- Aug 7, 2008
- 8,949
- 39
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- When they're not belting us, NZ
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Dawson must be axed
- Thread starter andolate
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Zagg
Club Legend
St Kilda Saints - Tom Ledger Sponsor 2013
St Kilda Saints - Tom Ledger 2012 Player Sponsor
St Kilda Saints - Nicholas Heyne 2011 Player Sponsor
St Kilda Saints - Nicholas Heyne 2010 Player Sponsor
From what I understand, Goose was in line to get some games towards the back end of last season, but then suffered a minor injury which ruled him out.
In the off season he probably talked with Ross and decided that as his opportunities would be limited here he'd look elsewhere for regular AFL football.
Are there any viable suggestions that you have that could replace Dawson? I've been frustrated with him at times, but he seems to be the best option and one would hope he plays himself into form again. As has been said, he's still young for a KP player, and should improve given time.
- Thread starter
- #28
Yes,
Baker Blake Fisher
Gwilt Gilbert Clarke
Nothing wrong with this setup. Yes, there are other options but this is solid.
We dont actually need to replace Dawson with another backman, we need to find another FWD option
dan0z
Club Legend
still to many talls for mine..
Rooster 24
Cancelled
- Jul 31, 2009
- 1,507
- 543
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
We should not be potting anyone from our backline. Kept Port to 7 goals and still managed to loose. Hardly the fault of Dawson & Clarke and while they can look shaky at times they were both serviceable. If you must apportion blame then look at the front half. We all know that Milne is hot and cold. Last week red hot, this week ice cold. That miracle goal has taken the focus off the countless dropped marks and poor decisions but over time he is well in credit. Likewise Kozi deserves a few more weeks before we write him off but overall they were both very average on Saturday.
that is precisely the example that i was thinking of.
having a great side on view of that, it was defintely 15
Oh well,we will take that as being the gospel then,thanks for that...
only a yr to late...
sure, he looked great going thrid man up, but as you can see, hawks fans were right, cant play KP, hes nothing more then a back pocket
sure, he looked great going thrid man up, but as you can see, hawks fans were right, cant play KP, hes nothing more then a back pocket
Nevertheless he would be a walk up start for your weak team at the moment.think you guys are a real chance to lose against Essendon next round and your season will be down the toilet.
saint jack
Rookie
Kildonan was right when he said
, However there are many problems in his game that need to be ironed out. He is too aware of his opponent at the expense of the ball, for one. I think Zac is just feeling a little too comfortable and maybe being dropped will give him a kick in the pants he does need at the moment.
Dropping to the reserves doesn't just need to be a "punishment" though. It can be an important tool to develop as a player against less elite opposition.
Nevertheless he would be a walk up start for your weak team at the moment.think you guys are a real chance to lose against Essendon next round and your season will be down the toilet.
dont count on it, he couldnt get a game in parts of 07 and the space of 5 weeks in 08 where there was plenty of space for him in defence.
and yes, it is possible our season might be in the shitter, but eh, doesnt change the fact we won in 08, and 2011 we will have the flag, nice way to commeorate 50 yrs sinc eour 1st flag i think
He..he..MM...O8 is fact,2011 is very wishful thinking from where i am sitting.dont count on it, he couldnt get a game in parts of 07 and the space of 5 weeks in 08 where there was plenty of space for him in defence.
and yes, it is possible our season might be in the shitter, but eh, doesnt change the fact we won in 08, and 2011 we will have the flag, nice way to commeorate 50 yrs sinc eour 1st flag i think
sainter
ENGLISH PREMIER LEAGUE
Zac vs Barry is 1-1 at the moment. I want to see the third installment.
- Feb 24, 2005
- 4,364
- 696
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- New York Giants, Adelaide Strikers
Dawson is the sort of bloke that could cost you guys a premiership, he could get 6 goals kicked on him in a GF in my opinion. ESPECIALLY if its against a Fevola or Hall
actually, fev is the one player Dawson is able to play on 1-on-1
- Jun 2, 2004
- 1,289
- 14
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Canberra Cannons and Seattle Sonics
I thought I might put this in this thread, to not upset or ruin the great win by the boys last night and place into another thread.
