-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Delistings - Who and When
- Thread starter Bay Pie
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Re: Delistings
Hey guys,
Ex-school mate of Daniel Farmer but was never really mates with him, however, I was close with his current best mate. He's informed me that farms has been delisted with the promise of being put onto the rookie list.
Hey guys,
Ex-school mate of Daniel Farmer but was never really mates with him, however, I was close with his current best mate. He's informed me that farms has been delisted with the promise of being put onto the rookie list.
TradeDraft
Post-Human
standingroomonly
Club Legend
Re: Delistings
Could Ugle be in any danger of a delist/re-rookie situation? I thought he was good in the VFL this year but small forwards are not something we're lacking on the senior list.
Could Ugle be in any danger of a delist/re-rookie situation? I thought he was good in the VFL this year but small forwards are not something we're lacking on the senior list.
Magnus the Magpie
All Australian
Re: Delistings
Why all the negativity on Buckley? Played 13 games this year and averaged just under 19 disposals. He has pace, size (190cm and 93kg) and, to my mind, looked really good at times coming off half-back. I know he had a couple of howlers but he wasn't R. Crusoe there. Best season to date with us (and probably including his Melbourne games as well) and still considerable upside IMO. Rated highly by a couple of commentators as well - e.g. the Ch.7 guys couldn't understand why he wasn't getting more games - for once, I tend to agree.
Why all the negativity on Buckley? Played 13 games this year and averaged just under 19 disposals. He has pace, size (190cm and 93kg) and, to my mind, looked really good at times coming off half-back. I know he had a couple of howlers but he wasn't R. Crusoe there. Best season to date with us (and probably including his Melbourne games as well) and still considerable upside IMO. Rated highly by a couple of commentators as well - e.g. the Ch.7 guys couldn't understand why he wasn't getting more games - for once, I tend to agree.
Hotpiescoldbeers
Team Captain
Re: Delistings
Do you know the dates for the 2nd and 3rd list lodgments?
Do you know the dates for the 2nd and 3rd list lodgments?
Re: Delistings
A few have to go. It's either players like Buckley and Macaffer or kids but we have to clear list spots.
Re: Delistings
Yep, it's all relative. A good player like Buckley gets talked about this way due to playing in a very good team and being on a list very light on weak spots.
TBH he stands out in my mind as the guy I more often than not felt a bit let down with after going to games this year. Again, a big part of that was our excellent H & A form this year, and he probably played decent enough but when those around you are playing to such a high level even a mostly good game can look poor.
Yep, it's all relative. A good player like Buckley gets talked about this way due to playing in a very good team and being on a list very light on weak spots.
TBH he stands out in my mind as the guy I more often than not felt a bit let down with after going to games this year. Again, a big part of that was our excellent H & A form this year, and he probably played decent enough but when those around you are playing to such a high level even a mostly good game can look poor.
- Nov 13, 2008
- 28,187
- 21,868
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Sydney Sweeney's Shaving Team...
Re: Delistings
Normally, big footiers like to focus their negativity on one person or player. It's not a good thing to spread your negativity and water it down. Sometimes I'm feeling a big negative about the team but I focus it on Buckley and so we have a far more focussed kind of negativity...
we used to use Fraser but he left....
Normally, big footiers like to focus their negativity on one person or player. It's not a good thing to spread your negativity and water it down. Sometimes I'm feeling a big negative about the team but I focus it on Buckley and so we have a far more focussed kind of negativity...
we used to use Fraser but he left....
TradeDraft
Post-Human
Optimax
Brownlow Medallist
- Jan 12, 2011
- 25,405
- 35,588
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Delistings
If as expected Witts go onto the Senior List then I make it that we have to delist only 4 more players and use just two picks in the draft
So my 4 off would be:
JMac
Buckley
Dick
and unfortunately
Caff
If as expected Witts go onto the Senior List then I make it that we have to delist only 4 more players and use just two picks in the draft
So my 4 off would be:
JMac
Buckley
Dick
and unfortunately
Caff
Re: Delistings
This is pretty much it but he did emphasize that a rookie can be upgraded at round 11. Which makes me think if Caff is carrying a niggling injury then this is what he may be alluding too - half a season for Caff to get himself right.
