List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

What Trade Happens 1st


  • Total voters
    338
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm just pointing out that these "guns" would attract first round draft choices as compo.

Put Langdon on the table and I guarantee you no club would offload a first rounder for him because he is not a gun. He is an ordinary footballer.
No he's not ordinary, he has played all 22 games this year as a second year player under extreme pressure, your assessment of him is flawed, name a better second year defender in the comp?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The only 2 things I like about kreuzer is 1. He has a bit of c u next Tuesday about him and you just can't teach that and 2. He can follow up at ground level
 
The only 2 things I like about kreuzer is 1. He has a bit of c u next Tuesday about him and you just can't teach that and 2. He can follow up at ground level

He is a Better Player then White but He has been very Injury Prone
 
Pick 2 means not a whole lot to me.

No one knows how the player will turn out. He should be good but he could be a bust as well. We are miles ahead of Carlton as a football club and it is time for us to add some experience to this young team.

I would give Kruezer 500 a year max. He gets to play for the club he supported as a child and gets a fresh start.
 
Pick 2 means not a whole lot to me.

No one knows how the player will turn out. He should be good but he could be a bust as well. We are miles ahead of Carlton as a football club and it is time for us to add some experience to this young team.

I would give Kruezer 500 a year max. He gets to play for the club he supported as a child and gets a fresh start.

Look what happened to Varcoe this Season
 
So Witt's to the dogs, giants or swans maybe?? I would rather take the dogs first round pick for Witt's and our 3rd rounder so we can have a first round draft pick still.
Seriously... Can't see us trading a 22 year old 208cm ruckman. They're like hens teeth!
 
Haha its an oldie but a Goldie, yeah I understand he's injury prone but if we can get him for under $449999 and land treloar at the expense of witts and a first rounder I'd be happy to take the punt. * wouldn't pay over 450k and also depends on medical obviously
 
No he's not ordinary, he has played all 22 games this year as a second year player under extreme pressure, your assessment of him is flawed, name a better second year defender in the comp?

Would any team in the comp trade a first round pick for him?

Why are we deflecting from the reality?
 
The only 2 things I like about kreuzer is 1. He has a bit of c u next Tuesday about him and you just can't teach that and 2. He can follow up at ground level
Would any team in the comp trade a first round pick for him?

Why are we deflecting from the reality?[/QUO
Who cares what others may or may not do, and frankly I could not care. I know what I can see, that is the reality. Your hypothetical valuing of him is not reality. It's speculation.
 

The fact that you cannot categorically say he is worth a first round pick shows his value as a player.

When we talk about "guns" we know they are worth plenty.
Langdon has far too many limitations as a player. He may one day improve but he is not a "jet" as many on here would have you believe.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Would any team in the comp trade a first round pick for him?

Why are we deflecting from the reality?
Your speculation of his trade value is purely hypothetical and therefore not reality. I know what I can see and that is in all likliehood the best second year defender in the comp
 
Really? you sure? Never heard of rocket surgeon either actually. I guess I'm just not hip to all this new fangled groovfaddery. But how come when I googled Herpa it just came up with a die caste model maker and std references? You been at Uncle Dongas sausages again?
I do it on purpose.
 
No to Kreuzer for mine. If Witts is traded I reckon Cox could step up and perform to a similar standard, plus Moore has also impressed around the ground in recent weeks. We'd still need another back up should Witts be traded, but I'd go a cheaper option, maybe someone like Grimley or Currie who aren't getting a game at their clubs.
 
Your speculation of his trade value is purely hypothetical and therefore not reality. I know what I can see and that is in all likliehood the best second year defender in the comp

Why don't you just answer the question?
Would he fetch a first round pick on the open market?

The answer is clearly no.
 
No to Kreuzer for mine. If Witts is traded I reckon Cox could step up and perform to a similar standard, plus Moore has also impressed around the ground in recent weeks. We'd still need another back up should Witts be traded, but I'd go a cheaper option, maybe someone like Grimley or Currie who aren't getting a game at their clubs.

I think we'll only be going after Kruezer if we genuinely need to get rid of Witts as a means of required currency for other players such as Treloar.

With the sub going, chances are you'll be able to play two genuine ruckman.

You don't want your second ruck to be an international rookie or a fringe player at a club like Norf.
 
Why don't you just answer the question?
Would he fetch a first round pick on the open market?

The answer is clearly no.
Your fascination with his trade value is mind numbing. Name the last premiership side that had all their players valued as first round draft selections.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top