Football Related Random Thread - PART 2

[Perrip]

 

[Section 5]

A bit of a mixture to finish off 2024.
A positive 2024 all round for the Brisbane Lions
AFL premiers
AFLW runners up
VFL PF loss

But no $1 million payday for McClelland trophy that went to the Hawks.
Hawks Lost SF in AFL, lost SF in AFLW. The VFL don't count towards the McClelland but the Hawks (Box Hill) loss in EF.

Just need to wait for the annual report.
A profit has been mentioned.
A decision pending (probably decided by now) to pay off all debt or show a better profit and put some funds back into BHA

On the Supporter base the largest city often comes out on top being Sydney.
The low North base plummeted even further by a huge 30.7%.

Looking at Brisbane compared to combined clubs from Perth and Adelaide:
Eagles + Perth combined in 2023 we were 296K behind them. In 2024 we made up ground and only 69k behind.
Crows + Port combined in 2023 we were 126k behind them. However, in 2024 we are now 69k in front.

Grand Finalists Sydney & Brisbane are the most widely supported AFL teams with over 1 million supporters each - Roy Morgan Research

For the first time both AFL Grand Finalists have over 1 million supporters with the Sydney Swans again topping the annual Roy Morgan AFL supporter ladder with 1,337,000 supporters.

www.roymorgan.com

 

[Section 5]

I thought i would see how Stats Insider rated the Lions players.
Stats Insider use short- and long-term data to arrive at a rating.
So not 2024 ratings as such. Cripps probably wins that.
There will be other lists, and they will not be the same as each use a different method.
The top 10

2025 SI AFL Player Ratings | Player Rankings

Get ahead of the game with Stats Insider's 2025 AFL Player Ratings. Discover comprehensive player rankings and stats to inform your footy predictions.

www.statsinsider.com.au

The PF teams from 2024
Lions had 6 in the top 50 and 8 in top 100 less Joe in 2025.
Swans had 4 top 50 and 7 in top 100.
Port had 4 top 50 and 5 top 100.
Cats had 5 top 50 and 8 top 100

 

[BuntonRules]

I thought i would see how Stats Insider rated the Lions players.
Stats Insider use short- and long-term data to arrive at a rating.
So not 2024 ratings as such. Cripps probably wins that.
There will be other lists, and they will not be the same as each use a different method.
The top 10

View attachment 2195296

2025 SI AFL Player Ratings | Player Rankings

Get ahead of the game with Stats Insider's 2025 AFL Player Ratings. Discover comprehensive player rankings and stats to inform your footy predictions.

www.statsinsider.com.au

The PF teams from 2024
Lions had 6 in the top 50 and 8 in top 100 less Joe in 2025.
Swans had 4 top 50 and 7 in top 100.
Port had 4 top 50 and 5 top 100.
Cats had 5 top 50 and 8 top 100

View attachment 2195280
View attachment 2195278
View attachment 2195276

Neale 1, Dunkley 36. Big gap. Says TEAM does it not?

 

[Pride of lions]

The highest paid player in the AFL rated at number 143 . Must be the greatest overpayment of a player in history. Another masterful pick up by Essendon

 

[Section 5]

The highest paid player in the AFL rated at number 143 . Must be the greatest overpayment of a player in history. Another masterful pick up by Essendon

That's Ben McKay.
Even when you isolate his position "key defender" he is 19th. Andrews is rated 3 behind Sicily and Wilkie.

 

[Section 5]

What ranking position do Lions players sit in each category.

Ruck: Oscar 4th behind Gawn
Midfield: Neale 1st
General Forward: Rayner 5th behind Rankine
Key Defender: Andrews 3rd behind Sicily
Key Forward: Joe 4th (Hippy next at 25th) behind J Cameron
General Defender: Wilmot 26th behind D. Houston

 

[Lace Out]

Hopefully Hipwood can get fit and move up to around 12-15.

 

[Lace Out]

What ranking position do Lions players sit in each category.

Ruck: Oscar 4th behind Gawn
Midfield: Neale 1st
General Forward: Rayner 5th behind Rankine
Key Defender: Andrews 3rd behind Sicily
Key Forward: Joe 4th (Hippy next at 25th) behind J Cameron
General Defender: Wilmot 26th behind D. Houston

What is Lester’s category and ranking ?

 

[Section 5]

What is Lester’s category and ranking ?

General defender 29th.
3KZ will not agree.
I think it would have included a few of his years he struggled to make the side

 

[BuntonRules]

General defender 29th.
3KZ will not agree.
I think it would have included a few of his years he struggled to make the side

What is the criteria?

 

[Section 5]

What is the criteria?

AFL Player Ratings​

Stats Insider has devised its own objective, data-driven AFL player ratings system to help footy fans understand who the best players in the competition are. The AFL player ratings system uses both short-term and long-term data to provide a dynamic rating system. At the completion of every game, Stats Insider collates votes, assesses performance and compares data to help evaluate AFL player rankings.

 

[martinson]

What is the criteria?

