EDFL Div 1 Discussion 2023

[LocalFootybuff63]

Mutaz el Nour to Deer Park..what an inclusion he'll he when not playing for Richmond VFL.

Could be playing in the AFL if picked up in the draft

 

[Turbos mail]

Another player there because he loves the club.

Isn’t he a deer park junior 1 pointer??

 

[Lee]

Isn’t he a deer park junior 1 pointer??

Yep

 

[Lee]

Mutaz el Nour to Deer Park..what an inclusion he'll he when not playing for Richmond VFL.

Great pick up, interesting too see how many games he actually plays, considering Mutaz is almost a staple in Richmond’s VFL side. Also a good chance he can get drafted

 

[Swoopingtime]

Lachie Smart to East Keilor.

SWOOPINGTIME

 

[inanunda]

Lachie Smart to East Keilor.

SWOOPINGTIME

Does he go ok?

 

[Executioner]

Div 1

Lachie Smart to East Keilor.

SWOOPINGTIME

Div 1 thread not Premier. No one cares about EK here.

 

[The Defender]

Lachie Smart to East Keilor.

SWOOPINGTIME

Probably change his mind again, announced as a Abers recruit last season didnt eventuate.

 

[Turbos mail]

Probably change his mind again, announced as a Abers recruit last season didnt eventuate.

Yes he does jump from club to club. Going to an opposition club it would have been a great offer. It was decent to begin with but they must have offered more. It’s out of control again. How many point is he. Thinking 5.
Opposition club, and been to a few clubs now. Also might have been VFL listed

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

Yes he does jump from club to club. Going to an opposition club it would have been a great offer. It was decent to begin with but they must have offered more. It’s out of control again. How many point is he. Thinking 5.
Opposition club, and been to a few clubs now. Also might have been VFL listed

Listed with Werribee last two seasons

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

Daniel Barnes new West Coburg Coach. Good luck to him.

Wonder if Phil Cleary put his hand up for the role once again?

 

[the horse whisper]

Yes he does jump from club to club. Going to an opposition club it would have been a great offer. It was decent to begin with but they must have offered more. It’s out of control again. How many point is he. Thinking 5.
Opposition club, and been to a few clubs now. Also might have been VFL listed

I’m guessing he gets and extra 2 points ontop of his points. 1 for more then 3 clubs in 3 years and 1 for change of clubs within the division. So he would have to be a 5-6 out could be a 7 depending on how many vfl games he played in those years.

 

[wce06]

How do points work if a player goes from a Div 1 team to a Premier Div team? Or when can I find the rules on points?

 

[1st time long time]

I’m guessing he gets and extra 2 points ontop of his points. 1 for more then 3 clubs in 3 years and 1 for change of clubs within the division. So he would have to be a 5-6 out could be a 7 depending on how many vfl games he played in those years.

6 is as high as you can go.

 

[the horse whisper]

6 is as high as you can go.

I’ve seen a player on a 7.

 

[the horse whisper]

How do points work if a player goes from a Div 1 team to a Premier Div team? Or when can I find the rules on points?

Well technically when he transfers both clubs will be in premier. So it will be same competition.

 

[1st time long time]

I’ve seen a player on a 7.

Who? Heath Shaw straight out of AFL was 6 for EK.

 

[the horse whisper]

Who? Heath Shaw straight out of AFL was 6 for EK.

It was in a different league. It was pre covid so not sure if the rules have changed but it can happen.
Could be ex vfl player, change clubs within same league then it could be your 3rd club within 3 years. That’s 5+1+1 = 7.
Then if heath shaw left east keilor after 1 year and went to apw then he would be 6 + 1 = 7.

 

[Turbos mail]

It was in a different league. It was pre covid so not sure if the rules have changed but it can happen.
Could be ex vfl player, change clubs within same league then it could be your 3rd club within 3 years. That’s 5+1+1 = 7.
Then if heath shaw left east keilor after 1 year and went to apw then he would be 6 + 1 = 7.

When will they learn to operate a calculator. That’s not smart recruiting

 

[ZingerAbed]

What happens if a team that is now in premier (deer park) loses a player to a Div 1 team/lesser comp
Does it add a point for moving from a premier competition?

 

[quicksmart]

Who? Heath Shaw straight out of AFL was 6 for EK.

Patrick Vezpremi was a 7.

Came from AFL to douttas = 6

Then moved to Paco + 1

This made him the only 7 point player in Australia.

 

[Gun Forward]

Patrick Vezpremi was a 7.

Came from AFL to douttas = 6

Then moved to Paco + 1

This made him the only 7 point player in Australia.

now playing at Melton South

 

[ROOS77]

6 is as high as you can go.

Can definitely be more than 6

 

[ROOS77]

Patrick Vezpremi was a 7.

Came from AFL to douttas = 6

Then moved to Paco + 1

This made him the only 7 point player in Australia.

Nick Graham at spotswood was a 7 pointer a few years back

 

[Canplaythisguy]

I’ve never heard of any local player being taxed other than GV and O&M, but also you have no reason to lie about being taxed at Rupo. Strange that’s how they do it.

Bloody disappointing if they had a disgruntled ex member put them in, that person is a “mop”. The stiffest part is APW would have spent close $200k+, and Tulla spent approx $100k on McKernan alone and both get cleared Most clubs trying to play finals just operating 2 books these days to get around it.

You’re kidding aren’t you?
APW spending close to 200k to win B grade. So you’re saying the average player would have been on $500 a game. You clearly have absolutely no idea. Stop throwing around accusations around clubs when you couldn’t be further from the truth.
Again the Mckernan information is wrong, as someone else mentioned it was job related. APW wouldn’t have even been in the top 3-4 spenders in B grade in 2022. You need to check some facts champ.