The AFL seem to think two new teams in the Gold Coast and Western Sydney are viable and will go ahead. My concern is the pressure these two teams will put on existing AFL clubs and State League competitions (and grass roots competitions and clubs) throughout Australia. The other thing I hate about the AFL is the unfair fixtures. So here is an idea of how the AFL could set itself up to prosper, be a fair sporting competition and strengthen football in general.
The Set Up
A 16 team competition to be split into two conferences.
The Allies Conference to consist of the following teams:
West Coast & Fremantle co-tenants of Stadium WA
Adelaide & Port Adelaide co-tenants of Football Park
Brisbane Lions all home games at the Gabba
Gold Coast all home games at Carrara
Sydney Swans all home games at the SCG
Western Sydney all home games at Olympic Stadium
The Victorians Conference to consist of the following teams:
Collingwood all home games at the MCG
Carlton all home games at Docklands
Essendon all home games at Docklands
St. Kilda all home games at Docklands
Geelong all home games at Kardinia Park
Tasmania Hawks, 8 home games at Launceston, 3 at MCG
Melbourne Tigers all home games at MCG
Western Kangaroos all home games at Docklands
The “New” Clubs
Gold Coast Football Club
- Based at Carrara with all home matches played from there
Western Sydney Football Club
- Based at Blacktown with all home games played at the Olympic Stadium
Tasmania Hawks
- A continuation of Hawthorn
- Based at Waverly
- 8 home games in Launceston, 3 at the MCG
Melbourne Tigers
- A merger of Richmond and Melbourne
- Colours Black, Gold and Red
Western Kangaroos
- A merger of Western Bulldogs and North Melbourne
- Based at Whitten Oval
- Colours Blue and White
The Fixture
Rounds 1-7 1st Leg of Internal Conference matches
All-Star match Victorians vs Allies
Rounds 8-15 vs other conference teams
Rounds 16-22 2nd Leg of Internal Conference matches
The Finals
The top 3 of each conference qualify to take positions 1-6 in the Finals. The position of the 6 teams is based on a merger of the ladders to determine who has the better overall result. These 6 teams get a break between Round 22 and the 1st week of Finals.
“Round 23” is to determine who gets positions 7 and 8 in the finals. 4th placed Victorians plays 5th placed Allies in one elimination game and 4th placed Allies play 5th placed Victorians in the other elimination game.
The Final 8 is then played as a 4 week finals series as it is now.
The Draft & Salary Cap
Would be as it is now except teams would be given the opportunity to use their 4th Round pick on a pre-picked player from their zone. It would be the responsibility, with funding from the AFL, for the clubs to oversee grass roots footy in their zone, including country areas.
The Victorians could have an 8 team “Reserves” and elite under 18 teams instead of the current set up with the AFL.
West Coast and Fremantle would look after the WAFL, Adelaide and Port the SANFL, Brisbane and Gold Coast the QAFL and Sydney and Western Sydney the NSWAFL.
The Problem
5 of the current Victorian clubs would have to change/adapt in order for football in general to go forward.
The Benefits
- A fair draw
- A meaningful representative game
- Maximising attendance
- Keeping standards up
- Allowing traditional state leagues stability
- Growing the game nationally
- Responsibility towards grass-roots football
- Stronger Victorian clubs through less competition
The Set Up
A 16 team competition to be split into two conferences.
The Allies Conference to consist of the following teams:
West Coast & Fremantle co-tenants of Stadium WA
Adelaide & Port Adelaide co-tenants of Football Park
Brisbane Lions all home games at the Gabba
Gold Coast all home games at Carrara
Sydney Swans all home games at the SCG
Western Sydney all home games at Olympic Stadium
The Victorians Conference to consist of the following teams:
Collingwood all home games at the MCG
Carlton all home games at Docklands
Essendon all home games at Docklands
St. Kilda all home games at Docklands
Geelong all home games at Kardinia Park
Tasmania Hawks, 8 home games at Launceston, 3 at MCG
Melbourne Tigers all home games at MCG
Western Kangaroos all home games at Docklands
The “New” Clubs
Gold Coast Football Club
- Based at Carrara with all home matches played from there
Western Sydney Football Club
- Based at Blacktown with all home games played at the Olympic Stadium
Tasmania Hawks
- A continuation of Hawthorn
- Based at Waverly
- 8 home games in Launceston, 3 at the MCG
Melbourne Tigers
- A merger of Richmond and Melbourne
- Colours Black, Gold and Red
Western Kangaroos
- A merger of Western Bulldogs and North Melbourne
- Based at Whitten Oval
- Colours Blue and White
The Fixture
Rounds 1-7 1st Leg of Internal Conference matches
All-Star match Victorians vs Allies
Rounds 8-15 vs other conference teams
Rounds 16-22 2nd Leg of Internal Conference matches
The Finals
The top 3 of each conference qualify to take positions 1-6 in the Finals. The position of the 6 teams is based on a merger of the ladders to determine who has the better overall result. These 6 teams get a break between Round 22 and the 1st week of Finals.
“Round 23” is to determine who gets positions 7 and 8 in the finals. 4th placed Victorians plays 5th placed Allies in one elimination game and 4th placed Allies play 5th placed Victorians in the other elimination game.
The Final 8 is then played as a 4 week finals series as it is now.
The Draft & Salary Cap
Would be as it is now except teams would be given the opportunity to use their 4th Round pick on a pre-picked player from their zone. It would be the responsibility, with funding from the AFL, for the clubs to oversee grass roots footy in their zone, including country areas.
The Victorians could have an 8 team “Reserves” and elite under 18 teams instead of the current set up with the AFL.
West Coast and Fremantle would look after the WAFL, Adelaide and Port the SANFL, Brisbane and Gold Coast the QAFL and Sydney and Western Sydney the NSWAFL.
The Problem
5 of the current Victorian clubs would have to change/adapt in order for football in general to go forward.
The Benefits
- A fair draw
- A meaningful representative game
- Maximising attendance
- Keeping standards up
- Allowing traditional state leagues stability
- Growing the game nationally
- Responsibility towards grass-roots football
- Stronger Victorian clubs through less competition