Opinion Cripps or Judd

[james Dean]

Cripps

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

I voted Judd when this thread was started mid-2022.

Since then Cripps has won 2 Brownlow medals and taken us back to finals. If the same poll was made today, I'd have to go for Cripps. His improvement as a player and leader as he nears 30 has been incredible.

 

[ITCHY EYEBALLS]

Yep, for me Juddy clearly a better player at his peak, but Crippa has put the club on his back and made us relevant again….with a little bit of help.

 

[BlueGum]

Judd was a stepping stone. He improved the players professionalism. Maybe even setting examples for Cripps. But Cripps leaves no stone unturned re leadership or game day improvements.

 

[Dramoth]

Judd was a stepping stone. He improved the players professionalism. Maybe even setting examples for Cripps. But Cripps leaves no stone unturned re leadership or game day improvements.

Absolutely he improved the professionalism of the players and improved the culture of the club. Crippa is setting the example all good leaders do. He hired the running coach to help him out one year, and other players are doing the same.

He, Cripps, has set the required level and the others want to get closer to it than ever.

 

[BigBreakfast]

I voted Judd when this thread was started mid-2022.

Since then Cripps has won 2 Brownlow medals and taken us back to finals. If the same poll was made today, I'd have to go for Cripps. His improvement as a player and leader as he nears 30 has been incredible.

Same, and lead us deeper into the finals than Judd

Ed: just changed it!

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Same, and lead us deeper into the finals than Judd

Ed: just changed it!

It allows multiple selections so I've changed ged it to both.

 

[Juddernaut08]

At Carlton: clearly Cripps now. Taken us to back to finals, taken us to a prelim, dual brownlows at the club.

Career: Judd still leads, having a ridiculously high peak and having won a premiership. I think even if Cripps wins a flag with us, I'd have Judd's career slightly ahead. Win 2 flags and Cripps wins!

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Judd the more dominant player, Cripps the better leader and Carlton player.

 

[T2B_]

At Carlton: clearly Cripps now. Taken us to back to finals, taken us to a prelim, dual brownlows at the club.

Career: Judd still leads, having a ridiculously high peak and having won a premiership. I think even if Cripps wins a flag with us, I'd have Judd's career slightly ahead. Win 2 flags and Cripps wins!

Its no slight on Crippa either, Judd's best is just out of this world. Was like watching a video game character with all stats pumped to max vs a bunch of low level characters sometimes. As Commetti once said, its "supernatural".