DT Trading Discussion 2010 (Part 4)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
If it's this week I would go Fisher, Hargrave had a great game on the weekend...but then again so did Brian Lake haha. He hasn't been overly reliable yet this season!

If Monty is out of my price range (I can afford him but need to upgrade other players) is NDS still a good buy though?

My midfield would be: Swan, Judd, NDS, Gibbs, Selwood, Barlow
 
Lookin for a little help here guys

Bringing in Ablett for Mckenzie

Ablett's BE is 198, whilst McKenzie's is 112. Don't think either will make it obviously. Would I be better holding off a week?
 
I don't see many really good money making options for me this week. so im thinking of going Silvagni to Hargrave, i just have enough in the bank to do it.

That will leave me 1 upgrade left in the mid and Waters/pods my 7th fwd/def with 12 trades and no money in the bank.

Thoughts?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Unsure whether to upgrade Silvagni to Hargrave and leave him as my 7th back. I am 1k off getting Heath Shaw at a bargain price which is very frustrating. I already have Sam Fisher as I brought him in last week.
 
Rate these trade options for me if you will:

Option 1:
Tippett > Playfair/Watts

Kenelly > any defender I like (main options would be Scotland, Carazzo, Gilbert etc I think as I already have Hodge Goddard and Enright)

Option 2:
Cover Kennelly with Nason and instead focus on Tippett > Watts/Playfair and then Martin > any midfielder I like (probably one of Hayes, Montagna or Judd)

Obviously I will have to do both options in the longer term, I'm just interested into which you think should be done first and where's the best value to be had.
 
Hey All,

I have 12 trades and 8K left.

My team is as follows:

Backs: Goddard, Hodge, Enright, Shaw, Waters, Maguire, Kennelly (Emerg: Davis & Webberley)

Mids: Bartel, Swan, Gibbs, Selwood, Montagna, Barlow (Emerg: Martin & Shuey)

Rucks: Sandilands, Hills (Emerg: Warnock & Lobbe)

Fwds: Pavlich, ROK, Brown, Gia, Buddy, Didak, Pods (Emerg: Gumbleton & Rockliff)

Now I think my team is ok, but I need to get rid of Kennelly either this week or next.

My thoughts are downgrade Rockliff --> Playfair & Kennelly --> $360,000 defender (Fisher, Duffield).

I really want Gilbert though who costs a bit more. Who else can I downgrade to get that extra bit of money.

Any ideas what I should do?

Cheers.
 
Lake is a tease, he doesn't rack them up like that every week.

I'm starting to consider Gilbert. Huge scores and is now in the elites for marks per game stats. Lake is just ahead of Gilbert now and only Bower is higher with his 2 game average.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

He's unique, but I have a complete midfield and I wanted look to him unless your tryna save same serious $
 
anyone else seriously considering luke power at 330k ish?
With only 2 upgrades left for my team (Silvagni and Martin)... I am beginning to wonder how to approach them. Considered Power earlier last week as an upgrade target but decided against that but now he does look very enticing. At only 330k, he is a bargain. He would be my 6th midfielder with my midfield at the moment being Swan, Bartel, Selwood, Watson, Barlow and Martin with Shuey and Stevenson on the bench. I'm a good 20k short of Goodes which is disappointing as he would have been a perfect pick-up at 360k.

Which upgrade do you prefer?

Martin to Power
OR
Silvagni to Hargrave +30k

Instead of downgrading Rockliff to Playfair, I could downgrade him to a 77k player as my 9th forward (with hitchcock cover as 8th forward) which would free up enough cash to get Goodes instead of Power or Duffield instead of Hargraves.

Opinions?
 
With only 2 upgrades left for my team (Silvagni and Martin)... I am beginning to wonder how to approach them. Considered Power earlier last week as an upgrade target but decided against that but now he does look very enticing. At only 330k, he is a bargain. He would be my 6th midfielder with my midfield at the moment being Swan, Bartel, Selwood, Watson, Barlow and Martin with Shuey and Stevenson on the bench. I'm a good 20k short of Goodes which is disappointing as he would have been a perfect pick-up at 360k.

Which upgrade do you prefer?

Martin to Power
OR
Silvagni to Hargrave +30k

Martin to Power.

Silvagni will be a great bench option for the remainder of the year and Hargrave is still unproven, despite the 125 (bare in mind lake got 190)

I will be grabbing Hall this week.

going to go Hall to Goodes and will finally have a complete forward line with only Trengove and Martin to upgrade.

Really need Shuey and Rocky to keep going up in value so i can cash them in and upgrade my mids.
 
Playfair + Power
OR
77k Random + Goodes

Quite tough... but with Chappy in the team it seems quite necessary to have cover. I must admit though, Goodes' DP could be extremely useful as I can swap him with Chappy if he gets injured and one of my West Coastie reserves can cover (Shuey, Stevenson)

Thoughts?
 
Playfair + Power
OR
77k Random + Goodes

Quite tough... but with Chappy in the team it seems quite necessary to have cover. I must admit though, Goodes' DP could be extremely useful as I can swap him with Chappy if he gets injured and one of my West Coastie reserves can cover (Shuey, Stevenson)

Thoughts?

make sure your 77k random is Mcniel
you'll thank me later if you work out how itll help you chapman situation
 
make sure your 77k random is Mcniel
you'll thank me later if you work out how itll help you chapman situation
Yep! Have been watching some of the reserves games and he is in fine form and with our crappy run with injuries I'd say he'll make his debut this year.
 
make sure your 77k random is Mcniel
you'll thank me later if you work out how itll help you chapman situation

although i like where your head is at. Don't you think it's a waste to have Goodes in the midfield if it prevents you from getting Boyd, Montag, Ablett?
 
Why is everyone jumping on Sylvia? 68, 48 and 49 all before his 107 don't sound very promising. I would have thought there were better options.
 
Their isn't aside from the people everyone has. (Excluding Brown)
He is at a nice price, and could prove a risky pick, with high reward.
 
Is it a wasted trade if i downgrade mayne to playfair and upgrade kennelly to carrazzo/enright/kelly.

This would leave my forward line with playfair, gumbleton or fyfe as my 7th forward. However they may score more then mayne but it will mean i have to use another trade to upgrade one of them in my forward line in the future.

My other option is to not trade this week until there is a suitable cheap rookie to downgrade jetta and upgrade kennelly and upgrade mayne later on?

Below is my current team with 12 trades left. Is there another option that anyone can see that i should do instead.

Defenders: Goddard, Hodge, Shaw, Gilbee, Kennelly, Maguire, Waters
(Webberley, Trengove)

Midfielders: Ablett, Bartel, Boyd, Cooney, Barlow, Cunnington
(Jetta, Martin)

Rucks: Sandilands, Hille
(Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Giansiracusa, Brown, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Franklin, Pod, Mayne
(Gumbleton, Fyfe)

Remaining: $13,100
Players in bold are who i think i need to upgrade.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top