murph4charlie
Debutant
1.
Judd - No question
2. Murphy - becoming elite
3. Jamison - structure
4. Gibbs- versatility
5. Kruezer - would play every week
6. Waite - versatility
7. Warnock -easily no1 ruck
8. Russell- pretty reliable -dodgy start to year though... slipping again.
9. Yarran- Slot him in anywhere
10. Garlett - more tricks than any other player on list
I know this is tough, and i'm not having a go at you, however IMO you have to have simpson - so consistent and so reliable (except that one kick that we won't mention) - week in week out he gives us everything.