List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 Part 3

[Hard Yakka]

Agree. It's ridiculous! Reporting on trade reports and rumours with no new content. Even reporting on reports and rumours of Collingwood trades, purely the speculation. It's amateur hour and if that's what membership money is being spent on, heaven forbid...

 

[Stoods]

I value Hansen around the pick 40 mark due to tall players being harder to come by. What would you guys value Marley at?

2015 he had a great year, a lot of us thought very stiff to miss on the 40 man AA squad.
Was ruined by injury this year which made him look unfit and worse than what he us, i honestly think pick 33 would be fine, maybe a tad overs but im pretty sure you guys don't have another pick for a while?

Ideally pick 35-40 you would think.

 

[NT.Thunder]

I value Hansen around the pick 40 mark due to tall players being harder to come by. What would you guys value Marley at?

I actually don't want to see him leave. I think he actually is one of few that has shown and does have potential and we should persevere with him. He had a poor season this year but still don't see any reason to move him on.

Wouldn't touch Hansen personally

 

[TradeDraft]

Agree. It's ridiculous! Reporting on trade reports and rumours with no new content. Even reporting on reports and rumours of Collingwood trades, purely the speculation. It's amateur hour and if that's what membership money is being spent on, heaven forbid...

Trade Show they have Daily has been Pathetic. Only Good when we Signed Mayne and Wells and Had Interviews with them.

Rest just been Reporting what AFL.com.au/Trade Radio has Reported

 

[left at home]

to ma

I don't get the 'Premiership Player' fetish. If anything a sign of clinging on to a long forgotten past. That was 6 yrs ago when dinosaurs roamed the earth and gorillas like him the fwd line. Doggies can have him.

to many hang on to that, l am thankful for 2010, but to me this is one reason why we win one only so often.
we are not ruthless enough to shed them before there time is up and hang onto them to long at times

 

[donkeyballs]

Close your eyes & think of round one 2016 against Sydney. You'll sleep, but there might be some nightmares.

I often run through the pies best 22 to relax and get to sleep. No joke. Works well!

 

[TradeDraft]

Hope BF does not Crash Tommorow with how busy it could be on here

 

[Tassiepies83]

He was VFL depth in 2016 and is now a year older and a veteran. Not a time of career a player is likely to do anything else than get worse.

He was in a team that unlike us had developing kds, some on Melbourne thread were annoyed he wasn't selected more often as was performing better, but they made a choice to go with youth a choice we will take when we have some young kds until then Dunn is fb.

 

[PIEWITHSAUCE]

I often run through the pies best 22 to relax and get to sleep. No joke. Works well!

Hopefully at some point in the next decade the list will be exciting enough to keep you awake.

 

[Stoods]

Hope BF does not Crash Tommorow with how busy it could be on here

Dave you may have to share a couple welcome threads there will be that many mate! Haha.

 

[TradeDraft]

Dave you may have to share a couple welcome threads there will be that many mate! Haha.

Might have to get them Ready on my Phone so I can go ASAP

 

[Temploar]

I think we might be a chance to complete a few trades today.

You heard it here first.

 

[THATSGOLD]

I often run through the pies best 22 to relax and get to sleep. No joke. Works well!

Funny you say that. I run through the player numbers. Start with Fasolo at 1.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Dave you may have to share a couple welcome threads there will be that many mate! Haha.

There will only be two. Lynden Dunn
And Hoskin Elliott

 

[Football God]

Might have to get them Ready on my Phone so I can go ASAP

Im figuring out how you do it so quick? Do you have multiple tabs open with "Welcome to Collingwood [insert players name here]" and once you see confirmation of said player you just click post?

Or a you just a wizard?

 

[Hardas]

Funny you say that. I run through the player numbers. Start with Fasolo at 1.

Do the same - bunch of tragics, aren't we.

 

[TradeDraft]

Im figuring out how you do it so quick? Do you have multiple tabs open with "Welcome to Collingwood [insert players name here]" and once you see confirmation of said player you just click post?

Or a you just a wizard?

Actually I do but I still might not be the 1st 1 to Post the Welcome Thread

 

[nahnah]

There will only be two. Lynden Dunn
And Hoskin Elliott

You're happy about WHE?
I'm for Dunn so we dont see Keeffe get a game. Keeffe looking like being our only FB was truly terrifying.

 

[Temploar]

Why am I hearing Williams is leaving?

What's the story there

 

[TradeDraft]

In Bed so going to Bed Soon to rest up for hopefully a Huge last day of Trade Period

 

[Good_Old]

Why am I hearing Williams is leaving?

What's the story there

Norf look to be interested.

 

[DAWESOME!!]

Will be interesting to see in what shape Thomas and Keeffe come back, and if they hit the track hard.
Upside - a couple of years out of AFL means their bodies will be super fresh.
Downside - it will take them a while to find the match fitness and pace of the game again, if they can. Hoping they do.
Upside - they know what it takes to play AFL, and if they have stuck out their exile this far they might just be burning with desire to grab their second chance with both hands.
Upside - they add depth to our team, which as we've seen over the past couple of years, is crucial.
Downside - The endless tirades of abuse and "I knew it"s from BF posters if they don't have solid years.

Would honestly be surprised if either makes it back as a regular AFL player.

 

[THATSGOLD]

You're happy about WHE?
I'm for Dunn so we dont see Keeffe get a game. Keeffe looking like being our only FB was truly terrifying.

H Elliott has talent for sure and we need hope and talent on the list after what we have done to it the past few weeks.

 

[THATSGOLD]

You're happy about WHE?
I'm for Dunn so we dont see Keeffe get a game. Keeffe looking like being our only FB was truly terrifying.

As for Dunn we are going to be so shit with him in our defence in 17. It's a disgrace it's come to this. We are going to cop some massive beatings in 17, mark them down.

 

[Matt_352]

So guys last day of trades. I'm hoping for us to achieve what needs to be achieved. Hoping for a pleasant surprise from something gubby and Dekka have up their sleeves. Everything is crossed.