List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[Ketchup]

Won't happen Acres signed a four year contract at the start of the season and many believe once he gets his body right will be the best player out of the draft.

I imagine that would only be St kilda supporters who have no idea.

I believe when Freeman gets his body right he will be the next ablett. Am I doing it right?

 

[JollyBallsUp]

Yeah GWS playing games.

Have 2 x 1st rounders from other clubs and dare say that is what they want off us.

Let me know when they get 2 1st rounders in the top 10. Pick 7 is significant and much better than the likes of Richmond who have previously offered 2 1st rounders which will most likely be picks 12 and possibly 14-16 if the could manage to win a final in the near future.

 

[JollyBallsUp]

I imagine that would only be St kilda supporters who have no idea.

I believe when Freeman gets his body right he will be the next ablett. Am I doing it right?

That's why they should part with pick 5

 

[TradeDraft]

Most likely stall it to last 3 days 3 weeks of bs and 3 days of trades.

Teams just dislike the pies want to always make things as hard as possible.

Not locking in Treloar early hurts all our other trade options because we don't know what we have to trade until Treloar is secured.

Do Teams hate what we did to Lions last year?

 

[DNine]

http://www.aflplayerratings.com.au/Ratings/Player/116629/Ahmed-SAAD

Two things here. One he likes the number kicking four goals, did so often,

But was even in the development league at one stage of the year.

I liked him last time he played, but he seems to of come back half the player he used to be.

I think we are looking like swapping Ben Kennedy for Jeremy Howe, which I like, but would like to get the second round picks for Seedsman and Freeman, as we will need them for Aish.

Also want us to get a key forward. Tomlinson would be good. I do think that next year may be the year that Majak Daw realises his potential, so wouldn't be against swapping Seeds for him, but I would love to know that the Rape charge against him will be thrown out.

 

[Adam H]

I imagine that would only be St kilda supporters who have no idea.

I believe when Freeman gets his body right he will be the next ablett. Am I doing it right?

Well if thats the case you should have signed him for four or more years.

 

[Babylove]

Okay I don't normally like Jon Ralph but it was so fun listening to him all but call KB an idiot (even if I didn't like what I was hearing re Treloar).

http://www.sen.com.au/news/10-15/trade-sentral-tuesday-13th-october#IfYxAd6ouXSdYB65.97

 

[Ketchup]

Well if thats the case you should have signed him for four or more years.

Unfortunately I am not on a list management teams. Hence why what I think. And what your board thinks. Really means sweet **** all when it comes to trading.

 

[CFC2010]

I imagine that would only be St kilda supporters who have no idea.

I believe when Freeman gets his body right he will be the next ablett. Am I doing it right?

I was thinking Dangerfield...........

 

[Hardas]

Don't be a f-wit

Not sure if you're being serious here.
If so, go f___ yourself sideways.

 

[Babylove]

Okay so how about this:

Freeman + 44 to Saints for 2016 Round 2 + Ahmed Saad
Pick 7 + Saints 2016 Round 2 to GWS for Adam Treloar
Round 16 Round 1 to Brisbane for James Aish
Kennedy to Melbourne for Jeremy Howe
Seedsman to Gold Coast for Pick 22
Pick 22 & Pick 26 to Sydney for Pick 14

Summary
IN
Adam Treloar
James Aish
Jeremy Howe
Ahmed Saad
Pick 14

Out
Nathan Freeman
Ben Kennedy
Paul Seedsman
Pick 7
Pick 26
Pick 44
2016 Round 1

Now if I could just get Derek Hine on the phone...

 

[DIDAIC0S]

Yeah GWS playing games.

Have 2 x 1st rounders from other clubs and dare say that is what they want off us.

Unless you think we are gonna finish ahead of Freo next year their first rounders are shizen compared to ours.


Sent from my Millennium Falcon using Tapatalk

 

[jkitto23]

Kennedy and 44 for Howe not 26

Yep would be happy with that!

 

[TradeDraft]

Okay I don't normally like Jon Ralph but it was so fun listening to him all but call KB an idiot (even if I didn't like what I was hearing re Treloar).

http://www.sen.com.au/news/10-15/trade-sentral-tuesday-13th-october#IfYxAd6ouXSdYB65.97

They need to get a Room

 

[loki04]

Unless you think we are gonna finish ahead of Freo next year their first rounders are shizen compared to ours.


