First club to 17 premierships?

[JayJ20]

Time to fire this thread up now that it seems Carlton and Essendon have awoken from their slumber.

Pies for mine.

I don't think we're anywhere near a premiership threat yet so its between Collingwood and Carlton. I'm going to go with Carlton.

 

[JayJ20]

Ok show me the 3 Grand Finals you won in the last 34 years then. I have you winning 2, drawing 1, and losing 4.

Who seriously cares?

How many flags have Richmond won since 1983? 3. How many have Collingwood won since 1983? Also 3. See what happens when an arbitrary timeframe is set?

Besides, many people on here wouldn't have been born for any of Richmond's pre-2017 flags so it's irrelevant.

 

[threesixpio]

Goalposts will be shifted by then and Carlton is the leader on 22 flags (for now)

Sure

 

[threesixpio]

Who seriously cares?

How many flags have Richmond won since 1983? 3. How many have Collingwood won since 1983? Also 3. See what happens when an arbitrary timeframe is set?

Besides, many people on here wouldn't have been born for any of Richmond's pre-2017 flags so it's irrelevant.

I was …and it’s ok that this is the case

 

[beerbandit]

Ok show me the 3 Grand Finals you won in the last 34 years then. I have you winning 2, drawing 1, and losing 4.

1990, 2010, 2023.

No one cares if you don’t rate 2010 GF Replay.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

1990, 2010, 2023.

No one cares if you don’t rate 2010 GF Replay.

I rate it.

It just wasn't a Grand Final, there is only one The Grand Final every year and that was played one week earlier and Collingwood did not win it. So when we talk about winning Grand Finals, no team won the Grand Final in 2010.

You obviously care enough about my thoughts to tell everyone you don't care about my thoughts. Dead give away.

 

[PerthBoy86]

Carlton in the box seat. This might be their best chance to push ahead again in the VFL flag race again.

 

[beerbandit]

I rate it.

It just wasn't a Grand Final, there is only one The Grand Final every year and that was played one week earlier and Collingwood did not win it. So when we talk about winning Grand Finals, no team won the Grand Final in 2010.

You obviously care enough about my thoughts to tell everyone you don't care about my thoughts. Dead give away.

Not really mate, it’s just a very obvious observation. I’m sure you’ve banged on about it in the past as well.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Not really mate, it’s just a very obvious observation. I’m sure you’ve banged on about it in the past as well.

Sometimes I find Collingwood supporters just need reminding that their beloved team has not been very good at winning Grand Finals. Always happy to oblige too. Don't mention it.

 

[Fadge]

Not really mate, it’s just a very obvious observation. I’m sure you’ve banged on about it in the past as well.

To be fair, he's done well to post as many times as he has in this thread without bringing Dustin Martin into the discussion.

I'm very proud of you, Meteoric Rise, you've shown great restraint.

 

[beerbandit]

Sometimes I find Collingwood supporters just need reminding that their beloved team has not been very good at winning Grand Finals. Always happy to oblige too. Don't mention it.

Seems you enjoy being a narcissist. Good for you, you must be winning in life.

And FWIW our Trophy cabinet is bigger and shinier then Richmonds.

 

[Monco Matt]

Collingwood.

Was that answer too short? Should I extrapolate?

Collingwood this season.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

“…you’ve got to be on the Blues now”!

Drew Prophet.

 

[Pistol Night]

“…you’ve got to be on the Blues now”!

Drew Prophet.

"Their pretty straight down the line, they dont talk in smoke and shadows behind the windows"

Travis Cloke.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Collingwood.

Was that answer too short? Should I extrapolate?

Collingwood this season.

There are only two problems I can see with that.

You have to make the Grand Final. Over the last 42 years Collingwood has managed to do that 7 times. So they would be a 1 in 6 chance to make the Grand Final. 16.66% chance.

AND

They have to win the Grand Final. Over the last 65 years Collingwood has managed to achieve that twice from 15 attempts. 13.33% chance.

Because Collingwood need to both make the Grand Final AND win the Grand Final this year to make your prediction dream come true, we multiply the 2 factors to arrive at the real chance of it happening.

2.22% possibility I am afraid Monco. Hey, that's better than nothing.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

"Their pretty straight down the line, they dont talk in smoke and shadows behind the windows"

Travis Cloke.

No doubt Travis was library monitor during his time at Collingwood.

I hear Maynard has picked up those reins - good luck to him!

 

[beerbandit]

There are only two problems I can see with that.

You have to make the Grand Final. Over the last 42 years Collingwood has managed to do that 7 times. So they would be a 1 in 6 chance to make the Grand Final. 16.66% chance.

AND

They have to win the Grand Final. Over the last 65 years Collingwood has managed to achieve that twice from 15 attempts. 13.33% chance.

Because Collingwood need to both make the Grand Final AND win the Grand Final this year to make your prediction dream come true, we multiply the 2 factors to arrive at the real chance of it happening.

2.22% possibility I am afraid Monco. Hey, that's better than nothing.

A young fella by the name of Nick Daicos is going to lift those percentages a little for you my friend.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

A young fella by the name of Nick Daicos is going to lift those percentages a little for you my friend.

His old man won more Copeland Trophies and he couldn't. Pretty sure his old man only slept with the light on sometimes as well.

 

[Pistol Night]

There are only two problems I can see with that.

You have to make the Grand Final. Over the last 42 years Collingwood has managed to do that 7 times. So they would be a 1 in 6 chance to make the Grand Final. 16.66% chance.

AND

They have to win the Grand Final. Over the last 65 years Collingwood has managed to achieve that twice from 15 attempts. 13.33% chance.

Because Collingwood need to both make the Grand Final AND win the Grand Final this year to make your prediction dream come true, we multiply the 2 factors to arrive at the real chance of it happening.

2.22% possibility I am afraid Monco. Hey, that's better than nothing.

This is the kind of logic that would of made Stephen Hawking get out of his wheelchair to shake your hand

 

[Pistol Night]

His old man won more Copeland Trophies and he couldn't. Pretty sure his old man only slept with the light on sometimes as well.

Daics prefers the lights on when he’s on the job

 

[Pistol Night]

No doubt Travis was library monitor during his time at Collingwood.

I hear Maynard has picked up those reins - good luck to him!

Maynard isn’t sure that a library is

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Daics prefers the lights on when he’s on the job

It would be nice to see someone do a Braynard on him and turn his lights out PN.

 

[Pistol Night]

It would be nice to see someone do a Braynard on him and turn his lights out PN.

Jesus whats Peter done? You’re a hard man

 

[beerbandit]

His old man won more Copeland Trophies and he couldn't. Pretty sure his old man only slept with the light on sometimes as well.

Well seems though you seem to be a percentage man. Nick Daicos is 1 from 1 at 100%

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Jesus whats Peter done? You’re a hard man

I was referring to Nick. Happy for his old man to mainly walk free, but it would be nice if he copped a bit of a slap for the 9 he kicked against the Tigers at feral park all those years ago.