This is pretty much it but he did emphasize that a rookie can be upgraded at round 11. Which makes me think if Caff is carrying a niggling injury then this is what he may be alluding too - half a season for Caff to get himself right.
mattys123
Hall of Famer
- Mar 24, 2008
- 31,426
- 20,284
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- LAK, NUFC, SAS, SFGiants, 49ers,
- Banned
- #69
Re: Delistings
GWS maybe? Surely he is better value than a washed up Brogan (just, maybe)
Or maybe the Lions, they just traded for a ruckman who said the petrol tank was empty.
GWS maybe? Surely he is better value than a washed up Brogan (just, maybe)
Or maybe the Lions, they just traded for a ruckman who said the petrol tank was empty.
Cousin of Daicos
HEY MAGPIE ARMY!
Re: Delistings
Would still be amazed if we let Caff go so easily.
Aside from injuries, why else would he have had an off year? Surely he did enough in 2010 to overlook ONE off year due to no pre-season and injuries throughout?
I mean hell, if we held onto Brad Dick and Sean Rusling for so long...
Would still be amazed if we let Caff go so easily.
Aside from injuries, why else would he have had an off year? Surely he did enough in 2010 to overlook ONE off year due to no pre-season and injuries throughout?
I mean hell, if we held onto Brad Dick and Sean Rusling for so long...
Jesus Baulks
Cancelled
- Apr 11, 2011
- 1,816
- 2
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Banned
- #73
Re: Delistings
Hine mentioned him in his interview as one of the players ready to step up next year, so you wouldn't think so. With Dick gone, Didak coming to a close and Krakouer in his late twenties, I think we'd definitely like to keep Ugle around. He showed a bit in the back half of the year I thought, looks a lively type.
Hine mentioned him in his interview as one of the players ready to step up next year, so you wouldn't think so. With Dick gone, Didak coming to a close and Krakouer in his late twenties, I think we'd definitely like to keep Ugle around. He showed a bit in the back half of the year I thought, looks a lively type.
Re: Delistings
does anyone know exactly how it works with blokes like stubbs farmer ugle? they were all drafted in 2010 and according to afl rules draftees must get a minimum 2 year contract. therefore they cannot be cut after 1 year. however, can we take them off the senior list and place them on the rookie list?
right now we have 51 players on the list (either senior or rookies) as listed below. this list includes 8 rookies. therefore there are 43 senior listed players. my understanding is that we can only have a maximum of 40 senior listed players after the national draft, and can upgrade a rookie mid year to make 41. leigh brown is still on this list so it's really 42, but we therefore still need to cut another 5 players prior to the national draft to give us the minimum 3 choices in that draft. witts will be added to the senior list via the last of those 3 picks (67)
so who are the unlucky 5? dick will very likely retire, leaving 4 more. mccarthy and macaffer sound as good as gone (as much as i hate to see them both leave 2 2nd year draftees are alot cheaper than these 2 and hence relieve a little cap pressure). so 2 more. who?
