draft top 10 - who do they remind you of

[tige19]

Whys that champ.

Because I said so , who knows Deledio could be the biggest thing in football in 12 months similiur to Judd or he could be a massive dissapointment like Josh Fraser only time will tell.

No doubting he will be a very good footballer but weather or not he will be a gun or not is yet to be determined.

Do you think Luke Hodge is a gun??? i would say not and over his career he avgs something like only 3 or so less touches a game than Judd its just how we percieve these things our selves.

Bye the way Hodge will be a gun no doubting that at all, you have to remeber when comparing Hodge to Judd there is a year and half between them in age, this year will be the coming of Luke Hodge.

cheers

 

[Bockchoy67]

Deledio - Matthew Pavlich
Roughead - Justin Leppitsch
Griffen - Lenny Hayes
Tambling - Daniel Wells
Franklin - Chris Tarrant
Williams - Trent Croad
Lewis: Paul Licuria
Meesen: Jamie Charman
Russell - Robert Murphy
Egan - Michael O'Loughlin

 

[Bentleigh]

Deledio - Matthew Pavlich

An upgrade of Goodard / Pavlich would be great.

 

[F/D]

Deledio - James Hird
Tambling - A tougher version of Aker
Franklin - Chris Tarrant
Williams - Angwin
Lewis: Hodge
Meesen: Charman
Russell - A.Wesh
Egan - R.Clarke

 

[Tigerbob]

Deledio - James Hird
Tambling - A tougher version of Aker
Franklin - Chris Tarrant
Williams - Angwin
Lewis: Hodge
Meesen: Charman
Russell - A.Wesh
Egan - R.Clarke

Pretty good assessment right there!!

 

[fishbowl]

I'll comment on the Hawk ones, Roughead - Jonathon Brown, Franklin - A. Goodes, Lewis - L. Hodge. Tambling - Eddie Hocking or Willie Rioli.

 

[Bentleigh]

I'll comment on the Hawk ones, Roughead - Jonathon Brown, Franklin - A. Goodes, Lewis - L. Hodge. Tambling - Eddie Hocking or Willie Rioli.

 

[Nightwolf]

I'll comment on the Hawk ones, Roughead - Jonathon Brown, Franklin - A. Goodes, Lewis - L. Hodge. Tambling - Eddie Hocking or Willie Rioli.

Hahaha, you are one biased supporter Fishbowl....

 

[banger888]

Deledio will be the next M. Voss/Hird/Buckley

Haha maybe but more likely Greg Tivendale or Aaron Fiora

 

[Bentleigh]

Haha maybe but more likely Greg Tivendale or Aaron Fiora

Why would that be more likly?

 

[superstar]

Deledio - faster Cam Bruce
Roughhead - David Schwartz
Griffen - Lenny Hayes
Tambling - Aaron Davey
Franklin - Adem Goodes
Williams - Luke Livingstone
Lewis - Beau Waters
Meeson - Steve Allessio
Russell - Robert Murphy seems a good comparison
Egan - smaller Jared Brennan

 

[Bentleigh]

Deledio - faster Cam Bruce
Tambling - Aaron Davey

Roughhead - David Schwartz
Franklin - Adem Goodes
Lewis - Beau Waters

Hawks seem to have done the best from the draft then eh?

 

[superstar]

Hawks seem to have done the best from the draft then eh?

Your words, not mine.

Those seem to be pretty close to the general opinion on most of the players. I suppose you would have preferred I say Deledio=Judd even though I see few similarities.

 

[theorangeapple]

Your words, not mine.

Those seem to be pretty close to the general opinion on most of the players. I suppose you would have preferred I say Deledio=Judd even though I see few similarities.

i agree, ive said all along that a quicker bruce is the best comparision to deledio. i dont see alot of judd in the way he plays.

 

[Nightwolf]

Deledio - faster Cam Bruce, as superstar said
Roughhead - Justin Leppitsch is probably the best comparison
Griffen - Lenny Hayes
Tambling - Michael Long
Franklin - Adam Goodes/Leigh Mattews / Seriously, maybe Tarrant aswell
Williams - Ben Holland?? I dont know about williams....
Lewis - Luke Hodge/Paul Licuria
Meeson - Charman
Russell - Probably a Joel Smith type
Egan - Michael o'Lachlan

 

[Bolt]

Chris Egan - Gavin Wanganeen
Roughead - Croad
Deledio - Hodge

Adam Iacobucci - Byron Pickett - take it from me.

Well then Hawthorn wasted another top three pick.

I hope for Hawthorn's sake he turns out to be better than croad

 

[superstar]

Lewis - Luke Hodge/Paul Licuria

Lewis' body shape is similar to Hodge, but I don't think they are of similar talent.

Hodge's foot skills and footy smarts are far superior IMO.

 

[Bentleigh]

Your words, not mine.

Going by your list of comparisons...

I could get out some quotes which had you uttering differnt opions if you like.

Those seem to be pretty close to the general opinion on most of the players. I suppose you would have preferred I say Deledio=Judd even though I see few similarities.

He shares some things with Judd. I wouldn't say the same.

Id like to remind you; just because a player plays in a similar style doesnt make them as good as that player.

Lewis' body shape is similar to Hodge, but I don't think they are of similar talent.

Hodge's foot skills and footy smarts are far superior IMO.

Yep. Very good back pocket.

 

[blaisee]

the difference between Deledio and johnston/Judd, is that deledio can mark. It is probably one of the best features of his game and why he will be better than both

 

[worthy]

Yep. Very good back pocket.

One of the true onballers in the draft, averaged over 30 possies whilst rarely training, and your labelling him a back pocket.
Lewis>>>Meyer

 

[superstar]

the difference between Deledio and johnston/Judd, is that deledio can mark. It is probably one of the best features of his game and why he will be better than both

Boys and girls, this is what an idiot looks like.

 

[Bentleigh]

One of the true onballers in the draft, averaged over 30 possies whilst rarely training, and your labelling him a back pocket.
Lewis>>>Meyer

Im rather happy with Meyer. Still at 12.

I still reckon you took Lewis much too high.

 

[worthy]

Im rather happy with Meyer. Still at 12.

I still reckon you took Lewis much too high.

And that's based on?

 

[Lenny*]

You're all obssessed.

 

[worthy]

You're all obssessed.

Yep, you say that like it's a bad thing