Good Call, Bad Call

[mollyfud]

Bad call. although depends what you call "work". Are the Pies one good assistant coach away from a flag ? No. Mick and Bucks have been together at the pies for many years without success, what has changed ? Nothing. Will their be infighting, backstabbing, dysfunctional off field happenings at the Pies? No.

Richmond will appoint Rawlings for 3 years soon.

Bad call.
1) No hurry as there isn't a great demand for Rawlings
2) Because of 1, they will go through the process
3) If he is successful, he will get a 2 year contract with an option for an extra 1 on reaching goals

For both the good of Richmond and Richo, tigers should trade Richo to a contender (i.e. Bulldogs) for draft picks (possibly late 1st rounder)?

 

[Anti-pow]

Bad call.
1) No hurry as there isn't a great demand for Rawlings
2) Because of 1, they will go through the process
3) If he is successful, he will get a 2 year contract with an option for an extra 1 on reaching goals

For both the good of Richmond and Richo, tigers should trade Richo to a contender (i.e. Bulldogs) for draft picks (possibly late 1st rounder)?

Bad call

Richo will play for Richmond next year or will retire. He has no desire to play for any other club!

 

[Reveler]

Richo will play for Richmond next year or will retire. He has no desire to play for any other club!

good call,

Nic Suban will get a nomination for the rising star in Round 19

 

[SouthSwans]

Bad Call.

Jesse White will get the nomination for the rising star in Round 19.

 

[StringyDog]

good call,

Nic Suban will get a nomination for the rising star in Round 19

Bad Call.

Jesse White will get the nomination for the rising star in Round 19.

Bad calls, calling for a nomination before a player has even played is just silly, even after they have played you can't pick it. There are quite a number of good young players that haven't received a nomination, including Ward who couldn't even get one when he had 33 posessions in a patch of 3-4 outstanding games.

The AFL still has its head in the sand about tanking, and Essendon being 1.25 favourites this week at Subi after losing to Richmond proves what is going on.

 

[Cosmo Kramer]

The AFL still has its head in the sand about tanking, and Essendon being 1.25 favourites this week at Subi after losing to Richmond proves what is going on.

Good call, the AFL have the homer simpson theory of 'if I don't see it it's not illegal', they choose not to see tanking hence it doesn't happen.

Karmichael Hunt is a brilliant signing for GC17?

 

[BarcaRulz]

Good call, the AFL have the homer simpson theory of 'if I don't see it it's not illegal', they choose not to see tanking hence it doesn't happen.

Karmichael Hunt is a brilliant signing for GC17?

Great call. Screw his footballing side, this SCREAMS publicity stunt. It'll be an added bonus if he can actually take the field and do well.

Masten will have a breakout year next season. Good call/Bad call?

 

[Richo83]

Great call. Screw his footballing side, this SCREAMS publicity stunt. It'll be an added bonus if he can actually take the field and do well.

Masten will have a breakout year next season. Good call/Bad call?

Good call. I rate Masten and it was a matter of time until he proved himself and got over injuries. Ditto Cotchin.

The era of bagging Richmond for picking Tambling should be over. Franklin is the better player but Tambling is good in his own right and has shown recently why he was picked so early.

Good call? Bad call? Terrible call?

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Good call. I rate Masten and it was a matter of time until he proved himself and got over injuries. Ditto Cotchin.

The era of bagging Richmond for picking Tambling should be over. Franklin is the better player but Tambling is good in his own right and has shown recently why he was picked so early.

Good call? Bad call? Terrible call?

More terrible than terrible call.
He has played a dozen good games in his career. He needs a few dozen more before the bagging stops.


There is to much money in local footy

 

[force65]

More terrible than terrible call.
He has played a dozen good games in his career. He needs a few dozen more before the bagging stops.


There is to much money in local footy

bad call

hitouts are an overrated stat

 

[BarcaRulz]

bad call

hitouts are an overrated stat

Good call. Hitouts to advantage on the other hand is an underrated one. Just because someone is 3 times as tall as you and can tap the ball doesn't mean anything.

Channel ten need to stop putting Kelli Underwood on. Good call/Bad call?

 

[that_dood]

Channel ten need to stop putting Kelli Underwood on. Good call/Bad call?

