draft top 10 - who do they remind you of

[Popey]

Deledio = Buckley/Pavlich
Roughead = Neitz/Jakovich
Griffen = Hayes/R.Harvey
Tambling = Wells/P.Matera
Franklin = Tarrant/Goodes
Williams = Croad/Harley
Lewis = Barnard/D.Harris
Meesen = Clark/Charman
Russell = Yze/Bowden
Egan = O'Loughlin/X.Clark

god no

 

[dascman03]

deledio-chris judd

tambling-daniel wells

LOL

Judd has pace
End of story

 

[Silvagnis]

Jordan Russell = Aussie Jones

Jordan Russell = Joel Smith
Matty Lappin = Jones

 

[Heisenberg_]

LOL

Judd has pace
End of story

20-metre sprint
Danyle Pearce (Sturt) - 2.79sec
Richard Tambling (Southern Districts) - 2.87sec
Jordan Russell (West Adelaide) - 2.89sec
Brett Deledio (Murray Bushrangers) - 2.90sec
Jesse Wells (Burnie) - 2.95sec
Chad Gibson (Norwood) - 2.95sec
Tim Hill (Bendigo Pioneers) - 2.95sec
Chris Egan (Murray Bushrangers) - 2.95sec
Clinton Young (North Ballarat Rebels) - 2.97sec
Jarred Moore (Dandenong Stingrays) - 3.00sec

You were saying

I'll throw these in for you as well

Standing vertical jump
Chad Gibson (Norwood) - 73.0cm
Danyle Pearce (Sturt) - 70cm
Tim Hill (Bendigo Pioneers) - 70cm
Brett Deledio (Murray Bushrangers) - 68.0cm
Angus Monfries (Sturt) - 68.0cm
Matt Little (Calder Cannons) - 67.0cm
Jordan Lewis (Geelong Falcons) - 67.0cm
Richard Tambling (Southern Districts) - 66.0cm
Jayden Attard (Dandenong Stingrays) - 66.0cm
Dean Limbach (Calder Cannons) - 65.0cm

Running vertical jumpDanyle Pearce (Sturt) - 96cm
Chris Egan (Murray Bushrangers) - 94cm
Richard Tambling (Southern Districts) - 93cm
Brett Deledio (Murray Bushrangers) - 92cm
Dean Limbach (Calder Cannons) - 90cm
Tom Williams (Morningside) - 87cm
Danny Meyer (Glenelg) - 87cm
Chad Gibson (Norwood) - 86cm
Damien McCormack (Dandenong Stingrays) - 84cm
Ryan Willitts (Northern Knights) - 83cm

 

[Bentleigh]

Deledio - Hodge
.

Not sure bout that.

Id go with Goddard/Pavlich

 

[Bentleigh]

LOL

Judd has pace
End of story

Deledio doesnt have pace?

 

[Cuneyt]

dascman03 is jealous

 

[Cuneyt]

Deledio - Hodge

If thats true then we stuffed up

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Deledio - Chris Mainwaring, only taller
Roughead - Nietz, but not as quick over the first 5-10
Griffen - Buckley, without the fig jam
Tambling - Peter Matera, only smaller
Franklin - Ottens, he's nothing like TarrentHaven't seen the rest

I have heard plenty of well-informed people compare Franklin to Tarrant and also Goodes so I think I'll take their opinion over yours. Never heard a single comparison to Ottens, from what I've seen of him and heard of him he is nothing at all like Ottens. Stupid comment.

 

[metallichris]

It seems that some people are taking this thread the wrong way. It's called 'draft top 10 - who do they remind you of'. Now that will come down to all different results because different people have different opinions. It seems that people are saying that other people's opinions are wrong, which just doesn't work because they're all interpreted differently.

Originally Posted by dascman03
LOL

Judd has pace
End of story

Deledio is just about as fast as Judd. In the 20m sprint, Deledio got 2.90sec, and back when Judd did it, he got 2.90 as well. So next time think before you speak.

 

[Lajon]

i heard that luke blackwell is havng a great pre-season

and that is relevant in this thread why??