Sent from my Millennium Falcon using Tapatalk

Richmond have offered 2 firsts for him.

We will land Treloar that I have no doubt.

I'm saying GWS are asking over for him based off that offer and are going to draw it out just to f@#k with us.

 

[didaksrightfoot]

kennedy for Howe.
Freeman for acres.
Seed for 19.
Treloar for 7 and 19.
Aish for 26 and next years 2nd..?
Saad in psd.
Wouldn't need to go to the draft.

I think you overate a couple of our guys there.

Kennedy for Howe might need an extra piece (our 3rd, or swapping our 3rd for their 4th or 2nd for 3rd or something).

I doubt Seed for 19 is gonna happen. (and whos 19 will that be?) hopefully gonna get a GC 2nd rounder - early 20s

And would St Kilda get rid of Acres? (unless hes asked for out or is uncontracted)

 

[MightyRoar]

Okay so how about this:

Freeman + 44 to Saints for 2016 Round 2 + Ahmed Saad
Pick 7 + Saints 2016 Round 2 to GWS for Adam Treloar
Round 16 Round 1 to Brisbane for James Aish
Kennedy to Melbourne for Jeremy Howe
Seedsman to Gold Coast for Pick 22
Pick 22 & Pick 26 to Sydney for Pick 14

Summary
IN
Adam Treloar
James Aish
Jeremy Howe
Ahmed Saad
Pick 14

Out
Nathan Freeman
Ben Kennedy
Paul Seedsman
Pick 7
Pick 26
Pick 44
2016 Round 1

Now if I could just get Derek Hine on the phone...

It was sounding alright until I got to the Kennedy and Seeds trades.....unfortunately we will need to throw a pick the Dees way as well and I'd be very suprised if we got Pick 22 for Seeds, would prob also need to throw a pick there way if we want pick 22.

 

[Pendles!]

Wasnt it Treloars manager to say Adam will be at Collingwood and only Collingwood next season? This Gubby bloke is weird, i heard the interview was very hard to listen to. Sounds like abit of a liar, clearly Mccarthy doesnt want to be in Sydney.

Would do Acres for Freeman in a straight swap. Trade the pick we get for Seedsman and our original second round pick for Aish then both our second rounders for Treloar and call it a trade period. Unless Sam Reid can come to us for Witts or Frost.

"Everyone is happy and no one wants to leave".

Wat.

 

[loki04]

Do Teams hate what we did to Lions last year?

No, it's just we are collingwood and they don't want to give us any leg up.

Need to put up a facade for their supporters make it seem like they dug their heels in and stuck it up us as much as possible before relenting.

 

[DIDAIC0S]

Richmond have offered 2 firsts for him.

We will land Treloar that I have no doubt.

I'm saying GWS are asking over for him based off that offer and are going to draw it out just to f@#k with us.

You're right, they're being nobs. I am pretty over hearing about media reports of Richmond and Freo offering up two 1st round picks for Treloar and McCarthy.

Lower picks this year are inherently worth more due to the perceived lack of depth in the draft. Our pick being 7.
Whereas regardless of where we finish next year those 1st rounders will be more much of a muchness in value.

I wish Brett Anderson for one could get his head around this simple idea.


Sent from my Millennium Falcon using Tapatalk

 

[THATSGOLD]

Most likely stall it to last 3 days 3 weeks of bs and 3 days of trades.

Teams just dislike the pies want to always make things as hard as possible.

Not locking in Treloar early hurts all our other trade options because we don't know what we have to trade until Treloar is secured.

Stale mate. We should get him next week but I don't think we will get Aish he will go to Carlton in PSD.

 

[TradeDraft]

No, it's just we are collingwood and they don't want to give us any leg up.

Need to put up a facade for their supporters make it seem like they dug their heels in and stuck it up us as much as possible before relenting.

Well look at last year with Boyd. They went from not Trading Boyd to Trading Boyd in 24 Hours.

GWS Think they Holding out would make us Panic and OverPay

 

[THATSGOLD]

Won't happen Acres signed a four year contract at the start of the season and many believe once he gets his body right will be the best player out of the draft.

Freeman could be the best player in the draft given you haven't seen him. It's a fair deal.

 

[jimmy35]

Pains up the ass are never ideal

Source?

 

[TradeDraft]

So IF we can't get Treloar would we trade the 2016 1st Rounder for Aish?