Good call. Worth a try and her play-by-play calling is not too bad, but her voice is just soooo bad and distracts from the game.

NRL players will start getting looked at by AFL teams after Hunt signed for the Coasters today.

 

[half back flank]

NRL players will start getting looked at by AFL teams after Hunt signed for the Coasters today.

Good call, with this move, more NRL players might want to try out.

John Longmire will coach North in 2010

 

[Cosmo Kramer]

Good call, with this move, more NRL players might want to try out.

John Longmire will coach North in 2010

Bad call, Damien Hardwick or Ken Hinkley would have to be in front at the moment and Longmire is unlikely to want to leave his job at Sydney where he is basically guaranteed the job once Roo's steps aside.

If Collingwood win the flag in 2011 they should still sack Mick Malthouse and put Buckley in as coach?

 

[robertg22]

Bad call, Damien Hardwick or Ken Hinkley would have to be in front at the moment and Longmire is unlikely to want to leave his job at Sydney where he is basically guaranteed the job once Roo's steps aside.

If Collingwood win the flag in 2011 they should still sack Mick Malthouse and put Buckley in as coach?

Bad call. No sackings will occur because it's written into his contract that he is stepping down as senior coach.

Essendon are a chance to lose this week to West Coast?

 

[mollyfud]

Bad call. No sackings will occur because it's written into his contract that he is stepping down as senior coach.

Essendon are a chance to lose this week to West Coast?

Good call (technically). Unless West Coast Forfeit the game the Bombers are chance to lose, its just an amazing small chance seeings that a) West Coast are crap b) there is the perception (real or not) that they are tanking. Prove the public wrong WC!

Hunts signing with the GC is another sign that the AFL have the expansion onto the Gold Coast and into West Sydney very very right?

 

[that_dood]

Hunts signing with the GC is another sign that the AFL have the expansion onto the Gold Coast and into West Sydney very very right?

Bad call Andrew D, very bad call. If you had left out the Western Sydney part then wonderful call. Western Sydney will have no support and is clearly the wrong move.

Tasmania deserve an AFL team over Western Sydney and their team would be more of a success.

 

[Rack Watts]

Bad call Andrew D, very bad call. If you had left out the Western Sydney part then wonderful call. Western Sydney will have no support and is clearly the wrong move.

Tasmania deserve an AFL team over Western Sydney and their team would be more of a success.

Good call, hopefully Western Sydney will completely boycot AFL due to the poaching of NRL players

Collingwood are peaking at a bad time and may miss a premiership window again?

 

[that_dood]

Collingwood are peaking at a bad time and may miss a premiership window again?

It has been a month and they are still winning so BAD CALL!!!

Matthew Lloyd played his last game of AFL football today.

 

[Torchy]

Good call, hopefully Western Sydney will completely boycot AFL due to the poaching of NRL players

Collingwood are peaking at a bad time and may miss a premiership window again?

bad call Caro....Collingwood have timed it perfectly

Beams could be somthing special

 

[SnowCool]

bad call Caro....Collingwood have timed it perfectly

Beams could be somthing special

Good call, hes a gem!

Melbourne will make finals next year

 

[Rabbit of Caerbannog]

Good call, hes a gem!

Melbourne will make finals next year

Premature call. 9-12.

Campbell Brown is a clean, fair and honest player that can call another player a sniper without being a laughably huge hypocrite.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Premature call. 9-12.

Campbell Brown is a clean, fair and honest player that can call another player a sniper without being a laughably huge hypocrite?

bad call. Browny gives as good as he gets which is why he is admired. Clean and dirty is subjective to the person watching

 

[Rioli magic]

Premature call. 9-12.

Campbell Brown is a clean, fair and honest player that can call another player a sniper without being a laughably huge hypocrite?

Bad Call, hypocritical call, Campbell can't call anyone a sniper.

Brett Burton took mark off the century on the weekend? Good call, Bad Call?

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Bad Call, hypocritical call, Campbell can't call anyone a sniper.

Brett Burton took mark off the century on the weekend? Good call, Bad Call?

bad call. whilst it was a good mark, his coming back from a knee injury has "improved" how it is ranked.

StKilda and Geelong will both fail to win the 2009 Grand Final. Good Call Bad Call