Who knows but just a couple of observations. We have only one player in the top 35 which you'd think is unusual for a team good enough to win the flag.

Scratching my head at the massive underestimation of Starcevich who has to be just about the best small defender going around. Certainly the best small lockdown defender.

 

[Section 5]

Surprised no one has mentioned the difference between Lohmann 35 games rank 137 and Ashcroft 31 games rank 213.

 

[Grasshopper17]

AFL Player Ratings​

Stats Insider has devised its own objective, data-driven AFL player ratings system to help footy fans understand who the best players in the competition are. The AFL player ratings system uses both short-term and long-term data to provide a dynamic rating system. At the completion of every game, Stats Insider collates votes, assesses performance and compares data to help evaluate AFL player rankings.

"collates votes"

 

[Section 5]

That looks like the AFL's special herbs and spices for free agency compensation

 

[Grasshopper17]

That looks like the AFL's special herbs and spices for free agency compensation

Yeah it's the leftovers.

 

[Section 5]

It looks like we have a new recruit in Logan Evans. Hopefully he can play 2nd or 3rd tall forward.

The player at all 18 AFL clubs that needs an enormous pre-season

Which player at your club needs a big pre-season?

www.sen.com.au

BRISBANE

Eric Hipwood
A pretty obvious choice this, a lot is going to rest on Eric Hipwood’s shoulders in 2025 following Joe Daniher’s retirement.
Ever since Daniher arrived in 2021, Hipwood has played second fiddle inside 50, but now he’s got to be the main tall target.
While he’ll be supported by the likes of Logan Evans, Charlie Cameron, Kai Lohmann, Zac Bailey and potentially even Sam Day, life is going to be very different for the 27-year-old against the opposition’s number-one defender.
If he can somewhat step into Daniher’s shoes and kick 45+ goals while competing well in the air, then the Lions are every chance of going back-to-back.
If he struggles without his tall partner and Brisbane no longer have a strong focal point inside 50, then it puts a huge dent in their premiership hopes.
There’s no doubt he’s got the talent to do it and 2025 could just be the making of the tall forward.

Lachlan Geleit

 

[KissKiss]

Who knows but just a couple of observations. We have only one player in the top 35 which you'd think is unusual for a team good enough to win the flag.

Scratching my head at the massive underestimation of Starcevich who has to be just about the best small defender going around. Certainly the best small lockdown defender.

Small lock down players don't tend to generate a lot of stats for these sort of ranking systems to work off - best way would be to see the statistical reduction in performance of their opposition. But that's too difficult for most systems.

Is there a minimum number of games for this one. As you would assume Lohman and Ashcroft are rising up the ranks a lot but have to over come the small sample before they pass more established players

 

[MSB ROYS]

I can believe this; as a regular drive from Sunshine Coast to Brisbane, it really is a shit show most of the time particularly on weekends in the wet coming to watch the Lions. Cant speak for other areas but regularly here how bad Brisbane traffic is from family and friends in other parts of the city

Glad I work from home now. I always found getting to work was mostly OK, but getting home in a reasonable time was a lottery. One incident at Greenslopes puts the city and southside in chaos.

 

[briztoon]

I can believe this; as a regular drive from Sunshine Coast to Brisbane, it really is a shit show most of the time particularly on weekends in the wet coming to watch the Lions. Cant speak for other areas but regularly here how bad Brisbane traffic is from family and friends in other parts of the city

View attachment 2200178

I call . I would need to see the list, but from my limited experience, Ho Chi Minh, Hanoi, Bangkok, Jakarta, Paris and London are all significantly worse. Along with the larger USA cities.

I would imagine quite a few cities in India and China are worse.

However, the one mitigating circumstance for many south East Asian cities is that, unless you have to travel for work, almost everything is available within one or two blocks of home, or within the local district.

 

[Grasshopper17]

I call . I would need to see the list, but from my limited experience, Ho Chi Minh, Hanoi, Bangkok, Jakarta, Paris and London are all significantly worse. Along with the larger USA cities.

I would imagine quite a few cities in India and China are worse.

However, the one mitigating circumstance for many south East Asian cities is that, unless you have to travel for work, almost everything is available within one or two blocks of home, or within the local district.

They couldn't have been using the Briztoon Index.

 

[briztoon]

They couldn't have been using the Briztoon Index.
View attachment 2200237

Ho Chi Minh has 8 million people living in a city, the quarter of the size of Brisbane, by area.

If you expanded out to the merging districts for an equal area of Brisbane, there are 16 million people.

It’s literally 10km from my family’s home in Thu Duc to District 1, and it’s near enough a 1hour Grab (uber) ride or an hour++ bus ride.

And they’re building the new international airport out at Long Thanh. Great for us, but that’s going to be close to a 2 hour ride from the airport to the tourist district in District 1.

 

[Section 5]

I quite enjoy watching this guys YouTube channel.
A video from 5 months ago so mentions Brisbane being 12th in 2023.

 

[MSB ROYS]

Brisbane worse traffic than Bangkok?