Good source: Gibson to Melbourne, Davey wants out of Dees

[WALL-e]

Fair reasoning there. It's not like you have any need for Tippett anyway - I reckon Watts will turn out just as well. You just need to be patient and give him time to develop.

...into a beautiful woman..

 

[Roosurgence]

Bit of hardness through the midfield now brock has done the burnout to Princes Park?

I honestly can't see it myself.

Maybe as I said either on this thread or elsewhere, what could work is you getting a young Hawker for 18, then Hawthorn giving us 18 for Gibbo.

Maybe Travis Tuck and Pick 25 and some swapping of picks for 18. Then 18 goes to us for Gibbo?

 

[Watt a gun!]

Gibson to Melbourne through a trade is ridiculous..not exactly filling any major list deficiency and not to mention completely out of character for bailey..trading two of melbournes best in johnstone and mclean for first rounders why we would we then give up a top 20 pick for some spud like gibson?

Over-rated and not worth it.

As for the Davey rumour, easily worth more than mclean which means a top 10 pick..whose going to be willing to give theirs up?

 

[SweetLeftFoot]

Gibson to Melbourne through a trade is ridiculous..not exactly filling any major list deficiency and not to mention completely out of character for bailey..trading two of melbournes best in johnstone and mclean for first rounders why we would we then give up a top 20 pick for some spud like gibson?

Over-rated and not worth it.

As for the Davey rumour, easily worth more than mclean which means a top 10 pick..whose going to be willing to give theirs up?

LOL. Gibbo would walk into your side and be in your best every week.

 

[yaco55]

Gibson to Melbourne through a trade is ridiculous..not exactly filling any major list deficiency and not to mention completely out of character for bailey..trading two of melbournes best in johnstone and mclean for first rounders why we would we then give up a top 20 pick for some spud like gibson?

Over-rated and not worth it.

As for the Davey rumour, easily worth more than mclean which means a top 10 pick..whose going to be willing to give theirs up?

The problem with this argument is that Carlton paid OVERS for Mclean.

 

[ScottishJarrod]

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,26120725-5012432,00.html
Davey is a Dee.........

 

[Deelighted]

That was a terrific source man.
A+ Thread!

 

[stabler]

...into a beautiful woman..

hey you're a funny guy, a regular akmal saleh.

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Looks like his sauce was wrong in Heinzsight. Try to ketchup with contract negotiations next time.

 

[Demonheart]

LOL. Gibbo would walk into your side and be in your best every week.

I agree, SLF, Gibson is much better than some of the comments floating around and he would be a good addition to our list. However we have more dire needs in other positions so I'd prefer to target other types of players.

If we ended up with Gibson I'd be very happy, but I wouldn't be happy to use any of our first 4 picks.

 

[Demonheart]

The problem with this argument is that Carlton paid OVERS for Mclean.

I agree, we've done extremely well to get pick 11, I just hope the deal gets done quickly in case Carlton come to their senses