Game Day Gameday Thread - Essendon Bombers Vs Norf Melbin Roos - 12.08.23 at 1.45pm - Marvel Stadium

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

I'm just about out on Perkins for the year. Lots of running in place and no defensive effort at ground level.

Send him to VFL to work on some midfield craft ot something, but he isnt earning his spot.
Yep
Even if it takes 2 years, he needs to become some form of mid cos he aint a forward
 
Gets targeted 30 times and kicks 2 goals = "whoah in form!".
playing a role really. it's annoying that our forward 50 entries aren't a bit less predictable and/or that he is the only bloke over 195cm in the forward line. We have a first tall and a third tall but no second tall atm, predictable and easy to defend.

And then there's the concrete hands thing he's been going for lately
 
playing a role really. it's annoying that our forward 50 entries aren't a bit less predictable and/or that he is the only bloke over 195cm in the forward line. We have a first tall and a third tall but no second tall atm, predictable and easy to defend.

And then there's the concrete hands thing he's been going for lately
I don't mind the mix, I just want our forward line to create more space and to actually kick it to the space.

I dunno what's more annoying, dump kicking it on 2MP's head or them waltzing it out of our 50
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Kelly has not been the same since his concussion. He is not a good enough player to be avoiding contact.
I thought this too and who can blame him with the horror stories coming out. But he isn't talented enough to play without putting his body on the line.
 
playing a role really. it's annoying that our forward 50 entries aren't a bit less predictable and/or that he is the only bloke over 195cm in the forward line. We have a first tall and a third tall but no second tall atm, predictable and easy to defend.

And then there's the concrete hands thing he's been going for lately
We need a forward who can be described with more than "playing a role".
 
It's ultimate an issue of blokes you can trust with ball in hand.

We've only seen a bit of Baldwin, but I like him because when he has it, I feel relaxed that he's probably going to do something sensible with it. Like kick to one of our blokes. Handover to the running receiver in space. You know, footy stuff.

Too many others like Kelly, Hind etc. they go to kick or handball and you feel your soul sweating because you know it's even-money to land in the lap of the opposition or hit one of our blokes in the back of the head or something. They have their own benny hill soundtrack with ball in hand.
 
I don't mind the mix, I just want our forward line to create more space and to actually kick it to the space.

I dunno what's more annoying, dump kicking it on 2MP's head or them waltzing it out of our 50
I don't think you can describe an incompetent forward line that fails to create space or apply pressure, and then in the same breath claim it's a good mix of personnel.

The only way both can be true is if you think the players are so dumb that they can't do the bare minimum of basic forward craft with a sick coach. In which case I still wonder how you can be happy with dumb personnel...

Either there are absent players, dumb players, or incompetent players.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top