You're pretty hung up on the Eagles considering you didn't play them and just won.
Anyway, great win by you guys. I noticed the commentators overlooked Sandilands contribution. The big man was everywhere.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Game Day Collingwood vs Fremantle
- Thread starter Lach72
- Start date
- Tagged users None
You're pretty hung up on the Eagles considering you didn't play them and just won.
Anyway, great win by you guys. I noticed the commentators overlooked Sandilands contribution. The big man was everywhere.
Man you are really wearing purple tinted glasses. The umpiring was well in our favour and there was ducking, SonSon did it at most contests which is diss appointing.
to be honest...I kept saying Sylvia wasn't out there and hubby managed to convince me he was!! lol we need a new tvHow did you confuse the Duffman with Sylvia??? Looks-wise, there is NO comparison
Mezz
Club Legend
- Aug 27, 2010
- 1,844
- 2,087
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Perth Scorchers
to be honest...I kept saying Sylvia wasn't out there and hubby managed to convince me he was!! lol we need a new tv
I think you need to stop listening to your hubby!
earthquake
Team Captain
- Aug 12, 2006
- 599
- 57
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- teams playing Carlton
The Pies didnt have Blair , Fasolo , White , Reid , Seedsman , J Thomas , Seedsman and Karnezis out . Freo had Clarke , Ibbotson and Suban out.
The Dockers next time encounter a different more powerfull Pies team .
Pies to win .
The Dockers next time encounter a different more powerfull Pies team .
Pies to win .
- Banned
- #557
Who?
Didn't Buckley say now was a good time to play Freo?? And if your comparing players (you forgot Clancee Pearce) Ibbo, Clarke, Suban and Pearce are in our best 22, the only players you've named in the Pies best 22 are Blair, Reid, Fasolo and White (whom is a bit of an unknown quantity for the pies)
I know which 4 I'd prefer coming into my team....
Showing a bit of ignorance about our list I think. You forgot to mention Sylvia, Gumbleton, Griffin, C Pearce, Morabitto and Bradley for the Dockers. Including the ones you mentioned, all nine of those guys would not have been "ins" for us, but if any of them had been available they would have played last night. Each of them would have improved us in a key area.
Last edited:
Campbell and the rule committee have made some minor interpretational changes to get the ball moving and you saw most of then during the game .
The umpires will not penalise a player for illegal disposal of the ball if he is in the act of kicking the ball : IE Fyfe .
Using the head as a battering ram again no free kick and the sliding rule .
The clarification of which got a good example with the Mzungu incident .
As I said before we get a better go from the umpires in Melbourne than in Perth .
Give me S.A or VIC umpires for our home games every time .
- May 15, 2006
- 19,595
- 19,977
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- The Cobblers who do the Cobbling
Nice sentiment turbo, post this on the pies board and get back to me with the responses.
Walters holds his head every time he gets contact in contested situations. That's not evading.
Buckley has discarded mature, hardened players, for very talented kids, they are in a induced re-build. The only thing that will save his job, is to
admit this. Thank god we hunted down a quality coach, and thank you to Harvey, and Co, for starting ours.
admit this. Thank god we hunted down a quality coach, and thank you to Harvey, and Co, for starting ours.
Excuses. Karnezis and White havent even pulled on a Collingwood jumper yet. Fasolo has been out ages. Pie's still had Pendles, Beams and a very decent midfield.
FIGJAM stated this was a good time to catch Freo'. His arrogance and lack of coaching ability is reward enough.
Next thing you'll be moaning they miss Daisy.
We couldn't have been watching the same game.
What free ride ?
That was a very well umpired game.
Have to agree. What free ride. Umpiring has some very average moments going both ways.
No free rides though. I must have been watching a different game.
- Apr 4, 2013
- 13,670
- 16,890
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Not both Seedsmans!
Nothing
Brownlow Medallist
- Jul 30, 2009
- 10,556
- 17,610
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Next time we play Pies will be in 2015 and Buckley will be in a full rebuild and heading towards draft picks. They will not be powerful for years (or until Bucks disappears).
I think you need to stop listening to your hubby!
Never heard of a wife who did!
See you in 2015 then.
Barls_7
Senior List
- Nov 26, 2013
- 222
- 531
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Your opinion/post reflects your ability of knowing the game of AFL obviously... Very very shite!
BTW congratulations, you officially take the trophy from this guy below...
- Mar 2, 2007
- 43,265
- 62,162
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Cowboys, Packers, Scorchers
We had the rub of the green a few times with the umps (though only finished with one more free fwiw), but I was commenting more on the general approach they took to the game. I hope they continue to let the tiggy touchwood stuff go all year, even if it means we miss out on a few frees.
I've been critical of Son Son for ducking in the past, but I thought he was ok tonight. A few times he ducked and spun to try get out of congestion, but I didn't notice any faking or throwing of the head back followed by an appeal to the umps that the likes of Shuey have mastered.
Dud
good young player who would of done close to nothing
good player but never played a home and away game for his club yet
would of been forced to play as a defender
good young player but wouldn't of changed the game at all
average player
you mentioned him twice because you're stupid
the ultimate dud
Freo had their second ruckman missing, one of the best intercept marking defenders in the league missing and another midfielder missing. To say Karnezis, then we can say Sylvia. You're knowledge of football is disgustingly bad. It shows one team has depth and one team doesn't.
