First 10 picked

[murph4charlie]

1.
Judd - No question
2. Murphy - becoming elite
3. Jamison - structure
4. Gibbs- versatility
5. Kruezer - would play every week
6. Waite - versatility
7. Warnock -easily no1 ruck
8. Russell- pretty reliable -dodgy start to year though... slipping again.
9. Yarran- Slot him in anywhere
10. Garlett - more tricks than any other player on list

I know this is tough, and i'm not having a go at you, however IMO you have to have simpson - so consistent and so reliable (except that one kick that we won't mention) - week in week out he gives us everything.

 

[mattclape]

1. Judd
2. Murphy
3. Jamison
4. Garlett
5. Waite
6. Bower
7. Gibbs
8. Simpson
9. Russell
10. Scotland

 

[pansies]

1. Judd
2. Judd
3. Judd
4. Judd
5. Judd
6. Judd
7. Judd
8. Judd
9. Judd
10. Judd

We can dream can't we.

 

[Snoozer]

Going to take a different approach. Judd is easily our best player, but i think his absence can be covered now by Murphy and the other midfielders more easily than us losing a quality KPP.

1. Jamison
2. Judd
3. Kreuzer
4. Murphy
5. Waite
6. Gibbs
7. Simpson
8. Garlett
9. Bower
10. Curnow

Russell and Yarran unlucky.

Correct.

We lose Jamison we're stuffed. Midfielders, even as good as Judd - who would be a massive loss - however the burden can be carried by many others.

Jamison
Warnock
Waite (as infuriating, dumb and selfish as he is)
Judd
Murphy
Robinson
Scotland
Garlett
Simpson
Yarran

 

[Jamie007]

1.Judd
2.Murphy
3.Kreuzer
4.Warnock
5.Garlett
6.Jamison
7.Waite
8.Scotland
9.Yarran
10.Gibbs

FWIW I wouldnt have Simpson in our top 22..

 

[Jeremias]

FWIW I wouldnt have Simpson in our top 22..

On behalf of 99.9% of Carlton supporters around the globe - thank **** you aren't on the selection committee

 

[Sin City]

FWIW I wouldnt have Simpson in our top 22..

This will bring some interesting new facepalm and fail pics

 

[thylacine60]

Just what this place needs, Toadman, another First 10 Picked thread.

 

[gbatman]

Too dificult, here are my auto selections when fit. Hmmm turns out there are 22 of them.

Judd, Murphy, Jamison, Bower, Waite, Kreuzer, Warnock, Curnow, Garlett, Russell
Laidler, Betts, Simpson, Yarran, Garlett, Gibbs, Scotland, Duigan, Ellard, Robinson and Walker, Carrazzo

 

[murph4charlie]

Just what this place needs, Toadman, another First 10 Picked thread.

negative much? if you don't like the thread don't read it or comment on it

 

[Mister Carlton]

1. Aaron Joseph
2.Aaron Joseph
3.Aaron Joseph
4.Aaron Joseph
5. Aaron Joseph
6. Aaron Joseph
7. Aaron Joseph
8. Aaron Joseph
9. Aaron Joseph
10. Aaron Joseph

 

[Claypigeon]

Depends what you're after but for team structure, you'd need a:
Ruckman: Kreuzer
CHF: Waite
CHB: Bower
FB: Jamison
Judd: Judd
Midfielder: Murphy
Utility: Gibbs
Foward: Garlett
Mid defender:Russell
Plays for the jumper: Simpson

B4F had the right idea I think, so I've gone with a similar scenario:

FB Line: Michael Jamison
CHB Line: Paul Bower
Centre Line: Chris Judd
CHF Line: Jared Waite (Unlucky Garlett)
FF Line: Eddie Betts
Ruck: Robbie Warnock
Inside Runner: Marc Murphy
Outside Runner: Kade Simpson (Unlucky Scotland)
Defensive Runner: Bryce Gibbs (Unlucky Russell)
Versatility: Matty Kreuzer

 

[GoBlues!]

1. Judd
2. Jamison
3. Warnock
4. Murphy
5. Garlett
6. Waite
7. Gibbs
8. Kreuzer
9. Scotland
10. Yarran.

 

[Salt Lake Cities]

1. Judd
2. Murphy
3. Jamison
4. Kreuzer
5. Simpson
6. Waite
7. Garlett
8. Gibbs
9. Betts
10. Russell

Change Gibbs with Warnock and Betts with Yarran and that'll do me(yes couldn't be bothered thinking of 10 at this time of day)

 

[Beloved]

I've picked mine in terms of structure.

1. Chris Judd - can't go past him.
2. Michael Jamison - he makes our defence.
3. Matthew Kreuzer - a game is won and lost in the ruck.
4. Marc Murphy - key outside midfielder.
5. Bryce Gibbs - versatile tagger and ball-winner.
6. Jarrad Waite - can be used to shut down a power forward or kick 6.
7. Paul Bower - running defender with the ability to win one-on-one contests.
8. Kade Simpson - versatile midfielder that can go back or forward if need be.
9. Eddie Betts - goals win matches.
10. Jeff Garlett - as above.

 

[tubes82]

1. Judd
2. Murphy
3. Jamison
4. Kreuzer
5. Simpson
6. Gibbs
7. Warnock
8. Garlett
9. Waite
10. Yarran

 

[KoutoufidesGhost]

Judd
Jamison
Waite
Murphy
Gibbs
Simpson
Russell
Kreuzer
Betts
Garlett

 

[rp84]

1. Judd
2. Murphy
3. Jamison
4. Warnock
5. Gibbs
6. Waite
7. Russel
8. Garlett
9. Betts
10. Simpson

Kreuzer, Houlihan and Bower get no mention due to injury.

Curnow is pushing for top 10 already

Duigan and Laidler are not far off either.

 

[BluesMan]

Simpson is top 5

 

[Stamos]

1. Judd
2. Kreuzer
3. Jamison
4. Murphy
5. Waite
6. Gibbs
7. Simpson
8. Russell
9. Betts
10. Garlett

 

[Azzurro]

OKay, I've had a rethink:

1. Nicholls
2. Judd
3. Jesaulenko
4. Doull
5. Koutoufides
6. Silvagni (SOS)
7. Williams
8. Walls
9. Kernahan
10. Vallence

Most from watching games live and via replay, others by folk-lore

 

[HBF]

1. Judd
2. Jamison
3. Waite
4. Kreuzer
5. Yarran
6. Murphy
7. Garlett
8. Warnock
9. Simpson
10. Gibbs

 

[Big Sim]

1. Judd
2. Murphy
3. Jamo
4. Waite
5. Eddie
6. Yarran
7. Garlett
8. Warnock
9. Gibbs
10. Simpson

Geeze that was a lot harder than I thought it would be and I left out several who should be there. Our best 10 these days contains about 20. Good signs.

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

1. Judd
2. Kreuzer
3. Jamison
4. Waite
5. Murphy
6. Gibbs
7. Warnock
8. Bower
9. Betts
10. Simpson/ Walker

 

[The Big Sticks]

1. Jamison
2. Judd
3. Kreuzer
4. Simpson
5. Waite
6. Houlihan
7. Murphy
8. Gibbs
9. Yarran
10. Warnock