Do Collingwood have any good players?

[Brad Goodman]

I'm struggling to think of any who are better than mediocre.

Certainly none worthy of All-Australian selection...

(funny thing is that some knobs actually have this opinion)

 

[AndyLucimitis]

The Collingwood paranoia continues - what's wrong, I thought you enjoyed being hated ?

 

[PumpyChowdown]

Didak, Davis, Swan and Pendlebury are the only ones bordering on okay. The rest are hacks and spuds.

 

[didak04]

I'm amazed how a bunch of plodders can finish top 4 and reach a prelim.

**** Mick must be a good coach.

 

[jerry springer]

their easy draw makes their player look better

they will get sorted out in the finals

opps

 

[Shawt]

I'm struggling to think of any who are better than mediocre.

Certainly none worthy of All-Australian selection...

(funny thing is that some ******s actually have this opinion)

Seriously... just enjoy what we accomplish as a team, who cares what "they" think.

I'm never going to rate a Carlton player above a Collingwood player - something in me will just never let me see them as more than a bunch of hacks. It's how tribal footy works.

 

[jerry springer]

"their backline is weak" is the best one ive heard this year

 

[simba_]

the real question is, do any collingwood players not have a criminal record?

 

[magpie_militia]

the real question is, do any collingwood players not have a criminal record?

I'd say the real question is, do any Port players actually want to play for Port?

 

[Surkin]

Swan and Pendlebury are good players.

Davis and Didak are good players when there is no pressure.

The rest are mediocre.

 

[Johnson#26]

OMG LOLZ u cant b seriose th Pies r lyke worst az didnt' u see dem wen teams like donz and tha crows beat them this yr and dont forget like their collywooble reocord in finals bahahahaha omg 1990 wasnt even their flag u saw esseden choaked so reked pies fanz hahahahaha

 

[Pie eyed]

the real question is, do any collingwood players not have a criminal record?

No the real question is will Port Adelaide have any players by round 1 next season, but nobody cares enough to ask the question.

Has a Club ever just simply folded and ceased to exist before?

 

[absy]

I'd say the real question is, do any Port players actually want to play for Port?

Hahaha

 

[mongrel_punt]

Just enjoy it without gloating.

We still lack the top liners St.Kilda and Geelong have, although we are a very even side across the 22. We will need all players firing to advance into the GF.

 

[AG]

Presti, Maxwell, Shaw, O'Brien, Swan, Davis, Beams, Pendlebury, Didak, and Lockyer are all good.

Cloke can be good but he is mentally shot this season. Something isn't right with him.

 

[robertg22]

Spuds, hacks, mediocre, whatever you want to label us...
Fact is we're in our 2nd prelim in 3 years and have made finals last 4 years. We've often lacked perceived 'star power' but it's probably more to do with a hard working game plan that we run, rather than the quality of our players. Many Sydney supporters will agree that they thought Rhyce Shaw was a spud but now think he is a gun. This does not surprise me.

 

[Spluff]

I'm struggling to think of any who are better than mediocre.

Certainly none worthy of All-Australian selection...

(funny thing is that some knobs actually have this opinion)

Worthy being the key word.

 

[The Wrecker]

They have 22 pretty decent players and that's all you need in a team sport.

 

[Blur]

No the real question is will Port Adelaide have any players by round 1 next season, but nobody cares enough to ask the question.

Has a Club ever just simply folded and ceased to exist before?

I reckon, come round 1, Port will be swept under the carpet indefinately. No one will ask what happened to them. The players will all be enjoying playing for other clubs, the supporters no longer plagued by the inconsitency, and Choco can do whatever the hell he wants!

 

[Blur]

No the real question is will Port Adelaide have any players by round 1 next season, but nobody cares enough to ask the question.

Has a Club ever just simply folded and ceased to exist before?

I reckon, come round 1, Port will be swept under the carpet indefinately. No one will ask what happened to them. The players will all be enjoying playing for other clubs, the supporters no longer plagued by the inconsitency, and Choco can do whatever the hell he wants!

 

[Mondeo]

Swan and Pendlebury are good players.

Davis and Didak are good players when there is no pressure.

The rest are mediocre.

You have the best credentials for recognising mediocity

 

[cancat]

Presti, Maxwell, Shaw, O'Brien, Swan, Davis, Beams, Pendlebury, Didak, and Lockyer are all good.

Those are all good players but this thread is yet another sook about Collingwood players in the All Australian team. Of all those players only Swan deserved to be in the team and he should be on the interchange bench.

 

[demondavey]

I'm struggling to think of any who are better than mediocre.

Certainly none worthy of All-Australian selection...

(funny thing is that some knobs actually have this opinion)

No your all rubbish, in fact melbourne should have had more AA players

 

[AG]

Those are all good players but this thread is yet another sook about Collingwood players in the All Australian team. Of all those players only Swan deserved to be in the team and he should be on the interchange bench.

I thought Davis was deserving. LeCras was unlucky but I don't think Porplyzia was as good as either. Davis finished off the season poorly but he was on fire for the majority of the year.

 

[Footy guru]

Those are all good players but this thread is yet another sook about Collingwood players in the All Australian team. Of all those players only Swan deserved to be in the team and he should be on the interchange bench.

Agree with you dont think Maxwell deserved to be in it before gilbert as he place the loose man whereas gilbert is accountable, Davis not before Le Cras although you are wrong about Swan being on bench - based on Statistics in the age today should be in before Selwood or Montagna if you base it on clearances , inside 50's and goals scored. I'm pretty sure last night they said he had the highest goal assists as well. should have been named in midfield so Le Cras got berth in forward line. Swan has even had more rebound 50's than Maxwell and if you compare him to other backman his score is quite low in that area. Sam Fisher played loose man down back last year and didnt make it this year.