-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Fevola Trade (merged thread)
- Thread starter Amers
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Banned
- #903
Re: Rumour: Eagles keen on Fevola
Please, Tony Notte left more talent floating in his toilet than Jacqui Watts has in his whole body, Wouldnt swap those two for a second. Notte and Watts are roughly the same age and Notte has shown more flashes of brilliance than Watts has holding a camera. Unforunately for us Notte is 2 years away with his body and I guess when he is ready he can slot right into the forward pocket and be groomed into the role
Please, Tony Notte left more talent floating in his toilet than Jacqui Watts has in his whole body, Wouldnt swap those two for a second. Notte and Watts are roughly the same age and Notte has shown more flashes of brilliance than Watts has holding a camera. Unforunately for us Notte is 2 years away with his body and I guess when he is ready he can slot right into the forward pocket and be groomed into the role
Re: Rumour: Eagles keen on Fevola
i seriously doubt that. AT BEST he has another TWO 80 goal seasons in him. very few players carry their peak football far into their 30s. guys with attitude problems that do are even fewer.
obviously because you are trying to sell him you will be trying to convince people that he will be one of those rare players that will keep on kicking 90 goals a year till he is 40, but forgive me if i dont bite.
personally i think he will be a NORMAL player, he will play well and kick another 80 or more next year, another 60-80 the year after that, and then he will taper off as age and injury takes him over.
oh so you think he is going to still be kicking 90 goals a year at age 33 eh? mate he might have 4 or even 5 or 6 years left, but top shelf? 80 goal seasons?
i seriously doubt that. AT BEST he has another TWO 80 goal seasons in him. very few players carry their peak football far into their 30s. guys with attitude problems that do are even fewer.
obviously because you are trying to sell him you will be trying to convince people that he will be one of those rare players that will keep on kicking 90 goals a year till he is 40, but forgive me if i dont bite.
personally i think he will be a NORMAL player, he will play well and kick another 80 or more next year, another 60-80 the year after that, and then he will taper off as age and injury takes him over.
Re: Roos keen on Fev...direct from a board member....
Unfortunately Carlton has set the precedent of not paying for market in a trade situation, considering Judd probably will be one of the greatest footballers of all time, he was traded at at a huge loss to West Coast.
Carlton will probably feel the same pain if a deal is to go ahead.
Unfortunately Carlton has set the precedent of not paying for market in a trade situation, considering Judd probably will be one of the greatest footballers of all time, he was traded at at a huge loss to West Coast.
Carlton will probably feel the same pain if a deal is to go ahead.
Scodog10
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Rumour: Eagles keen on Fevola
massive lolz at the fact that west coast supporters want the guy at their club but the best iv seen them offer in this thread so far are Spangher (whose shown 2/5ths of bugger all so far), Mckinley(whose a very lazy small forward) and a third rounder in a supposed weak draft, your clubs supporters overate their own players more than anyone else by the length of the Flemington straight...
Also to the Carlton supporters who are saying we don't want to trade with Collingwood, the officials at your club have had enough (it may also have something to do with sponsorship and the prospect of financial backers pulling out), if they deem Collingwood to have offered what they believe to be Fev's value they will accept the deal... IMO i would shop around Medhurst to see what value we could get id say prob early second rounder then on trade that to Carlton so my offer would be.
Pick 14 + Pick 20-25 + Dawes
massive lolz at the fact that west coast supporters want the guy at their club but the best iv seen them offer in this thread so far are Spangher (whose shown 2/5ths of bugger all so far), Mckinley(whose a very lazy small forward) and a third rounder in a supposed weak draft, your clubs supporters overate their own players more than anyone else by the length of the Flemington straight...
Also to the Carlton supporters who are saying we don't want to trade with Collingwood, the officials at your club have had enough (it may also have something to do with sponsorship and the prospect of financial backers pulling out), if they deem Collingwood to have offered what they believe to be Fev's value they will accept the deal... IMO i would shop around Medhurst to see what value we could get id say prob early second rounder then on trade that to Carlton so my offer would be.
Pick 14 + Pick 20-25 + Dawes
Re: 3 way fevola deal inc west coast, carlton, collingwood
That's not what Eddie McG said on the radio this arvo -"only happened yesterday", "nothing has been decided as yet", "too early to say", "trade week is next week".
Collingwood are the only club NOT to have ruled him out.
That's not what Eddie McG said on the radio this arvo -"only happened yesterday", "nothing has been decided as yet", "too early to say", "trade week is next week".
Collingwood are the only club NOT to have ruled him out.
Re: Official Fev to be traded - either saints of Hawks
Roughead >>>>>>>>>>>>> Fevola
Roughead is only gonna get better, Fevola worse
Roughead >>>>>>>>>>>>> Fevola
Roughead is only gonna get better, Fevola worse
- Banned
- #910
Re: Rumour: Eagles keen on Fevola
Second are you really a Collingwood fan? What a terrible trade on your part. Why on earth would you want to give up that much.
Firstly I would suggest actually knowing something about our players before commenting on their worth.
Second are you really a Collingwood fan? What a terrible trade on your part. Why on earth would you want to give up that much.
PooMonkey
Tie dye biatch!!!
- Sep 23, 2009
- 3,409
- 519
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Manchester Utd, SF 49ers, Rovers.
Re: Roos keen on Fev...direct from a board member....
We payed very good value for Judd....
Pick 3, 20 + Josh Kennedy (Pick 5)
how was that not a fair deal
We payed very good value for Judd....
