EDFL Division 1 2016

[Old Cat]

#7? He is a gun. What it is happening at CB? Surely not everyone is leaving?

#7 is a good one... But alas not the player being persuaded... Big $$$ thrown around I've been told..

 

[Turbos mail]

Assuming Craigieburns team stay as is. How does everyone think they will fare against teams in premier? Considering that they have the best midfield and the best forward line in div 1 by far?

I'm not sure if your seroius with this question but I will reply..
The reality is the current 2016!side would be relagated after 1 season. However they won't field the same side.

Use Douttas as an example, as there 2015 team is probably better than Craigieburn's 2016 side and you would have noticed they recruited pretty heavy in grabbing some good players from the country (Hartwig & Allan) as well as a top premier player from an opposition club (Veszpremi). Craigieburn will need to recruit a player like Hartwig to play on the gun forwards. Plus need a smart knowledgable coach who can take the club forward in all aspects as its not easy, just ask Barney.. It's a challenge out there no doubt, so they must appoint a quality person who has coached VFL or at the minimum senior level footy in a top comp.
*these comments are based on Buggie moving on after the seasons end as per reported on here..

 

[Old Cat]

Assuming Craigieburns team stay as is. How does everyone think they will fare against teams in premier? Considering that they have the best midfield and the best forward line in div 1 by far?

It's always your second tier players that determine how competitive you will be in a stronger division... Your best can only take you so far...

 

[Turbos mail]

I would have thought as is would finish 6-7

Your kidding Willo. Marby Park finished 6th and Strathmore finished 7th. Both of these clubs, and Avondale would beat Craigieburn of 2016 by 90+ points. West Coburg would beat them by 60+ points but are a bit younger and smaller.

Some players play a lower division every year (sometimes at different clubs) as they don't like the challenge or contest of playing against better players. Don't get carried away watching some guys in the lower division giving the impression they are superstars..

 

[Theyoungone]

Your kidding Willo. Marby Park finished 6th and Strathmore finished 7th. Both of these clubs, and Avondale would beat Craigieburn of 2016 by 90+ points. West Coburg would beat them by 60+ points but are a bit younger and smaller.

Some players play a lower division every year (sometimes at different clubs) as they don't like the challenge or contest of playing against better players. Don't get carried away watching some guys in the lower division giving the impression they are superstars..

You think Avondale would beat Craigieburn side this year by 90+ points? But can barely win More than 2 games. Craigieburn would sit above Avondale heights and west coburg if they kept the same side plus maybe 2 or 3 add ons.

 

[Theyoungone]

Your kidding Willo. Marby Park finished 6th and Strathmore finished 7th. Both of these clubs, and Avondale would beat Craigieburn of 2016 by 90+ points. West Coburg would beat them by 60+ points but are a bit younger and smaller.

Some players play a lower division every year (sometimes at different clubs) as they don't like the challenge or contest of playing against better players. Don't get carried away watching some guys in the lower division giving the impression they are superstars..

Who are these lower division players you speak of?

 

[Old Cat]

Some players play a lower level to be amongst friends/ family... CB have a few of those types as do most clubs...

 

[Outbackhack37]

Your kidding Willo. Marby Park finished 6th and Strathmore finished 7th. Both of these clubs, and Avondale would beat Craigieburn of 2016 by 90+ points. West Coburg would beat them by 60+ points but are a bit younger and smaller.

Some players play a lower division every year (sometimes at different clubs) as they don't like the challenge or contest of playing against better players. Don't get carried away watching some guys in the lower division giving the impression they are superstars..

From memory CB and Marby played a great praccie which was very close. Was that at the beginning of 2016 or 2015? My memory is fading. You cant read to much into praccies. Having said that Lakes beat APW in a praccie at the start of this year

 

[Little fella]

I'm not sure if your seroius with this question but I will reply..
The reality is the current 2016!side would be relagated after 1 season. However they won't field the same side.

Use Douttas as an example, as there 2015 team is probably better than Craigieburn's 2016 side and you would have noticed they recruited pretty heavy in grabbing some good players from the country (Hartwig & Allan) as well as a top premier player from an opposition club (Veszpremi). Craigieburn will need to recruit a player like Hartwig to play on the gun forwards. Plus need a smart knowledgable coach who can take the club forward in all aspects as its not easy, just ask Barney.. It's a challenge out there no doubt, so they must appoint a quality person who has coached VFL or at the minimum senior level footy in a top comp.
*these comments are based on Buggie moving on after the seasons end as per reported on here..

Have u been drinking again douttas 2015 side better than craigieburns 2016 side u r taking the piss craigieburn r a ten goal better side this year than last year Roberson kite bongo Piggot browning and if they keep all of them and there coach and picked up three quality players would push for finals

 

[EDFL knowitall]

Have u been drinking again douttas 2015 side better than craigieburns 2016 side u r taking the piss craigieburn r a ten goal better side this year than last year Roberson kite bongo Piggot browning and if they keep all of them and there coach and picked up three quality players would push for finals

Now your the one that's dreaming

 

[andleanback]

Have u been drinking again douttas 2015 side better than craigieburns 2016 side u r taking the piss craigieburn r a ten goal better side this year than last year Roberson kite bongo Piggot browning and if they keep all of them and there coach and picked up three quality players would push for finals

Pushing for premier division finals?? Are you dreaming

 

[Bissa3]

Your kidding Willo. Marby Park finished 6th and Strathmore finished 7th. Both of these clubs, and Avondale would beat Craigieburn of 2016 by 90+ points. West Coburg would beat them by 60+ points but are a bit younger and smaller.

