No Oppo Supporters General AFL and other clubs discussion thread. **Opposition fans not welcome** Part 2

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Richmond will win comfortably next week

Martin, Cotchin and Rance will have to really dominate for them to win easily. Guys like Prestia, Houli, Ellis and Caddy will also have to fire.

Jenkins will get shut down and don't think Tex will get much space against but Crows also have McGovern, Lynch and Betts who will probably snag a few between them.

At the other end, can't see Rioli repeating that performance and Talia will shut down Reiwoldt. Richmond don't have the firepower to match Adelaide.

Crows are a more balanced side who don't need their best 3 players to dominate to compete with the big boys.
 
Martin, Cotchin and Rance will have to really dominate for them to win easily. Guys like Prestia, Houli, Ellis and Caddy will also have to fire.

Jenkins will get shut down and don't think Tex will get much space against but Crows also have McGovern, Lynch and Betts who will probably snag a few between them.

At the other end, can't see Rioli repeating that performance and Talia will shut down Reiwoldt. Richmond don't have the firepower to match Adelaide.

Crows are a more balanced side who don't need their best 3 players to dominate to compete with the big boys.
What's stopping Rioli from repeating that performance? Riolis tend to go alright in Grand Finals.
 
Not fussed who wins - had my entertainment over the last three weeks, so good luck to both sides. Torn between Eddie and Dusty so just hoping for a good game.
 
Cotch and Ellis will get off. The MRP will manipulate the result or the Tigers will appeal and win.

I'm not advocating that guys can go out and belt each other during finals, but I'd like to see something like this.....

Unless it's intentional, then suspensions can be served in the new year?
 
What's stopping Rioli from repeating that performance? Riolis tend to go alright in Grand Finals.

Historically small forwards struggle in GFs (Cyril aside). Giants small defenders are pretty average as well.

To kick 4 goals in a GF is tough. In the past 10 years only the following players have achieved it:

Mooney
Stevie J x2
Chapman
Buddy
Roughie
Gunston x2

Some pretty impressive names on that list.
 
Not fussed who wins - had my entertainment over the last three weeks, so good luck to both sides. Torn between Eddie and Dusty so just hoping for a good game.

Same. I am content now that Cats and Swans are out of the running. Just please, please, please be a close match!
 
Adelaide will romp it in next week. They're equally as desperate as the Tigers (the sole reason Richmond has made it this far) but a billion times more talented and skillful. They are on a mission to win this flag for Phil Walsh and I shall salute them when they do, they've been the best team all year.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I was at the Game.....The Tiger fans are on a par for feral levels with the Pies



Are they or is it just that there are so many of them so it appears that they are worse than others. Every club has it ferals so we can't be dumping them all in the same basket
 
Historically small forwards struggle in GFs (Cyril aside). Giants small defenders are pretty average as well.

To kick 4 goals in a GF is tough. In the past 10 years only the following players have achieved it:

Mooney
Stevie J x2
Chapman
Buddy
Roughie
Gunston x2

Some pretty impressive names on that list.
Impressive names, I agree. None of them are Rioli. There is something...dare I say...special about that name. A couple of them have done ok on the big day. I don't know if he'll kick a bunch of goals, I just hope he brings the Rioli magic.
 
Cotch and Ellis will get off. The MRP will manipulate the result or the Tigers will appeal and win.

I'm not advocating that guys can go out and belt each other during finals, but I'd like to see something like this.....

Unless it's intentional, then suspensions can be served in the new year?
Biggest problem for Cotchin is that even if its deemed as a minor offence that only warrants a fine, he is automatically suspended for one week since it's his third offence. Same applied to Hodge this year. Based on other incidents this year it will be impossible for the MRP to let this one go particularly because it resulted with a concussion. I'm afraid he's gone
 
I am not necessarily convinced he has chosen to bump.......I can see how some come to that conclusion but I think he is protecting himself as he goes for the ball.

Absolutely just getting himself in the contest for the ball.... and what’s more, he wins it.

Will and should play in GF. Was terrific play. Hodge or Lewis like.




On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
If Cotchin isn't suspended the AFL rules are a farce. I don't think he should go for that, but it is a third offence... head is sacrosanct... he made head contact... if Cotchin is not suspended it's rigged pure and simple.
I tend to agree. I think the rule sucks, but as he goes for the ball he brings his arms into his body and rolls his shoulder into Shiels - probably in self defence. Had he kept his arms outstretched to get the ball I think he would be okay.

I hate the tribunal's inconsistency.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top