12 Ball, Luke
17 Beams, Dayne
11 Blair, Jarryd
48 Bolton, Jye (R)
15 Brown, Leigh
16 Brown, Nathan
27 Buckley, Simon
29 Ceglar, Jonathon
18 Clarke, Martin
32 Cloke, Travis
49 Cribbin, Paul (R)
1 Davis, Leon
31 Dawes, Chris
33 Dick, Brad
4 Didak, Alan
0 Elliot, Jamie
41 Farmer, Daniel
35 Fasolo, Alex
6 Goldsack, Tyson
44 Gordon, Thomas (R)
45 Hunter, Thomas (R)
26 Johnson, Ben
18 Jolly, Darren
23 Keeffe, Lachlan
7 Krakouer, Andrew
30 Macaffer, Brent
5 Maxwell, Nick
3 McCarthy, John
50 McNamara, Shae (R)
8 O'Brien, Harry
10 Pendlebury, Scott
47 Perham, Jack (R)
38 Reed, Scott (R)
20 Reid, Ben
46 Reilly, Declan (R)
14 Rounds, Luke
40 Seedsman, Paul
39 Shaw, Heath
22 Sidebottom, Steele
28 Sinclair, Ben
43 Stubbs, Trent
36 Swan, Dane
2 Tarrant, Chris
13 Thomas, Dale
24 Thomas, Josh
34 Toovey, Alan
37 Ugle, Kirk
21 Wellingham, Sharrod
19 Wood, Cameron
0 Yagmoor, Peter
25 Young, Thomas
does anyone know exactly how it works with blokes like stubbs farmer ugle? they were all drafted in 2010 and according to afl rules draftees must get a minimum 2 year contract. therefore they cannot be cut after 1 year. however, can we take them off the senior list and place them on the rookie list?
right now we have 51 players on the list (either senior or rookies) as listed below. this list includes 8 rookies. therefore there are 43 senior listed players. my understanding is that we can only have a maximum of 40 senior listed players after the national draft, and can upgrade a rookie mid year to make 41. leigh brown is still on this list so it's really 42, but we therefore still need to cut another 5 players prior to the national draft to give us the minimum 3 choices in that draft. witts will be added to the senior list via the last of those 3 picks (67)
so who are the unlucky 5? dick will very likely retire, leaving 4 more. mccarthy and macaffer sound as good as gone (as much as i hate to see them both leave 2 2nd year draftees are alot cheaper than these 2 and hence relieve a little cap pressure). so 2 more. who?
12 Ball, Luke
17 Beams, Dayne
11 Blair, Jarryd
48 Bolton, Jye (R)
15 Brown, Leigh
16 Brown, Nathan
27 Buckley, Simon
29 Ceglar, Jonathon
18 Clarke, Martin
32 Cloke, Travis
49 Cribbin, Paul (R)
1 Davis, Leon
31 Dawes, Chris
33 Dick, Brad
4 Didak, Alan
0 Elliot, Jamie
41 Farmer, Daniel
35 Fasolo, Alex
6 Goldsack, Tyson
44 Gordon, Thomas (R)
45 Hunter, Thomas (R)
26 Johnson, Ben
18 Jolly, Darren
23 Keeffe, Lachlan
7 Krakouer, Andrew
30 Macaffer, Brent
5 Maxwell, Nick
3 McCarthy, John
50 McNamara, Shae (R)
8 O'Brien, Harry
10 Pendlebury, Scott
47 Perham, Jack (R)
38 Reed, Scott (R)
20 Reid, Ben
46 Reilly, Declan (R)
14 Rounds, Luke
40 Seedsman, Paul
39 Shaw, Heath
22 Sidebottom, Steele
28 Sinclair, Ben
43 Stubbs, Trent
36 Swan, Dane
2 Tarrant, Chris
13 Thomas, Dale
24 Thomas, Josh
34 Toovey, Alan
37 Ugle, Kirk
21 Wellingham, Sharrod
19 Wood, Cameron
0 Yagmoor, Peter
25 Young, Thomas
- Jan 12, 2011
- 25,405
- 35,588
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Delistings
You confuse a player getting a 2 year contract with not being able to cut a player on a contract, they are different things.
We have done it in the past. Our last one was Toby Thoolen.
The Club must payout the remainder of the contract if that player is not re-drafted or placed on the rookie list.
Players can be cut after one year, it happens more often than you think.
You confuse a player getting a 2 year contract with not being able to cut a player on a contract, they are different things.
We have done it in the past. Our last one was Toby Thoolen.
The Club must payout the remainder of the contract if that player is not re-drafted or placed on the rookie list.
Similar threads