Pick 3, 20 + Josh Kennedy (Pick 5)
how was that not a fair deal
Absolute Gun
All Australian
Re: Roos keen on Fev...direct from a board member....
There is no way we would give up Pick 5 for a 28 year old drunk. When it is not even our premiership window.
There is no way we would give up Pick 5 for a 28 year old drunk. When it is not even our premiership window.
Ryan Dixon Webb
Club Legend
Re: Roos keen on Fev...direct from a board member....
I heard North were interested in Shaun Grigg, maybe Brendan Fevola + Shaun Grigg for Pick #5 is a bit more realistic.
I heard North were interested in Shaun Grigg, maybe Brendan Fevola + Shaun Grigg for Pick #5 is a bit more realistic.
Re: Rumour: Eagles keen on Fevola
And you are a fool.
Haha. A couple of people on here have said they want him, the majority do not. And Mckinley + Spangher for me is overpaying. It's not that we overrate them, it's just that's what he's worth to us IMO.
And you are a fool.
The Flying Belgian
Third Tall
Re: Roos keen on Fev...direct from a board member....
Gotta love Carlton fans.
Yes, a player who you're turfing out of the club for discipline will be desired by every other team
.
I'd say every team loves the though of a bloke kicking 70-odd goals a season - they just don't that bloke to be an arseclown.
Gotta love Carlton fans.
Yes, a player who you're turfing out of the club for discipline will be desired by every other team
. I'd say every team loves the though of a bloke kicking 70-odd goals a season - they just don't that bloke to be an arseclown.
Re: Roos keen on Fev...direct from a board member....
Wouldn't take that for Tippet alone, let alone giving up Knights and their first rounder too.
Wouldn't take that for Tippet alone, let alone giving up Knights and their first rounder too.
Re: Roos keen on Fev...direct from a board member....
Considering pick 5's more untouchable than Brent Harvey at the moment, I'd say you're a ****ing moron.
But that's just me.
Considering pick 5's more untouchable than Brent Harvey at the moment, I'd say you're a ****ing moron.
But that's just me.
Re: Rumour: Eagles keen on Fevola
Considering he's talking about a trade that would include Fev departing the Blues, it's probably best to assume Fev wouldn't be there (when discussing Carltons needs)
Surely not that hard to comprehend.
Is he gone? Where was I?
Considering he's talking about a trade that would include Fev departing the Blues, it's probably best to assume Fev wouldn't be there (when discussing Carltons needs)
Surely not that hard to comprehend.
TotalPackage
Draftee
Re: Pies in the Mix
But imagine if he kicked the winning goal in a GF against Carltank. That would be gold!
But imagine if he kicked the winning goal in a GF against Carltank. That would be gold!
Re: Carlton what will you be asking from fevolas clubs of choice either st kilda or hawthorn?
I cant see Kingy going around again, so I reckon he might be a valuable option in the ruck (trio of Kosi, Gardy, McEvoy) - if we did make a play at Fev (although Ross has said no), I reckon maybe our first round pick, or even our second round pick and Maguire since Carlton (despite their optimisim) need a big bodied defender. He is 25 and well over his injury - I'd hate to give him up but if the saints are keen on Fev then thats what may be needed to get it done.
I dont think Carlton can be overly demanding, they either accept something or get nothing. They couldn't play him if they didn't trade him, so they have painted themselves into a corner.
I cant see Kingy going around again, so I reckon he might be a valuable option in the ruck (trio of Kosi, Gardy, McEvoy) - if we did make a play at Fev (although Ross has said no), I reckon maybe our first round pick, or even our second round pick and Maguire since Carlton (despite their optimisim) need a big bodied defender. He is 25 and well over his injury - I'd hate to give him up but if the saints are keen on Fev then thats what may be needed to get it done.
I dont think Carlton can be overly demanding, they either accept something or get nothing. They couldn't play him if they didn't trade him, so they have painted themselves into a corner.
- Banned
- #923
Re: Roos keen on Fev...direct from a board member....
Carlton will get a late 1st rounder and a fringe player if they are lucky.
More likely a 2nd rounder and an ok player.
NO one is going to give you treasure for your trash.
Look at Aker. Same age as Fev is now when he was traded, a brownlow medalist and 3 time premiership player who did alot less to fall out with his club than Fev. He went for pick 33.
Look at Cousins, also a brownlow medalist, had a year out the game and some pretty bad history but is equal to or a beter player than Fev. He was taken last in the psd for minimum wage.
Fev comes with a $1.4million price tag, a bad on field attitude, will be 29 in a few weeks and has show no sign that he wil change his ways.
You really think you'll get pick 5 + players for a $1.4 mil timebomb, who isn't even a 100 goal forward despite being referred to as one on a constant basis ?
Carlton will get a late 1st rounder and a fringe player if they are lucky.
More likely a 2nd rounder and an ok player.
NO one is going to give you treasure for your trash.
Look at Aker. Same age as Fev is now when he was traded, a brownlow medalist and 3 time premiership player who did alot less to fall out with his club than Fev. He went for pick 33.
Look at Cousins, also a brownlow medalist, had a year out the game and some pretty bad history but is equal to or a beter player than Fev. He was taken last in the psd for minimum wage.
Fev comes with a $1.4million price tag, a bad on field attitude, will be 29 in a few weeks and has show no sign that he wil change his ways.
You really think you'll get pick 5 + players for a $1.4 mil timebomb, who isn't even a 100 goal forward despite being referred to as one on a constant basis ?
- Status
Similar threads