Zac was ordinary. Starting up forward IMO was a sign that Lyon had lost faith in him down back .. OR .. there was no match up for him. Starting Fisher on Hall sent a very clear message. Starting Zac up forward sent an even clearer message.
Yeah Zac was moved back onto Big, Bad, Bustling Barry later in the game, but the Dogs delivery into their forward line was atrocious They didn't know what they were doing or how to go about getting the ball forward ..
As for Raph Clarke ...
Holy shit, that game to me proved once and for all why he should not get a game.
1 - Bad hands, he cant get the ball clean at all on the first grab, fumbles way to much
2 - Out of position
3 - Get run down a lot !! ... has no peripheral vision at all. I cant believe how many times he tries to arch the back and take off with a run, only to be caught about 3 seconds later. He should look for the kick hand pass.
4 - Too many turnovers and poor disposal for my liking
He is a liability, who will cost us a game very very soon.
Zac was ordinary. Starting up forward IMO was a sign that Lyon had lost faith in him down back .. OR .. there was no match up for him. Starting Fisher on Hall sent a very clear message. Starting Zac up forward sent an even clearer message.
Yeah Zac was moved back onto Big, Bad, Bustling Barry later in the game, but the Dogs delivery into their forward line was atrocious They didn't know what they were doing or how to go about getting the ball forward ..
As for Raph Clarke ...
Holy shit, that game to me proved once and for all why he should not get a game.
1 - Bad hands, he cant get the ball clean at all on the first grab, fumbles way to much
2 - Out of position
3 - Get run down a lot !! ... has no peripheral vision at all. I cant believe how many times he tries to arch the back and take off with a run, only to be caught about 3 seconds later. He should look for the kick hand pass.
4 - Too many turnovers and poor disposal for my liking
He is a liability, who will cost us a game very very soon.
willingnable
Cancelled
- Banned
- #43
No starting Dawson up front had nothing to do with a loss of faith by lyons rather it was a clear indication that lyons is still trying work out the best way to adjust the forward line with nick no longer there.
Axcellence
Cancelled
St Kilda - Player Sponsor Nathan Wright 2015
St Kilda - Nathan Wright Player Sponsor 2014
St Kilda Saints - Nicholas Heyne 2010 Player Sponsor
I think Ross Lyon said in a pre game interview that he will mix it up against Hall. That's going to be predominant strategy going against big forwards now...
Squizz
Brownlow Medallist
- Oct 10, 2007
- 14,562
- 3,296
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Thought that was a big win to Lyon tactically. Fish was up for it and nullified Hall who can be a fast starter in games. The club would have been pleased with Zac's defensive efforts as a forward and contesting. Got a fair bit of help from Gilbo and Fish when he went to FB as the pace of the game slowed, but I don't see the problem with that.
I think we need to persist with Zac. The way we play their are very few times he will be left one on one with a power forward. He played some fantastic games last year when his confidence was high, his contested marking and long kicking can be a real asset to us.
Fisher didn't nullify Hall. Ross did by playing 18 men on him
Look2Me4Guidance
Destination Club Supporter
Ahh an armchair observer.
Zac did well in the 1 on 1's with Hall and read the played decently whilst up forward. His last 3 weeks have been significantly better than his previous 3.
Defacto
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 21, 2008
- 22,930
- 17,129
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
He's slowly improving. Needs another go next week.
Kildonan
Premium Platinum
I agree that we should persist with him. He is improving. I doubt he will be exposed terribly due to the support he gets from the best defence in the league. This defence includes the much maligned Jason Blake, the still maligned Raphael Clarke, Steven Baker, Sam Fisher and Sam Gilbert.
The latter three guys can't be doing all the work.
Have faith that our defence is so good because of the structure and our workrate rather than our personnel. Zac needs more games under his belt and another preseason to build himself up again (something must have gone wrong with this last preseason for him because he returned skinnier than he left at the end of last season.).
