Peatling played 55% game time and Davies 58%.

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[jenko007]

Need to go hard for Peatling! Is the perfect addition to a future Daicos, Allan midfield. Runs all day, good decision making with elite disposal. His stats are skewed due to being sub multiple times. Every full game he was in the elite section for tackles more than 7 a game with high pressure acts, will be a future A listed Midfielder.

 

[IlovethePies]

Look, I’m just gonna put this out there.

I reckon we will get Petracca.

Don’t ask me how, but I’ve got a good feeling about this.

In fact, I’ve got a woody.

Agree..I believe the media morons condemning Trac, despite almost dying- for wanting to play at a high profile club, will create a firestorm of backlash. There will be demands for transparency about how the Melbourne medical team allowed him back on the field. There will be demands for transparency about what pressure Goodwin et al placed on the medical staff to influence them. There will be demands to know how Melbourne treated him in the aftermath. The AFL, and Melbourne will be threatened by a catastrophic exposure of dereliction of duty of care. They will have no way out but to facilitate Trac's move to the club of his choice. If Trac nominates us, we'll get him... For minimal cost.

 

[LuckyLee]

Peatling is a 24yo midfielder who just had a career year where he averaged 14 disposals a game.

Davies is a 22yo depth player for GC who averages 15 disposals a game.

I'm not real excited by those two.

Averages are misleading. What were they once you exclude those in which they started as sub? Much higher I think you’ll find.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Didn't they say he be at Collingwood next season in middle of the Year?

That was more the media suggesting that....

 

[MoreMoore]

Regarding Stringer, if it costs us nothing I’m ok with it.
Next year will be like the bulls last dance. It’ll be all on the line for a flag. 2026 will be a substantially different list.

Imagine Jordy, Trac and Stringer in a center bounce

 

[Fat Jesus]

Ginnivan kicked 40 in 2022. There’s more to footy than just goals scored.

Sure lmao 42 goals. Just a sneeze.
I'd have him. Easily

 

[domus]

As for stringer, ok with him coming to us if he wants to.
Don’t like him as a person, but a talent
Offer one yr plus an option for another

He loves his little boy. That's a good start. What's he done wrong as a person?

 

[PIEWITHSAUCE]

He loves his little boy. That's a good start. What's he done wrong as a person?

How long have you got?

I'm not rapt with the idea from a culture perspective but can see why we'd be talking to him as the only ammo we have currently (aside from a future 1st and maybe Trac falling into our lap) is the ability to go at free agents.