List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 Part 3

[Anzacday]

Ok it's an emotional time and I'm asking for calm please.
Inappropriate things have been posted and in turn deleted without any ramifications.
However, any further abuse or posting of inappropriate content will not be tolerated.




Vicky Park Magpie Girl 76woodenspooners Gone Critical

 

[Jafo]

So who's right and wrong now that's marsh has officially requested a trade to WA? Or we speculating the supposed walk out the other week is related to this request or two separate things?

 

[Tassiepies83]

Wow this sites has the worst case of bipola I have seen, the ups and downs are crazy, I mean this morning people were talking up our chances next year and now they are saying we are in for a world of pain next year on the back of losing a backman that's only played 15 games with a worse injury history than Wells and he is only 21. Don't get me wrong he will be a loss but hardly enough to write-off the season surely?

 

[danielnajdek]

It was fair enough to, In a situation like this when someone isn't well and all someone can think about is using it to take a pot shot at someone else is pathetic.

Don't pay attention to him. Just a attention seeker who always peddles his own pathetic agenda over and over again.

 

[Go Woods]

Hopefully the club can really try and take Draft picks out of Vic, the following players have left us due to homesickness or wanting to simply go home over the past few years.
Nick Davis
Sharrod Wellingham
Dwayne Beams
Jono Marsh
Hope there aren't any more surprises as our list does contain a number of interstate players....Becoming really frustrating.

 

[TradeDraft]

Hopefully the club can really try and take Draft picks out of Vic, the following players have left us due to homesickness or wanting to simply go home over the past few years.
Nick Davis
Sharrod Wellingham
Dwayne Beams
Jono Marsh
Hope there aren't any more surprises as our list does contain a number of interstate players....Becoming really frustrating.

Glad we have quite a Few SA Boys then

 

[rupink06]

At this rate I'll have to be taking up full back in 2017!

 

[Go Woods]

Keefe return becomes even more important to us next year.

 

[Go Woods]

Glad we have quite a Few SA Boys then

Suppose it's only a short trip home for these boys when they feel the need to see family.

 

[Jasper84]

Ok it's an emotional time and I'm asking for calm please.
Inappropriate things have been posted and in turn deleted without any ramifications.
However, any further abuse or posting of inappropriate content will not be tolerated.
[



Vicky Park Magpie Girl 76woodenspooners Gone Critical

Anzacday are you
guys able to resurrect the Marsh rumour thread? There were some pretty poignant posts on there about what he may be going through, which might help with the understanding of why he is leaving.

 

[Bay Pie]

In other news, Brisbane are actively shopping Rockliff but no clubs are interested. I hope we stay away. Overrated and poison.

David Noble while at Adelaide actively perused him to join he Crows, last year & earlier this year. Now he's at Brisbane, he actively wants him out. Hmmmmmmm. Something stinks about this guy.

 

[TradeDraft]

Keefe return becomes even more important to us next year.

At Moment he is a Walk Up for FB Postion

 

[whiskeytown]

Marsh will fetch a late third round or early fourth round. He's unproven, has questionable hamstrings, is a rotten kick at times. Worth no more than Frost.

Might have to keep Goldsack now, if possible

 

[Matthew_13]

Boys, Was told after the news on marsh that he wasn't at the B & F. Can someone confirm is this is correct?

 

[Rusty22]

keefe has a lot to owe us next year step it up big fella.
Schazza
Ramsay
Langdon
all to come back , relax guys.

 

[TradeDraft]

Boys, Was told after the news on marsh that he wasn't at the B & F. Can someone confirm is this is correct?

I say what be Said. I highly Doubt he would been

 

[nahnah]

Marsh + 25 for Darling

No thanks! Rather wait and get lynch!! Darling has proven he is soft, cant trust him in big games.

 

[whiskeytown]

Kudos to the poster who called marsh's exit a week or so ago.... Big Footy knows before the journos do

 

[well left]

Disappointed to lose Marsh but the reasons are there and we need to move on.

Liked the look of Sam Collins in a couple of Freo games I saw this year. 194cm, 92kg defender recruited from Box Hill who played 12 games this year. Let's get in his ear to come home.

 

[northpie]

Let's give the guy a massive wrap. Clearly he has struggled to settle into a new life in Melbourne , but has given it a real crack despite I suspect some pretty depressing times. In spite of some bad disposal errors I never once doubted his endeavour or passion for the team.
Thanks for Your contribution to the pies , thanks for the honesty when it has got too much, and all the best with whichever WA club you end up at.

 

[DaVe86]

The rumour has been around a while, and i definitely didnt see him at the bnf. So i dont think this has come as a surprise to dekka.

Which makes the timing of the announcement interesting. Makes me think either we waited to secure wells and mayne to ease the pain of losing marsh....or we have sorted out an adequate trade or replacement so now is the time to announce.

 

[BigEvilBastard]

What about straight swap with Marsh for Sam Collins from Freo, gotta be better than Mckenzie. Collins is only 22, good size to him, something to work with for the future. Ready made.

 

[Tassiepies83]

Disappointed to lose Marsh but the reasons are there and we need to move on.

Liked the look of Sam Collins in a couple of Freo games I saw this year. 194cm, 92kg defender recruited from Box Hill who played 12 games this year. Let's get in his ear to come home.

I really like that idea

 

[Linda_Lovelace]

My source is also pretty strong and I have no reason not to believe him but having said that I think it is fairly pointless having any further discussion on Marsh unless something becomes official. It was done to death on the other thread and just caused people to talk to each other like crap. We will know by the end of the trade period if he wants to leave.

Sadly, you were right, my info was about 6 weeks old so maybe a bit happened once he went home?

 

[Kadog]

What about straight swap with Marsh for Sam Collins from Freo, gotta be better than Mckenzie. Collins is only 22, good size to him, something to work with for the future. Ready made.

Won't happen. Collins is now in their best 22.