Mega Thread Dayne Beams trade (Its over, thread closed)

[GoalSneak07]

I strongly feel Beams will choose the Lions, they'll throw the money and it makes sense to play with his Brother. Players I would look at are Darcy Gardiner, Redden, Rich and the likes. There is no hope we get Rocky. I'd like to think the club would secure a young player and a high end pick.

 

[Lord Wilberforce]

This. All is not lost. We can still win out of all this.

Not likely.

 

[Jonno94]

Lions set to offer 5 years.

That's it?

 

[IQ3]

come on guys. im not the biggest beams fan, but ease up, his dad has cancer so it is a no-brainer to be closer

 

[Pbft]

"Fortius Quo Fidelius"

Maybe he has a secret desire to play for the Saints

Seriously, it blows to lose good players from the club you bleed for as a supporter. Goddard was my all time fav player until two years ago. Now I wish we would just do the honourable thing and **** off completely. Absolutley love the fact he has screwed himself over by joining the injectors.

Make no mistake...this is all about FA. Greedy players and irrelevant AFLPA are destroying our game. Cheer em one year...abuse em the next.

 

[ksardog]

Pick 4 & Leuy for Beams?

Dont want or need broken down ruckman. Try again

 

[HeavyPop]

Sad news, but all the best to Beams.

It will be interesting to see how it all plays out.

 

[Fruit]

A three way trade for Dangerfield or Rockliff from Brisbane would do it but neither look likely to happen.

Which ever way you see it we will probably lose out at least for the short term because we will end up either with an early draft pick or a young player.

I think Pick 4 for Beams will be the likely trade, it's not realistic to ask for more than that for a guy who wasn't even an AA and has not won a best and fairest yet.

He has won a B&F

 

[PieBeast]

Shows where you're at more than anything.

You're right it does, very humane of me not to ask you to do something you're clearly aren't capable of.

 

[Fruit]

A three way trade for Dangerfield or Rockliff from Brisbane would do it but neither look likely to happen.

Which ever way you see it we will probably lose out at least for the short term because we will end up either with an early draft pick or a young player.

I think Pick 4 for Beams will be the likely trade, it's not realistic to ask for more than that for a guy who wasn't even an AA and has not won a best and fairest yet.

He has won a B&F

 

[TradeDraft]

Sad news, but all the best to Beams.

It will be interesting to see how it all plays out.

Yep.

Footy is a Business so you just Move On and try and get the best we can get

 

[Scodog10]

No Dave

I've become what I always hated when I was a kid, the bitter and twisted collingwood supporter. We all become one at some point, I never understood as a little fella....but watching your club continually **** themselves over and just be a basket case....I now completely understand

it's a natural progression for the young, wide (one) eyed optimistic little feels to turn into the bitter, twisted, old supporter who has seen it all before but the love can't let them walk away.

Collingwood shit me

I feel ya mate. Growing up in the 90's with a father who grew up watching us through the 70's-80's I know exactly where your coming from...

 

[Mateyman]

As an independent, I reckon pick 4 is fair, considering he wants to leave.

An "independent" ...Carlton supporter

 

[Caztheconquerer]

No

Pick 4 & Leuy for Beams?

no chance

 

[didaksrightfoot]

There is always the option of going after Clay, pay overs and bring the whole family down to Melbourne.

nothing a bit of creative salary cap work couldn't assist with... get Eddie to employ the lot of them with Channel 9 and give the Dad the highest level of medical cover we could offer

(obviously I'm being facetious and just trying to make light of a serious situation that isn't ideal for all parties involved)
---

Suggestions of Pick 4 for Beams is way too low IMO.

 

[Optimax]

So you think the Club are run by Idiots and Eddie and Bucks has to go?

Our club is a basket case Dave, full of yes men.

I've got no idea how to fix it.

 

[Good_Old]

The same reason your idiot posters persist to post on our forums requesting Rocky + Pick 4.

You've probably already been quoted but champ, heck right off.

 

[TradeDraft]

I feel ya mate. Growing up in the 90's with a father who grew up watching us through the 70's-80's I know exactly where your coming from...

This Trade could set up our next Premiership Team

 

[Rohan25]

just trade him now, I can't stand a year of endless speculation about what he's going to do at the end of next year, "beams watch" on 360 every night etc. just trade him now and be done with it.

 

[Collingwood pro]

Pick 4 & Leuy for Beams?

We dont need ruckman

 

[Shade]

This Trade could set up our next Premiership Team

Awesome collingwood 2020?

 

[DERKADERRR]

As an independent, I reckon pick 4 is fair, considering he wants to leave.

 

[Some Idiot]

Agree. If he's going for family reasons I've got no issues. Strength through Loyalty could well mean family anyway.

Staying true to family is ultimately the pinnacle of loyalty, no doubts about it.

 

[Mark_K]

I honestly have no issue with this. Well, that's not true. I hate that he wants out, but so long as its for the right reasons, which this appears to be, i can't begrudge him.

This is not on Buckley, so before the trolls run wild, do yourself a favour and read up on the issues.

His father is recovering from Cancer. Whether he is better or not is irrelevant. It's clearly had an affect on Dayne, so much so that he wants to be near his home. Tbh, i'd probably do the same thing.

If he wants out, i have no interest in keeping him around.

Trade him now whilst his value is high and under contract. Don't let him become a free agent.

 

[pieman123]

How about this
Beams to St Kilda for pick 1
St Kilda trade beams to Brisbane for Aish and pick 4
Buckley to channel 7