Some players play a lower division every year (sometimes at different clubs) as they don't like the challenge or contest of playing against better players. Don't get carried away watching some guys in the lower division giving the impression they are superstars..

You are an out and out deadset flog turbo!! You have got no idea what you are talking about! Yes there is a significant gap particularly with the top 5-7 sides but you make out its a jump up to the AFL. If you honestly think AH an WC would beat CB by those margins you are deluded. And that the doutta side from last year is better than this years CB

 

[Billyblogs]

2016 CB team is no doubt better than DS 15 team,some people seem to try and just hammer them from any little bullshit angle they can concoct
IF they do win it (they haven't yet ) I hope they do well,this theory that nobody will travel there as its apparently in the middle of nowhere doesn't stack up they have cash to burn 3 ex AFL listed players ex prem players and guns from other comps. sounds like there on the move to me.

 

[Turbos mail]

Some players play a lower level to be amongst friends/ family... CB have a few of those types as do most clubs...

I agree with that on some players but it's a small minority of players.

 

[oldandslow]

Rather than comment on what Craigieburn are doing next year and who their coach might be it would be good to hear about this weeks game. Predictions, best on ground, key match ups.

 

[Turbos mail]

You are an out and out deadset flog turbo!! You have got no idea what you are talking about! Yes there is a significant gap particularly with the top 5-7 sides but you make out its a jump up to the AFL. If you honestly think AH an WC would beat CB by those margins you are deluded. And that the doutta side from last year is better than this years CB

Avondale would absolutely smash CB if each side had there best team. Now your the flog if you think otherwise..

Who would play full back on Rose? He would kick more than your total score, you fool.

Btw- I only answered a question and didn't start this topic of conversation, but some of you really have no idea on footy but enjoy watching CB beat up on clubs in div1. I'm sure you clap every goal against the bottom teams to. All 40 odd goals. Really laughable..

 

[Turbos mail]

Have u been drinking again douttas 2015 side better than craigieburns 2016 side u r taking the piss craigieburn r a ten goal better side this year than last year Roberson kite bongo Piggot browning and if they keep all of them and there coach and picked up three quality players would push for finals

Little Fella, surely your taking the piss here.. Good luck to you guys but you will need more than 3 players if you go up. Not sure on who you think these players are mate but Bongo is maybe the only one. Browning is young so give him a tick, but the others.. Ummm

 

[Usain_bolt]

Cragieburn by 31
Best on ground : bongetti

Key match ups / Tullamarine midfield very unaccountable last time they met

Piggot on Becker

 

[Bissa3]

Avondale would absolutely smash CB if each side had there best team. Now your the flog if you think otherwise..

Who would play full back on Rose? He would kick more than your total score, you fool.

Btw- I only answered a question and didn't start this topic of conversation, but some of you really have no idea on footy but enjoy watching CB beat up on clubs in div1. I'm sure you clap every goal against the bottom teams to. All 40 odd goals. Really laughable..

Your an idiot. A nobody with no idea!

 

[Billyblogs]

BOG D Scott
TM must negate young and kite they are the keys to CB
If the above happens TM win

 

[Old Cat]

CB if they play upto their best should be too strong.... But strange things can happen in Grand Finals...

 

[Old Cat]

I agree with that on some players but it's a small minority of players.

I did say some.. Which is not many, u may even say a small minority...

 

[Disco 45]

Avondale would absolutely smash CB if each side had there best team. Now your the flog if you think otherwise..

Who would play full back on Rose? He would kick more than your total score, you fool.

Btw- I only answered a question and didn't start this topic of conversation, but some of you really have no idea on footy but enjoy watching CB beat up on clubs in div1. I'm sure you clap every goal against the bottom teams to. All 40 odd goals. Really laughable..

You are an absolute goose!!

CB would beat AH if both teams had there strongest players on the park. You talk about rose yes he is an absolute gun but what about down the other end who would match up on Clokes x 2 robbo and fletch?
Page would dominate the ruck and would give CB mids first use of the ball.

As for the comment about clapping every goal against the bottom teams im sure you would be standing behind the goals when Pacco play APW with your little pacco beanie and scarf on that you've knitted at home and chase the ball once its gone through the goals to get it back to the umpire quicker so your team could kick more goals. Too bad they are useless and cant win a final!

Piss off back to the A grade forum u r a dead set clown and u talk about other people not knowing about football i havent seen u post 1 thing where you have been even close to knowing what u r on about ur just a useless prick.

 

[Billyblogs]

You are an absolute goose!!

CB would beat AH if both teams had there strongest players on the park. You talk about rose yes he is an absolute gun but what about down the other end who would match up on Clokes x 2 robbo and fletch?
Page would dominate the ruck and would give CB mids first use of the ball.

As for the comment about clapping every goal against the bottom teams im sure you would be standing behind the goals when Pacco play APW with your little pacco beanie and scarf on that you've knitted at home and chase the ball once its gone through the goals to get it back to the umpire quicker so your team could kick more goals. Too bad they are useless and cant win a final!

Piss off back to the A grade forum u r a dead set clown and u talk about other people not knowing about football i havent seen u post 1 thing where you have been even close to knowing what u r on about ur just a useless prick.

Tell us what you really think lol

 

[Aucklander]

Next person to hand out any abuse can take a day off.

Craigieburn too good and will win by 68. Young or Page BOG. I think the two earlier games should both be pretty good.