Analysis Conspiracy theories surrounding Geelong's list management and salary cap

[Vdubs]

The greats are always exception to rules.

Would be an interesting topic, which of any younger brothers surpassed their star older brothers?

Just a few that spring to mind...

Bruce Nankervis?
Gary snr certainly superior to older brother Geoff Ablett
Zac Guthrie? Not yet
Troy Menzel, no way.

Kelvin Matthews- no way

Darren Jarman- yes.

Kane or Chad Cornes?

Shaun Burgoyne- probably.



Simon Madden clearly the superior
Danihers- Terry certainly the most durable.

 

[Geelong_Sicko]

Would be an interesting topic, which of any younger brothers surpassed their star older brothers?

Just a few that spring to mind...

Bruce Nankervis?
Gary snr certainly superior to older brother Geoff Ablett
Zac Guthrie? Not yet
Troy Menzel, no way.

Simon Madden clearly the superior
Danihers- Terry certainly the most durable.

And older brother Kevin. Gaz was superior to Kev as well!

 

[Vdubs]

And Zach Guthrie! I reckon he's surpassed older brother Cam now...

Any chance he's our next skipper?
I love him. Very calm, modest, interviews exceptionally well. A top 5 player week in week out. And (surprisingly?) durable so far.

 

[Geelong_Sicko]

Any chance he's our next skipper?
I love him. Very calm, modest, interviews exceptionally well. A top 5 player week in week out. And (surprisingly?) durable so far.

Yeah he doesn't miss a beat. He'd certainly be putting himself on the shortlist. He's turned into Mr Dependable down back.

 

[cats_09]

Any chance he's our next skipper?
I love him. Very calm, modest, interviews exceptionally well. A top 5 player week in week out. And (surprisingly?) durable so far.

I'd love him to be

I did shake my head at someone who said Zach doesn't look or act like a leader, just a bit too passive - they then voted Stewart as who should be captain

I know we all have different opinions & it would be boring otherwise, but I question anyone who said the younger Guthrie doesn't look a future leader as I think there's been some strong qualities on display throughout his career


As for Stewart, I know he's def a favourite for some but I feel like he's one who hasn't got the best from himself when he's been our acting captain, and while wearing your heart on your sleeve has its benefits - he's started playing as bit of an angry man at times

 

[Vdubs]

I'd love him to be

I did shake my head at someone who said Zach doesn't look or act like a leader, just a bit too passive - they then voted Stewart as who should be captain

I know we all have different opinions & it would be boring otherwise, but I question anyone who said the younger Guthrie doesn't look a future leader as I think there's been some strong qualities on display throughout his career


As for Stewart, I know he's def a favourite for some but I feel like he's one who hasn't got the best from himself when he's been our acting captain, and while wearing your heart on your sleeve has its benefits - he's started playing as bit of an angry man at times

You took the words right out of my keyboard.

 

[iameviljez]

And Zach Guthrie! I reckon he's surpassed older brother Cam now...

Cam was still a better player at his best, and plays a harder position.

Both better than their eldest brother (an afl.com.au journo).

 

[Geelong_Sicko]

Cam was still a better player at his best, and plays a harder position.

Both better than their eldest brother (an afl.com.au journo).

Yeah, it's probably erroneous to compare them side-by-side. Different players in different positions. Same could be said for just about anyone, in fairness. Gazza Snr and Jnr played very different roles, Jnr a midfielder and Snr the spearhead, though both could fulfill multiple roles on any given day if needed.

 

[iameviljez]

Yeah, it's probably erroneous to compare them side-by-side. Different players in different positions.

Cam Guthrie did play in the same position as Zac for a few years, and was pretty damn good at it.

 

[Taper]

Would be an interesting topic, which of any younger brothers surpassed their star older brothers?

Just a few that spring to mind...

Bruce Nankervis?
Gary snr certainly superior to older brother Geoff Ablett
Zac Guthrie? Not yet
Troy Menzel, no way.

Kelvin Matthews- no way

Darren Jarman- yes.

Kane or Chad Cornes?

Shaun Burgoyne- probably.



Simon Madden clearly the superior
Danihers- Terry certainly the most durable.

Ollie Henry?
He'll go past Jack very soon.

 

[The Unforgiven]

The people posting these conspiracies are probably the same people who believe climate change is being caused by the government controlling and manipulating the weather with the HAARP machine and chemtrails.

Or they just deny that it's happening at all.

 

[Vdubs]

Ollie Henry?
He'll go past Jack very soon.

I love them both

 

[Lana]

The people posting these conspiracies are probably the same people who believe climate change is being caused by the government controlling and manipulating the weather with the HAARP machine and chemtrails.

If you can't comvince them, then join them. You'll have more fun that way.

I've started talking in biblical terms, the end times have begun with the arrival of the great deceiver, the anti-Christ and we're seeing the start of the apocolypse, as virtue and vice are swapped, Winter has become Summer, repent sinners, repent. Great works are afoot, I bring a holy prophecy by the way of the Lion, the dead shall rise after the Saints go matching in at the termination of the 9th month.