 

[tigers1au]

I have heard plenty of well-informed people compare Franklin to Tarrant and also Goodes so I think I'll take their opinion over yours. Never heard a single comparison to Ottens, from what I've seen of him and heard of him he is nothing at all like Ottens. Stupid comment

I can see the how the goodes comparison might apply, but goodes is more thickly set than Franklin. Franklin is a tall, lean forward/ruckman. Who moves well and has nice skills, similar to Ottens(when healthy that is). And they both seem to have temperament problems ie. When the going gets tough they tend to look for a place to hide. You can delude yourself as much as you want about Franklin being like Tarrant if you want, but the first time you actually see him play you'll see that I'm right and will beg me for my forgiveness, which is pending, depending upon how much you grovel.

 

[tigers1au]

oh yeah, Goodes has much better footyball instincts than Franklin aswell.

 

[Jabso]

This is the playing style not if they're as good as or as bad as:

Deledio - Pavlich but quicker
Roughead - D.Schwarze
Griffen - Buckley but lighter
Tambling - Wells
Franklin - Goodes/Tarrant
Williams - B.Kinnear (if B.Kinnear was any good)
Lewis - Athletic Ling
Meesen - Charman
Russell - N.Lappin
Egan - X.Clarke/O'Louqlin in the midfield hopefully

As for Collingwood's other draftee here's what I've heard:
Rusling: Don't really know apart from the stupid carey comparison. Maybe a lighter but faster Pavlich?
Iaccobuchi: Picket and Licuria
T.Cloke: Ottens

 

[Silvagnis]

Anyone know who Jesse Dubbya Smith reminds you of? Perhaps Ben Hart
He would have gone top ten for sure and his career barring injury will surpass most of the players taken before him.

 

[F/D]

Tambling= A tougher version of Aker

 

[F/D]

Anyone know who Jesse Dubbya Smith reminds you of? Perhaps Ben Hart
He would have gone top ten for sure and his career barring injury will surpass most of the players taken before him.

He reminds me of a Clement.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

I can see the how the goodes comparison might apply, but goodes is more thickly set than Franklin.



Franklin is a tall, lean forward/ruckman. Who moves well and has nice skills, similar to Ottens(when healthy that is). And they both seem to have temperament problems ie. When the going gets tough they tend to look for a place to hide.

Firstly, Franklin is about 86kgs at 17 years old! How heavy was Gooodes at 17? As for the temparament problems, think your thinking of Richo there mate. Don't delude yourself into thinking you have gotten rid of that problem.

 

[deck]

You can delude yourself as much as you want about Franklin being like Tarrant if you want.

At the teal cup carnival all the scouts were calling him tarrant like and he was even asked in a interview about being compared to tarrant. Just out of interest how many games have you seen franklin play?

 

[theorangeapple]

mitch morton - nick dal santo; the common denominator being class. also watch out for mitch's foot skills they are pretty special. the roo's recruiting manager said he would be on a par with any other player picked in the draft incl deledio.

 

[tigers1au]

Firstly, Franklin is about 86kgs at 17 years old! How heavy was Gooodes at 17? As for the temparament problems, think your thinking of Richo there mate. Don't delude yourself into thinking you have gotten rid of that problem.

I don't know exactly how heavy Goodes was at 17 but I remember he wasn't as lean as Franklin.

At the teal cup carnival all the scouts were calling him tarrant like and he was even asked in a interview about being compared to tarrant. Just out of interest how many games have you seen franklin play?

All the scouts, just out of interest how many scouts told you this. I think you've been listening to pre draft hype, where player abilities tend to be blown out of proportion. Just for the record I've seen Franklin play a couple of times both in person and on tv, and it was pretty obvious that he's a different player to Tarrant.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

I don't know exactly how heavy Goodes was at 17 but I remember he wasn't as lean as Franklin.

Well I'm telling you right now he was as lean as Franklin, possibly moreso. 86kgs at 17yo, you wouldn't want to be any heavier than that.

 

[tigers1au]

Well I'm telling you right now he was as lean as Franklin, possibly moreso. 86kgs at 17yo, you wouldn't want to be any heavier than that.

mmm, I don't have the stats in front of me at the moment, but isn't Franklin around 197.5cm and goodes about 193cm(current height), as is Tarrant. So physically at least he looks leaner. And Goodes does have a very solid build.

 

[team_x]

Adam Iacobucci - Byron Pickett - take it from me.

Take it from you? Why? Did you read Wisbey's profile did you?

 

[stefoid]

20-metre sprint

Jesse Wells (Burnie) - 2.95sec

really? geez. this is a 195cm 94 kilo guy.